Rating:
Average user rating 4.5
79

Extraordinary You: Episodes 1-2

You guys have NO idea how excited I am for this drama! It’s finally here, MBC’s anxiously-awaited Extraordinary You, which tells the story of a girl who learns that she’s not real – in fact, she’s only a character in a webtoon. The first episodes really deliver, with cute characters, clever execution, and a strange world that I can’t wait to learn more about.

  
EPISODE 1-2

We open on a wide shot of Seuli High School in Seoul. A girl steps out of a nice car — she’s our heroine, EUN DAN-OH (Kim Hye-yoon). She narrates, “There are a few things that always happen to a heroine. It’s her destiny to have hot guys obsess over her.” (Cue Designated Hot Guy asking why she’s not answering his calls.)

A soccer ball flies directly at Dan-oh, but she stops it with one delicate boot and ignores the handsome guy who asks her to kick it back to him. Next she runs into The Rebel, riding his obligatory motorcycle, and Dan-oh tells us that he’s definitely the male lead in the cast, though she doesn’t want to cave to his charms too easily. A girl bumps into him and takes off, and Dan-oh picks up the piggy keychain on the ground and gives it to Nam-ju, assuming it belongs to him.

A while later, Dan-oh is talking with a friend when all the girls start screaming that “A3” has arrived. A3 is the school’s version of the legendary F4, consisting of OH NAM-JU (Kim Young-dae), the “rebel,” BAEK KYUNG (Lee Jae-wook), the guy who’s been calling Dan-oh, and LEE DO-HWA (Jung Gun-joo), the soccer player and flirt of the trio.

They mostly ignore the fawning hoards of females, until a clumsy girl careens straight at them, carrying a box of art supplies. She crashes into Nam-ju and they both fall to the ground, landing in a very trope-y “accidental kiss” situation. Nam-ju looks stunned for a moment, then he complains that she ruined the art supplies, his uniform, and his face.

Dan-oh gently helps the clumsy girl to her feet and snaps at Nam-ju that he’s not special just because he’s a member of A3. He doesn’t look chastened, but Kyung stares at Dan-oh thoughtfully, and Do-hwa helps the girl pick up her dropped art supplies.

As Dan-oh storms off angrily, she experiences a couple of weird blips, where things around her go staticky and she hears a loud noise like a page turning. She turns around, and all the students in the hall behind her are standing perfectly frozen. The blip happens again, and just as Dan-oh is wondering what’s going on…

Dan-oh sits in her classroom, with her classmates all goofing off around her. To her surprise, a message on the chalkboard says that it’s the first day of midterms. By the look of her battered and highlighted workbook, she’s obviously studied, though she has no memory of it. She wonders if she’s having a dream, but pinching herself doesn’t wake her up.

There’s another blip, and now the message on the board declares that it’s the last day of midterms. Her classmates want to go out to celebrate, and when Dan-oh says they just started testing, her friend SOO-CHEOL (Kim Hyun-mok) jokes that she studied so hard she’s gone nuts. He’s excited that his recording of the girl crashing into Nam-ju has gotten a lot of “likes” online, but Dan-oh’s other close friend SAE-MI (Kim Ji-in) is upset that her beloved Nam-ju was so cruelly assaulted.

Worried for her sanity, Dan-oh asks her doctor if her memory loss is a side-effect of heart surgery she had in the past, or maybe the new drug she’s on. Doctor Lee (cameo by Yoon Jong-hoon) assures her that people don’t go suddenly crazy, and that it’s probably due to lack of sleep from studying, especially with her weak heart.

He advises Dan-oh to get more sleep and read fewer manhwas (Korean comic books), hee. He asks if Kyung is stressing her out, but she insists that the problem is with her mind. At home, Dan-oh searches online, but she can’t find any condition that matches with her symptoms.

On the way to school the next day, Kyung’s father (Choi Jin-ho) chastises Kyung for not going to the hospital with Dan-oh yesterday. Kyung is under orders to follow Dan-oh every time she goes to the hospital, since his father sees it as an opportunity to impress Dan-oh’s father. Kyung only says that he didn’t know Dan-oh was going, looking deeply uncomfortable.

