Drama Recaps
Joseon X-Files: Episode 2
by | September 6, 2010 | 29 Comments

This is a really well-done drama. Suspenseful, taut, and wonderfully produced.

In addition to a story that intrigues, Joseon X-Files is really great to look at — love the pacing, the cinematography, the contrast of colors and light. It’s an example of a drama not just being pretty for the sake of pretty, but using every aspect — visuals, sounds, light, dark, even empty space — to serve the whole.


Casker – “말할 수 없는 이야기” (Unspeakable story) [ Download ]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

EPISODE 2: “Secret Light, Part 2”

In the forest, Hyung-do’s vision blurs from the drugged dart that has hit him, as the man in black steps forward to warn him to stop digging for info. With smoke wafting from his pipe, he tells him not speak a word of this — if he doesn’t listen, he risks his life.

Hyung-do and Officer Jang are tied up for questioning — and surprise of surprises, the man who steps in to face them is the Gangwon-do official he’d met in Episode 1. He warns Hyung-do to keep his mouth shut, as he’s been given the okay to kill him if necessary.

Furious and uncomprehending, Hyung-do demands to know who would give such an order. What are they hiding? He saw the empty village and the strange light flying around. There’s no way he’ll just back off now; he vows to find out the truth and right the false charge leveled against the governor, his teacher.

What a shock, then, to be told that the governor confessed to conspiracy.

Inexplicably, the official cuts the rope that binds Hyung-do, suggesting he help his teacher. Leaning in, he tells him he’ll allow him to escape, assuring him that he will not be held back. Go — and forget all this. (So it appears there is some sympathy after all, coming from one Gangwon-do official for another… or is there another reason?)

As promised, Hyung-do is allowed to leave, and he staggers out wearily. He drinks with Jang, who sees that he has fallen asleep and offers a few drunken words of advice, as the older hyung to his younger colleague:

Jang: “Even if what you say is right, if a hundred people say it’s not so, then it’s not so. It’s not that you’re wrong, but the important thing isn’t fact or truth, got it? What’s important is reality.”

Hyung-do’s eye opens in time to catch those words of counsel. In the morning, Jang awakens alone to find Hyung-do gone, with a note instructing Jang to hie himself back to Hanyang and deliver his message to an investigator with the police.

Meanwhile, Hyung-do races back to the mountain with five peaks, stopping short when he spies a gathering of masked men in the forest. He ducks out of view — and meets a man wielding a rifle.

This man is the lone resident still here from the mysteriously disappeared village — he’d gone out hunting, and come back to find a strange light. The ground trembled violently, and then the people were gone.

The man leads Hyung-do to a clearing in the woods where he saw the light. The man is intent to find his disappeared child, and becomes distracted by a fallen shoe. Hyung-do, on the other hand, is on alert for the small flying ball that hovers in the air above them — which then dives straight for them.

Driven by rage, the villager demands the light to return his child and fires a shot, which misses. Hyung-do defends himself with a club, though he is unable to connect with the flying ball.

And then, a big light.

Nearby, in a different clearing, the group of masked horsemen wait as a bright light shines down through the treetops from some source in the sky. Their purpose remains unclear, but their attentions are diverted by the sound of a nearby gunshot.

It’s been fired by the villager, who keeps shouting for the return of his child. Finally, the ball dives straight at him, and embeds into his chest.

Shooting electricity into the villager, the ball then detaches. With a big bang! it falls to the ground, now defunct, just a hunk of metal. The man collapses, dead, bearing a scorched mark on his chest; this explains the scorched dog in the previous episode.

At the sound of approaching horsemen, Hyung-do grabs the ball and hides.

The masked men find the dead man and carry his corpse away. The leader looks off into the distance toward Hyung-do’s hiding place; the latter sweats as his men approach. But the pipe-smoking leader — who seems aware of Hyung-do’s presence — orders his men to retreat.

Gulping a sigh of relief, Hyung-do makes his way out of the forest, where he sees a strange bluish light emanating from over the five peaks. He starts to climb.

Halfway up, a disembodied voice asks, “Must you see it?” It’s his teacher’s voice, but instead of being dissuaded, Hyung-do becomes more determined to find out what it is. Particularly when more small flying balls zoom through the air, passing him by on their way toward the big light.

Amidst growing shock as the balls whiz by, Hyung-do continues the steep climb, wondering if this is what his teacher had seen. As he nears the top, a rumbling, mechanical sound starts to grow and the light grows brighter.

A huge vessel rises from the mountaintop. At first it lifts slowly into the air, and then with a loud whoosh, it disappears.