He mentions her hospital visit to Dan-oh when she greets him, but she waves it away as simple stress. Kyung accuses her of being desperate for attention and getting his family involved, and he mentions the fact that they’re engaged, but he stops himself from saying anything else.

Dan-oh suddenly comes clean, telling Kyung about her spotty memory and how she’s hearing strange noises. Kyung tells her to just blame her heart condition like usual and walks away, leaving Dan-oh throwing a tiny adorable temper tantrum.

In class, Dan-oh tells Sae-mi about her weird symptoms, and how she lost her cool at Kyung. Sae-mi just tells Dan-oh to stop pretending because everyone at the school knows she likes Kyung. Then ~BLIP~ Dan-oh finds herself in her gym clothes, with no memory of how it happened. ~BLIP~ and she’s back in her school uniform, and there’s Baek Kyung swag all over her desk. What on earth??

Sae-mi explains that they’re making “love fridges” (hers is dedicated to Nam-ju), and when Dan-oh whines, “Why am I making this?” Sae-mi asks if something happened between her and Kyung. She says again that everyone knows Dan-oh likes Kyung, and Dan-oh thinks with horror, “Something is wrong with me…”

Over time, Dan-oh experiences more blips… sometimes time advances just a couple of hours, sometimes several days. She never knows whether in the hospital on an IV drip, standing in the middle of the street, or at school. She still thinks she’s having a problem with her memory, and worries that it seems to be getting worse.

In the school library, a male student contemplates a long scar in his left palm. He watches as Dan-oh pulls a few books from the shelves, then sits on the floor flipping through them, looking for information on her memory loss.

Dan-oh sees one book wobbling on the shelf, surrounded by tiny sparkles. She grabs it and watches as the letters in the title, “Secret,” move as if by magic. She shuffles the pages, on which seem to be manhwa panels, then she freezes as snippets of scenes run through her mind.

Kyung grabs her wrist, angry that she followed him… the clumsy girl is deliberately tripped in the lunchroom, and the students record it on their phones as Nam-ju helps her up. When her vision normalizes, Dan-oh steps back and trips over a pile of books, dropping the manhwa, and is caught by someone.

She turns to see Kyung, who accuses her angrily of following him to the library, just like in her vision. Dan-oh pulls out of his wrist-grab and escapes, and Kyung starts to follow her, but he’s stopped by a pretty girl named Ae-il, who asks how he’s endured Dan-oh’s “stalking” for ten years.

The boy with the scar, whose face we haven’t seen yet, shoulder-checks Kyung as he leaves the library. Kyung calls out an angry, “Hey!” and the boy turns around, but Kyung can’t read his nametag or see his features because of the bright backlighting.

Dan-oh dunks her head in the bathroom sink, and when she hears another page-turning noise that usually denotes a time blip, she yells, “Go ahead, erase my memory. Do it again!” Someone knocks from inside one of the bathroom stalls, calling out for help. Dan-oh removes the pen holding the door closed and lets out the clumsy girl who’s soaking wet and covered in leaves.

A package of wet wipes mysteriously appear in Dan-oh’s hand. She recognizes the clumsy girl as JOO-DA (Lee Na-eun), who’s new at their school and has been getting bullied regularly. She fusses over Joo-da, but wonders why, when she should be more concerned for herself.

Dan-oh stomps up to the school roof, seriously concerned for her sanity, especially her out-of-character fussing over Joo-da. Nam-ju is up there trying to nap, and he snaps at Dan-oh, asking if this is how she treats Kyung. Dan-oh just shoves him back inside the school and goes back to her worries.

The boys of A3 hang out together after school. Nam-ju tosses the piggy keychain on a table and grumbles that “she” is driving him crazy, but when Kyung tries to pick up the keychain, Nam-ju grabs it and barks that it’s his. He asks what Kyung thinks of “her,” and Kyung says she’s not his type, which calms Nam-ju down. He admits that he’s been thinking about “her” a lot.

Dan-oh is growing more concerned, now that she’s not just experiencing time skips but is also behaving strangely. She recalls the hallucination she had in the library, but realizes that a hallucination wouldn’t then actually happen in real life.

At lunch, a frighteningly made-up Sae-mi notes that the “Dried Squid Fairy” has made an appearance today, calling him the hidden fourth member of A3. All the girls squeal at the angelically handsome cafeteria worker, JIN MI-CHAE (Lee Tae-ri), who apparently only shows up on days when dried squid is served.

Mi-chae notices that Dan-oh seems down and serves her extra dried squid. She just says she can’t eat when she keeps losing her memory, and Mi-chae gives her an odd look. At the sight of the curry, Dan-oh remembers her second vision of Joo-da being tripped and her lunch tray going flying, splattering her and Dan-oh with curry. She mutters that she’d rather not get curry on her shirt, and Mi-chae shoots her another strange stare.

As they eat, Dan-oh asks Soo-cheol and Sae-mi what they’d do if they could see the future. Soo-cheol says he’d make videos billing himself as a prophet and become an online success, and Sae-mi says she’d win the lottery and buy Nam-ju an expensive bag. Dan-oh says she wants to prevent unfortunate mishaps.

Just then, the girls that Dan-oh saw tripping Joo-da surround the newcomer and start hassling her for being admitted to the school on a sponsorship from Nam-ju’s family’s foundation (wow, they’re just going full-on unabashed Boys Before Flowers, aren’t they?).

A teacher breaks up the bullying, but the girls don’t go far, and Dan-oh sees them exchange loaded glances. She exchanges her still-full lunch tray for Soo-cheol’s empty one, and when Joo-da stands, Dan-oh also stands and runs in front of her. She gets tripped, but unfortunately, Joo-da is also tripped and they both end up on the floor covered in curry, just like in her vision.

The students jump up to record the humiliating moment, and Dan-oh realizes that she can’t change what she’s seen. Nam-ju shows up right on cue and smashes one student’s phone. He steps forward and holds out a hand, exactly as Dan-oh remembers.

In class later, Dan-oh catches Nam-ju watching her, and he quickly looks away. Ignoring the lesson, Dan-oh wonders if she’s losing her memory because she can see the future. She asks to go to the nurse but instead stands in the hall trying to get another vision, but nothing she tries works.

The class can see her in the hall gesturing and yelling, so the teacher sends Kyung to take her to the nurse, since he’s her fiance and all. Dan-oh tells him to leave her alone, but Kyung says she’s got a weird way of having a crush on him. Dan-oh laughs at that, then nervously admits that he’s not wrong.

He turns away and she complains that he’s always rude to her. Kyung turns back and says that he doesn’t like a woman who’s ill, and that her crush on him is a waste of time because he’ll never return her feelings.

Later, outside on the catwalk, Dan-oh berates herself for not saying anything in that moment. She covers her face with her hands in embarrassment, and when she peeks through her fingers, she sees a shimmering circle in the air in front of her.

EPISODE 2

Dan-oh rubs her eyes, but the sparkling circle stays where it is. She notices that Mi-chae is standing underneath the circle staring up at it, but she looks away and when she looks back, he’s gone. Dan-oh goes to the cafeteria kitchen looking for Mi-chae, and LOL, he ducks behind the counter when she walks in.

Mi-chae pretends to have no idea what Dan-oh is talking about when she says that she saw him looking at the “black hole.” She insists on getting a straight answer, but he just says nothing good will come from her knowing. Dan-oh sees the “Secret” book on the counter, but Mi-chae sits on it to prevent her from grabbing it.

Dan-oh runs off (Mi-chae: “She’s more quick-witted than I thought…”) and heads to the library. The spot where she previously found the book is empty, but there’s a smaller black hole where it used to be. Dan-oh reaches out to touch it, and it nearly sucks her whole arm in before she yanks her hand back. She decides that it’s all connected — the black holes, the book, and “Dried Squid Fairy.”