Across the rocky terrain, our pipe-smoking man does his thing: observing Hyung-do and looking enigmatic.

As instructed, Jang delivers Hyung-do’s missive to the royal police; the message provides his account to back up what his teacher had seen. He appeals to them to reconsider the accusations leveled against the Gangwon-do governor.

Alas, this is naive of him. Instead, the minister to whom he appeals simply decrees, “We’ve got one more crazy man.”

Now Hyung-do is interrogated, and his sidekick Jang brought as a corroborating witness. He is asked to confirm the contents of Hyung-do’s account.

To Hyung-do’s shock, Jang disavows knowledge and stutters that he knows nothing. Jang hangs his head in cowardice as he suggests that perhaps Hyung-do mistook what he saw. (It’s a beautiful bit of acting on Jo Hee-bong’s part; he plays Jang with nuance as one torn between loyalty to his friend and abject fear for his life.)

Next, we are officially introduced to the pipe-smoking man, who joins the investigation. Hyung-do sputters in recognition, but is sharply told to mind his place — this is Ji Seung, who occupies one of the top government posts as the court’s financial officer.

Agitated, Hyung-do exclaims that Ji Seung also saw all this, but the official feigns ignorance: “Have we met?” The more heated Hyung-do grows, the more crazy he’s starting to seem as he insists that Ji Seung has a hand in this, and that a man’s life hangs in the balance.

Unperturbed, Ji Seung chuckles and calls him “an interesting fellow.”

The minister (of rites? — apparently this is Lee Yi-cheom) charges Hyung-do with plotting in league with the accused governor, who is currently imprisoned. The minister knows the truth, but he presents the situation as interpreted by the court: that the governor saw a comet in Gangwon-do but made up false claims of a monster in the sky, which agitated popular sentiment and therefore endangers national stability.

Moving in for the kill, the minister asks, “You want to live?” There’s one way for Hyung-do to settle public agitation, and success will enable him to protect himself and his teacher. The minister declares him the only suitable man for the task, because if he fails…well, Hyung-do’s life is already on the line. No extra risk. I’m starting to get the sense this minister’s a little unhinged, maybe. Crazy for power, and all that.

Hyung-do is released, but advised not to go far since he’s not a free man just yet. Jang hovers around the gates upon his release, and I find something very pathetic and stirring about how miserable he looks as he stammers out an apology for forsaking his friend. But Hyung-do tells him it’s all forgotten — and, repeating Jang’s words from earlier, reminds him that what’s important is reality.

Jang takes him to a place where he can get help for his secret task, and I think that the very fact that he was tipped off by someone at the police should raise his hackles.

Passing through a butcher’s shop, they find a bookshop — the one run by Yoon-yi, the mysterious woman who spied on Hyung-do previously.

She has been apprised of the situation and ushers him in, showing him drawings of his particular area of interest: strange flying objects. He asks if similar objects can be made, though he’s not in a situation to divulge why he needs them.

Thankfully Yoon-yi doesn’t press, and replies that she knows some weapon-makers who should know how to make such items. Hyung-do asks her to keep this matter secret, saying earnestly that a precious life hangs in the balance.

The weapons-making team gets to work, assisted by Yoon-yi. A metal ball is forged with holes that shine light from within, and once completed, the flying metal ball is prepared for launch.

As they ready the proceedings, Hyung-do wonders what kind of person Yoon-yi is, given what he knows about her: she’s privy to these mysterious books, and she knows how to make unusual weapons. It doesn’t add up.

Yoon-yi says that she can’t answer that question, but it’s not meant to be coy; she means it literally: “I can’t remember my past.” But she doesn’t elaborate.

Launch time approaches, and Hyung-do’s team waits for his signal. Across town, the minister also waits for the promised display.

Hyung-do orders the launch, and the fuse is lit on the metal ball, which is then loaded into a cannon. The force of the cannon propels the ball through the air, lit from within, and curious citizens look up as the ball of flame soars through the night sky.

Hyung-do looks upset with himself, or at the least conflicted over his actions. On the other hand, the minister appears satisfied, while the governor sees it from his prison cell with dismay.

The next day, a court herald announces to the populace that this was a testing of new artillery, as was the incident in Gangwon-do. This explanation seems reasonable, and appeases the people’s curiosity.

Hyung-do may not feel good about being part of this deception, but he is in a good mood because he believes his actions to have saved his teacher, per his agreement with the minister. Thus he is horrified — and confused — when Jang gives him the governor’s belongings, weeping that he is being executed by the court.