She goes back to the kitchen, peeking in the windows, and when Mi-chae steps away, she sneaks in and grabs the book. The first thing she sees is a male character saying, “I don’t like a woman who’s ill. It’s annoying. You’re wasting your time having a crush on me” — the exact words that Kyung said to her earlier.

The male character even looks like Kyung, and the girl he’s talking to looks just like Dan-oh. Dan-oh drops the book in shock and sees more manhwa panels, this time depicting the situation in the bathroom between herself and Joo-da.

Mi-chae returns and picks up the book, and Dan-oh says that book is about her, but he just smirks and says she’s wrong. Dan-oh tells him that she’s been able to see the future ever since she touched the book, not to mention the black holes, so Mi-chae sits down and tells her the truth:

We aren’t humans. What you’re feeling is the gap between scenes. You didn’t fall asleep, but you’re living in the next day. You don’t remember coming to school, but you’re at school. A few days pass by in the blink of an eye. You wouldn’t usually feel it, but once you gain consciousness, you become aware of that gap. Then you think you’ve lost your memories. This is… the world of manhwas!

He finishes with a dramatic flourish, but Dan-oh calls him crazy. He jokes that he’ll live longer than the writer intended with all the insults he’s received today. Dan-oh tries to leave, but Mi-chae grabs her wrist and tells her in plain words that she’s a character in a manhwa.

She still doesn’t believe him, and she scurries away with Mi-chae trailing behind her, begging her to hear him out. He chases her all over campus until she finally stops on the catwalk, in danger of having a heart episode. Mi-chae holds her on the railing and asks if she’ll believe him if he pushes her over, assuring her that she’d be perfectly fine in the next scene.

Instead he drops Dan-oh’s phone over the edge, but it hangs in midair, surrounded by sparkles. Dan-oh calls to Sae-mi and Soo-cheol below that “Dried Squid” threatened to push her over the handrail and that her phone is floating. But suddenly Mi-chae is gone, her phone is in her hand, and Soo-cheol says she’s been with them this whole time.

Dan-oh goes to class and does her best to convince herself that she’s just gullible and has been reading too many manhwas lately. She asks herself out loud how that explains her seeing the future, and suddenly Sae-mi and Soo-cheol say the exact same things they said at lunch about what they’d do if they could see the future. Dan-oh realizes that she remembers them saying those things because she’s self-aware, which would mean that the rest of the students are not.

She finds Mi-chae and asks him how he made her phone float. He says again that this is the world of manhwas, but Dan-oh suggests that he drew the manhwa himself after watching her. In the middle of his denial, there’s another ~BLIP~ and Mi-chae is gone, but Nam-ju is approaching.

Sae-mi tells Dan-oh to push her in front of Nam-ju as he passes, so she does, but he just sidesteps Sae-mi and stops in front of Dan-oh. He offers her a chance to thank him, and she thinks he’s talking about helping her to her feet in the cafeteria. But she can’t force the words out, and Nam-ju walks away looking annoyed.

It’s back to the kitchen, where Mi-chae is reading the “Secret” manhwa. Over his shoulder Dan-oh reads the scene that just happened between herself and Nam-ju. She yanks at the book and rips out several pages, and Mi-chae tells her in annoyance, “Just accept it. You’re Eun Dan-oh, a character in a manhwa.”

Dan-oh shows Sae-mi the pages and tries to explain that they’re living in that manhwa world, and Soo-cheol repeats her words in a loud, mocking voice. The rest of the class tease her for reading too many manhwas when she’s in the hospital, and Dan-oh hides her face in her hands, then ~BLIP~ it’s a different day.

Sae-mi doesn’t remember anything about the manhwa pages, and when Dan-oh mentions them, it kicks off Soo-cheol again, and the class repeats their teasing word-for-word. Another ~BLIP~ and it’s a different day, and Dan-oh when asks Sae-mi if she can hear the page-turning noise, off we go for a third round of word-for-word teasing.

Dan-oh is still at school after dark, finally accepting that Mi-chae’s claim that they’re living in a manhwa world must be true. She goes home and looks through her photo albums, and she analyzes her character — she’s from a rich family, pretty, a good student, and has heart disease. On top of all that, she’s engaged to the guy she’s had a crush on for years. From all this, Dan-oh concludes that she must be the leading lady.

Dan-oh’s dad, CHAIRMAN EUN (Eom Hyo-seob), finds her moping in the kitchen, and she asks what he’d do if they were actually living in the world of manhwas. Playing along, Dad says that he’d want to be the main character because he could fix her heart. He says that it wouldn’t change the fact that he loves Dan-oh most in the world, awww.

Elsewhere, a mysterious person draws Dan-oh’s face. In the morning, Dan-oh decides that no matter what world she lives in, she’s still Eun Dan-oh, and she’s real.

When she gets to school, the way her classmates fawn over her just reinforces Dan-oh’s belief that she’s the main character in this romance manhwa. She witnesses Joo-da arriving at school and crashing into the bike rack, and she sighs at Joo-da’s unfortunate fate as the bullies’ target.

In class, the bully trio accuses Joo-da of stealing the wallet of their leader, Il-jin. Dan-oh watches as Il-jin slips her wallet into Joo-da’s backpack, so she stalks over and tells Il-jin that she saw everything. She makes Il-jin apologize to Joo-da, and she preens when Joo-da calls her pretty and kind, saying it’s just her role.

At recess, Dan-oh watches the boys, wondering one which is her leading man. She sees Do-hwa waving and assumes he’s flirting with her, then spots Kyung and Nam-ju both staring in her direction. All three of them head towards her… then walk right past her. She seethes at being ignored, but the guys just continue on, so Dan-oh clutches her chest and gracefully collapses.

She decides that whoever comes to her rescue must be her leading man, and we hear a guy’s voice call her name and sneakers running to her, but we don’t see who it is. After another ~BLIP~, Dan-oh wakes in a hospital room. Kyung is there, and he leaves annoyed when Dan-oh wakes up and asks where Nam-ju and Do-hwa are.

Frustrated and feeling mistreated as the main character, Dan-oh goes to the one person she can talk to — Dried Squid Mi-chae. She complains that she feels sick and asks how the main character can be so badly constructed with her weak heart and the way she’s mistreated by the guys. Mi-chae gives her a weird look, then slowly backs away from the ranting Dan-oh and disappears.

In home ec class the next day, Dan-oh wonders who to decorate her cake for, ruling out Nam-ju, who already has enough girls chasing him around. When she’s finished, Sae-mi assumes it’s for Kyung, but Dan-oh loudly denies it. Sae-mi whines that she’s liked Kyung for ten years, but Dan-oh says that was before she was self-aware.

Do-hwa comes into the classroom and praises Dan-oh’s cake, saying that he loves chocolate. Kyung snaps that it’s probably not for Do-hwa, and Nam-ju says pointedly that he loves cake. Dan-oh tells them primly that she hasn’t decided who to give her cake to, and she asks them to pinky-promise that her decision won’t break up their friendship.

The guys just look at her like she’s lost her mind, ha. Outside the classroom, the mystery boy watches Dan-oh talking to A3 about her cake.

Outside, Dan-oh helps Joo-da carry some heavy bags, then she hears the sound of a page being turned and realizes that something is about to happen. A crowd forms around her and Joo-da as one of the three male bullies orders Joo-da to carry his backpack.

Dan-oh senses that her male lead is about to show up and rescue her, and Nam-ju shows up on his motorcycle right on cue. Dan-oh is a bit disappointed that her leading man isn’t that jerk Kyung, but she’s okay with it being Nam-ju, since he’s also handsome and the top dog of the school.

The bullies tell Nam-ju that they’re making her pay for being rude to him, but Nam-ju growls, “Who said you could do that?” He approaches Dan-oh and Joo-da, and Dan-oh prepares herself for her big romantic moment, though she finds that she can’t step towards Nam-ju like she wants to do.