True enough, the minister has reneged on his word (or, perhaps cleverly maneuvered the situation so that Hyung-do acted according to his plan) and prepares to execute the governor. Hyung-do races there, but he’s too late: the deed is done and the body already laid out. His disbelief turning into anger, Hyung-do fixes his gaze on the duplicitous minister, and starts following him with dogged steps.

But it’s probably a good thing for his own sake that he is stopped. A drugged dart catches him in the neck, and we’re given a brief glimpse of a police officer behind him as Hyung-do falls.

When he awakens, he is in a room with Ji Seung, who tells him not to resent him — Hyung-do was about to attack the minister of rites.

Hyung-do can’t understand — he did what was asked of him! Why was the governor killed? Ji Seung replies, “It wasn’t what I wanted either, but I didn’t kill him. They were just governing by national law.”

As far as Hyung-do’s concerned there was no crime committed, but Ji Seung returns with the official line — that the governor purposely incited the public by making that fireball to confuse them.

Hyung-do bursts out that he was the one to do that, not his teacher. Ji Seung informs him, “For your sake, your teacher confessed that he did everything alone. He knew that both of you could not live.”

Ah, so now we understand why the governor looked saddened at the sight of the fireball — he realized that Hyung-do had sealed his own fate in trying to save him, and that the minister would have him exactly where he wanted him.

Ji Seung tells him that if he feels this is unfair, then write down everything he saw. Hyung-do doesn’t see the point of this exercise, but Ji Seung prompts him to comply. And so he writes.

When he finishes, he is instructed to fold the paper and put it in a cylindrical container, which Ji Seung then seals with wax. That accomplished, Ji Seung says, “Now nobody can see this.”

Er, what now? What’s the point in writing something that nobody will read?

Ji Seung answers that this is a vault of secret records: “Bizarre and mysterious incidents that nobody can explain. These are records that contain the truth,” but which cannot be revealed. (This is also where our drama gets its name; I’ll talk more about it below.)

This vault, however, differs from the official annals of history: “Far off in the future, when all of these things can be explained, they may become nothing.”

He explains that these records started back in the reign of Taejo — the first century A.D. — and is showing Hyung-do this “Because you must work for these records now.” By whose order? “The king.”

Apparently the king respects Hyung-do’s seriousness and adherence to rules, “although we were a bit worried.” That is a curious word — “we” — but Ji Seung merely says that Hyung-do will come to learn of it in time.

Now begins his double life — as government investigator, and as an employee of these X-Files.

Hyung-do declines harshly: “I have no wish to live for the sake of a truth that I cannot reveal to anybody.” Ji Seung counters that they aren’t revealing the truth for the sake of the royal dynasty, “but for history.” He asks, “Won’t a time come when our descendants accept this with gratitude?”

Hyung-do is not really given much of a choice, and he tries to come to grips with this new information as he heads to Yoon-yi’s bookshop carrying his teacher’s diary. He asks a favor of her — to keep his book in safekeeping, because he can’t keep it himself. She agrees.

Apologetically, he thanks her for her work in that “useless” errand of making the fireball. Yoon-yi demurs, saying simply, “It’s how I met you.”

Yoon-yi invites him to have some tea with her, and heads to stir the coals in their warming pot… where she drops the diary he just gave her.

Hyung-do doesn’t see her burning the book, but she does give the camera the creepiest stare as she does it, just in case you weren’t sure there was some major shiftiness going on. (I can’t even look at that screencap. She freaks me out. Enjoy!)

And then, Ji Seung steps inside the shop, which strikes him as odd. Hyung-do looks around with growing misgivings, starting to wonder if something is off here….


RUN AFTER THE BOOK! Go get your book back! Don’t trust the mysterious albeit pretty woman who is totally working behind your back for reasons which may or may not be nefarious but who in any case don’t deserve your trust!!

Regarding the title: Some of you may wonder why I’m calling this “Joseon X-Files” instead of the literal translation of the Korean title [기찰비록, Gichalbirok], which means (as Ji Seung explains) a secret record of events that cannot be explained. Which is basically what X-Files are. The word exists in our lexicon, so I figured I’d use it instead of going with an unwieldy literal translation.

I’m sort of in love with the look of this drama, which works so well with the skillfully built suspense. It’s sharp, and dark, and feels more like a film with its assured pacing than a drama series. Sure the actors are pretty to begin with, but the visual appeal is enhanced by the immediacy of the drama’s vibe, which is not quite raw but still a bit gritty.

Plus, the story is shaping up nicely, giving us hints of intrigue and mystery, but keeping things shadowy enough to pique our interest.

For example, there’s Yoon-yi and this shadowy secret organization, which is called Shinmuhwe. I know that Hyung-do’s a part of them now, but I’m not convinced that they’re all on the same side, particularly with Pipe-Smoker pulling his strings and Yoon-yi acting in accordance to higher orders. Perhaps Hyung-do hasn’t earned his place in the organization yet, but just because they’ve accepted him doesn’t mean they’re suddenly looking out for his interests. If I were Hyung-do, I’d be wary of trusting anyone, especially after even his sidekick turned on him.

One thing I really appreciate about this drama is that it doesn’t hit us over the head with its clues. Often, I feel like dramas underestimate their audience and set up clever clues, then point them out overtly to us as though they’re afraid we’d miss the point. Here, some details may evade us at first glance, but the fact that they are laid into the plot without fanfare is appreciated.

In fact, sometimes I don’t catch certain things until I go back and rewatch certain scenes. Usually I get everything in a first watch, but I’m finding it necessary to make a second pass to grab details I may have missed.

For example, there’s an officer who remains in the background, plot-wise, who is more significant than he appears on the surface. He’s a part of the royal police force, dressed in blue, and at first his actions make us think he’s against Hyung-do — he rips up his missive detailing his eyewitness accounts, and he’s the one who darts him at the execution. He’s also the one who gave Jang the tip sending them to Yoon-yi. Sketchy indeed. However, it appears he’s actually a part of Ji Seung’s secret organization, and if you go back to rewatch his scenes, what once seemed menacing could be reinterpreted as wary and watchful. It could be that he knew the greater picture and was trying to warn Hyung-do before he created bigger trouble for himself — but then again, the story might prove otherwise later. As I said, trust no one.


29 Comments from the Beanut Gallery
  1. birdscout

    Looks so good! Thanks for the recap, javabeans. KJH (noth THAT KJH) is looking great in his traditional outfit. Hope to watch this soon.

  2. YM

    Woah!!!…Last week when I watched this, I literally GASPED in horror as episode 2 ended!! I mean I love Kim Ji Hoon and watched it since it’s his last drama series for 2 years but, forrizle, I almost forgot he was even in there!!

  3. Ani

    “As I said, trust no one.”

    HAHAHA! Loved it! I haven’t seen this drama yet, but I grew up in the X-Files era, so I find this pretty interesting, especially the whole “WHo is my friend and who is my foe” aspect of it. Will be sure to watch it when I can. As for now, the recaps are much appreciated.

    • 3.1 Kiara

      Lol same…Next will be “The truth is out there” and “I want to believe”.

      Thank you so much for the recap JB:). <3

  4. asianromance

    you are amazing! Thank you for the recap!! that screencap of Yoon-yi is indeed, VERY CREEPY- but it makes me really want to watch the series for why she is being so mysterious and to know what’s up with Ji Seung.

  5. Amg1

    The waiting was completely worth it!
    I am really enjoying the passing of this drama and the fact that it is very well written, I just finished Episode 3 and all I can say is that it is getting better with each episode.
    I am pleasantly surprise by the over all quality of this show, I never would have guess that a Korean show could take this subject matter and make such an interesting show, Thank you again for your hard work!!!!

  6. Lemon

    Wowww. This story seems intense.

    It’s true that her stare freaked me out. Luckily I’m reading this recap in the morning! I probably won’t watch this though, because I’m quite a scaredy-cat. :S

  7. mimmay

    I’m absolutely enjoying this drama. I think KJH is doing such a wonderful job. The cast is just great, especially the pipe-smoking man. The only thing I hate is that it only airs once a week. I’m feeling so nostalgic because I used to wait every Friday night for The X-Files to come on.

  8. mskololia

    Thanks for the recap JB…I am enjoying this drama along with its secrets. 🙂

  9. sunshine

    I can’t really put my enjoyment of this show in words. It has an intriguing premise (sci-fi events in historical times). It’s beautifully shot. The characters are shrouded in mystery. It’s well-acted. I can say all of this, but I feel as if that doesn’t even begin to touch why I enjoy this show so much.

  10. 10 dramacafe

    Thanks for the recaps JB. I just love this series. It’s one of those very rare intelligent dramas that we just don’t wanna miss watching. Like what you said, I just enjoy how it doesn’t directly shove the clues to our faces, so it kinda feels like we the viewers are also in pursuit of the answers together with Hyungdo. Oh! And the pipe-smoking man definitely reminds me of the cigarette-smoking man in the X-Files.

  11. 11 Angela

    LOVING this series, and anxiously awaiting episode 3. Thanks so much for the recap!!

  12. 12 Knight Devil

    Thank you for your wonderful recap.

    Aside from the awesome camera work, I also like the soundtrack, which at times is reminiscent of the X-Files series.