He comes close… then pulls Joo-da to his side. Facing the crowd, he says, “I hate when someone touches something that’s mine.” Suddenly, lights shine down on Nam-ju and Joo-da, as Nam-ju says, “Did you hear? You’ll be my errand girl from now on, Yeo Joo-da.”

Shocked, Dan-oh realizes that all the times she thought Nam-ju was staring at her, he was actually staring past her at Joo-da. When he said he was giving her a chance to thank him and Dan-oh couldn’t speak, it was because he was talking to Joo-da, who was standing behind her. And when he said he likes cake, he was looking directly at Joo-da.

Dan-oh finally understands that Nam-ju is the male lead — in fact, his name means “leading man.” And she’s just heard Joo-da’s full name for the first time, “Yeo Joo-da,” which means “heroine.” Nam-ju and Joo-da are actually the romantic leads in the manhwa of Dan-oh’s life… and Dan-oh is just a minor supporting character.

In the library, the mystery boy looks out the window at the crowd gathered around Nam-ju and Joo-da. In his hand is a sketchbook, with a drawing of Dan-oh.

  
COMMENTS

This may just be one of the cutest drama premieres ever. I pretty much loved everything about it — the characters, the world-building, and especially the clever way Dan-oh slowly discovered the truth about her reality and her place in it. There are a lot of mysteries to solve, and the girl at the center of them all has just learned that not only is she not the leading lady, she’s not even an important character in the story. How Dan-oh will react to this disappointing discovery is going to be a lot of fun.

There’s been a lot of hype leading up to Extraordinary You (otherwise known in its manhwa form as “July Found by Chance”), and the ratings for this first episode were pretty high, so I went in with very high hopes that this show would be everything it’s promised to be. And I’m happy to say that in my opinion, it’s starting out to be every bit as cute and clever as promised. I know very little about the manhwa except that it’s still unfinished, so the writer of Extraordinary You has stated that they will be creating an ending that will likely deviate from the manhwa itself, out of necessity.

I love that the story-within-the-story is a blatant rip-off of Boys Before Flowers, with its middle class heroine landing in an exclusive school and running afoul of the resident Top Dog and his lackeys. Besides offering a lot of opportunity for meta jokes, this also means that the background action is familiar enough that we can focus on side character Dan-oh’s problems and still easily keep up with the “real” leads. It’s also fun how such a dated story lets this version positively wallow in old-fashioned tropes (how many wrist-grabs can they cram into one episode?) and familiar character stereotypes, and we can just laugh at them instead of being annoyed. The fun will be in watching Dan-oh, and hopefully her friends if she can convince them of the truth, break out of these tropes as they navigate their strange reality.

We are all the “main character” in our own life, but in a manhwa, that’s not true for everyone. Dan-oh’s “time skips” are a phenomenon caused by the fact that she only exists in scenes where one of the major characters is doing something, and her memory loss is really just the fact that she doesn’t exist between those times. I’ve never thought about the minor characters in stories I’ve read, but now I have to wonder… do they know they’re not the main character? Do they have lives outside of their contribution to the main storyline? Why has Dan-oh suddenly become self-aware when the rest of the students are still trapped in the manhwa’s narrative? And how does Mi-chae know the truth?

My only disappointment with the premiere of Extraordinary You is that we didn’t get to officially meet Dan-oh’s leading man yet, but I’m sure we’ll see him soon. He’s very mysterious, and that scar on his hand hints at something dark and twisty, which makes me wonder if he’s just another clueless background character or if he knows something, like Mi-chae does. I actually hope that our mystery man does know how their world works, because right now, Mi-chae is my favorite character simply because he’s so enigmatic and elusive (and Lee Tae-ri has been a personal favorite ever since I first saw him in Rooftop Prince). I would love to see Dan-oh’s love interest in on the secret of “Secret,” and watch as the two of them navigate this strange reality.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , ,

79

Required fields are marked *

I'm staying for Dan Oh's reaction to drama/comic tropes. She's the voice of drama watchers. Hahaha 😆

20
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap @lollypip!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

She is one of us, she is a beanie!!! Voice of our frustrations. :)

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap!!

I had to admit, I wasn’t feeling the first few minutes of the show, but the second half had won me over.