  13. 13 rhea

    For a while there, I thought the girl was Jung Yumi, whom I adore. 🙂

    Kim Jihoon is a joy to watch. Even with limited facial expressions, he delivers. I would love to watch this if it comes out subbed.


  14. 14 hjkomo

    So glad to have another gem of a show to watch. Thank you, Cable! Kim Heung Dong needs more chances like this to give us quality dramas.

  15. 15 bandaid

    that screenshot was CREEPY. no kidding. Thanks so much for the recap! 😀

    i’m not a fan of SCi-fi series, but this one seems promising. 🙂

    BTW, we don’t have TvN here, so where can i watch this online? Thanks!

    • 15.1 mskololia

      You can watch subbed at viikii or dramacrazy.

      • 15.1.1 bandaid

        oh, thanks 😀

  16. 16 J.K.

    Oh my, nice format (finally something cinema-like instead of cardboard-studio-sitcom-like) and decent special effects (yes, computery gumiho tails were so erm computery). Oh my, finally… I’m so happy I lived to see this *sniffing into handkerchief*.
    Not to mention the acting is good.
    Thanks for the recap, I believe this thing is definitely worth seeing.

  17. 17 eclipse

    If you google it,you will find that there`s website who subs this drama online..

  18. 18 jiajia

    I suddenly have a random idea that maybe Yoon-yi, the mysterious lady who don’t remember her past may be from the future. That’s why she knows about the weird stuff happening but doesn’t remember how she got the knowledge? Since this drama is about X-files, traveling through time should’nt be an impossible idea don’t you think?

    Haha. just a random thought I want to share. NICE Re-cap! This drama is really well done. I esp like that screen cap where it shows Hyung-do’s silhouette when he was climbing the mountain (? or isit hill?). They made use of the light to create cool visuals. nice~ =)

  19. 19 taejo

    Why did the three major networks pass this gem up? Will they ever rebroadcast this on major stations? I know the rating is low because it is on cable, but I’m sure this series would do better than 3.5% if MBC is showing this series on its Wed-Thur night lineup.

  20. 20 Artemis

    Loving it a lot. It’s real quality on cable! I kind of wish it was more than 12 episodes, but I like the fact that the episodes are 45 minutes.

  21. 21 jojo

    Because of your excellent recaps/commentaries JB, you have peaked my interest in this series. I like KJH so I will give it a try. Was a fan of the X Files and believe a little scary stuff once in a while is good for you.

  22. 22 sang hee

    thanks a milln JB…i’ve been waiting for your recaps on this epis & i cldn’t agree w/you any better than that – this drama is well made & at times i felt like i was watching a Hollywood made proj., I agree the cinemat. is so good and of course not to mention my idol KJH’s acting which is so convincing indeed! need i say more about his dead gorgeous face? i always freeze the screen for his close ups, he’s an eye candy to the max! :)) luv him luv him

    thnx again JB – u’r da best!

  23. 23 sang hee

    JB me again i forgot to ask you, any idea of rating for this drama? it’s so good that i hope people in Korea & outside Kor. are watching this otherwise they don’t know what they’re missing!

    Thnx again for your ever excellent recaps! This drama as i said earlier is really good & production is well done! Kudos to them & the leads esp my KJH! :)))

  24. 24 Ally

    Wow, this is SO interesting. I just finished watching the second episode and I am completely and officially hooked.

    I’m still trying to figure out why she burned the book- it was a good source of info., so why not just put it with the other secret files? Why did the pipe-smoking man let her burn it?

    I guess the answers will come. I can’t wait!

    Thanks for the recap!

  25. 25 Bien

    Dramabeans! You’re one kick-ass Recap writer! You should

    get paid for this!! Hahaha! Never has it been that reading a

    Recap has been as interesting as watching the drama. I don’t

    know where you get the passion and the skill to put into

    detailed description everything that happens into the drama.

    And your comments have always been witty and quirky for

    me! So Funny!

    Just I appreciate your work so much, I haven’t watched

    Joseon X-files, but sometimes I feel, I’d rather wait and read

    your Recaps.

    Thank you so much!

  26. 26 Vicky

    Shooting electricity into the villager, the ball then detaches. With a big bang! it falls to the ground, now defunct, just a hunk of metal.

    the villager ACTUALLY MANAGED to shoot that ball while he was falling , without even looking up at the ball !!!! I know right ? It sounds impossible, but if you put that scene again, you will see that this is what really happened.What are the odds?!

Add a Comment

Stay civil, don't spoil, and don't feed the trolls! Read the commenting policy here.

 characters available. Comments will be truncated at the word limit.