I have read the webtoon prior to seeing episode 1, so I knew what I was going into but omg, I found myself shipping Dan Oh with Nam Joo for a second there when she thought the manhwa world revolved around her! I was like oh no, does Nam Joo have “secret” crush on Dan Oh and is only forced to like Ju Da???? And then the reveal at the end was sooooo hilarious! Girl, Dan Oh is sooo delusional and I fell into her trap fast 😂😂😂😂😂 I love her so much.

I didn’t like that they changed the original title, but, now I love the title a lot!!! It’s poking fun at our wonderful extra heroine. Extraordinary You Eun Da Oh! 😍😍

Also ratings - sadly pilot episode rating was abysmal. Since it’s an MBC drama, 3.5% is horrible. K-Netz loved Kim Hye Yoon and this drama though and there’s so much buzz online, so hopefully TV ratings will rise!

9
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

high school dramas usually don't get really high ratings (moment of 18 was an exception) especially if they're more fluffy and comedic, so I wasn't too surprised with the ratings. but still disappointed, because this drama definitely deserves more!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"extraordinary" is a smart pun because Dan-Oh found out she's just an ordinary extra in a manhwa. ;)

7
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

😂😂😂 ordinary extra - cracking up so much. Dan Oh is not going to like this one bit.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

In a show with a slightly W-like premise, they need to give mystery-guy a face before we start calling him No-Face :)

10
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The pilot was amazing! I have so many questions (those who've read the webtoon, don't spoil me please) and I think Dan-oh forgot to ask the Lee Tae-ri the BIG questions: Since when has he been self-aware? How does he know so much? Does he know why she's/they're self-aware? What happens to them when the manga ends? GOSH

12
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

In Westworld, self-awareness developed in certain bots, because they were pre-programmed by their creator. This drama reminded me a lot of Westworld.

Gosh is the word. I think it has to do with the nameless guy. Who is he? Why is he nameless? Is he the creator of the manga? If so, how did he get in?

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm just as excited too lollypip! Love loved loved the first two episodes.! I was dying to see Rowoons face, but the direction was such that if Danoh didn't see him viewers couldn't either. It was all shot brilliantly.

13
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love the way they shot Rowoon's face, always in shadow and silhouette. He is like the very minor extra who in the webtoon probably doesn't even have a face, and it reflected in the way Dan-oh and other characters couldn't see or remember his face properly.

12
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

yeah the way it was shot was gorgeous and added an extra mystery to his character. it's really interesting the way his character doesn't appear right from the start as he is a main character in the drama, but since he is an extra in the webtoon, not having him introduced straight away adds to the meta which i really really love

11
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same! Took the words right out of my mouth. I want to shake WWW's director & show him this is how you use light & halos twit.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

So beautifully done, the light bouncing off his face. I almost died in ep 2, btw.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

So did I errand candy, so did I.

2

Wow, it's fun! I can't believe how much fun I was having while watching this. I love delusional Eun Dan-oh and all her antics. I was half expecting her to break down in existensial crisis after the Fairy dropped the bomb about her true identity. It's great that instead, she chose to bask in the glow of being a heroine in a romantic youth story. I love how she can enjoy herself and her situation. Her rant about "candy" and her supposedly pitiful and too nice character just added an extra dash of meta and awareness that made me love her even more.

17
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I adore her. The strongest, most sarcastic heroine ever, sassy and in your face.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

This was a fun premiere with a spunky female lead to carry the show. The premise is fresh and youthful. Can’t wait to see haru

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Having read the webtoon i was laughing so hard watching Dan-oh thinking that she was the main character, and the ending when she finds out that she's just a supporting character was hilarious. Everything about the first 2 episodes was perfect for me, I was not disappointed at all. The meta is the best part of the drama, especially when Dan-oh curses at the writers for her characterisation.

Kim Hye-yoon is killing it, I can watch this girl for hours. The cast is wonderful, there are a few new faces but they're all doing a great job!

13
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am so in love with Oh Nam-joo. Lee Na-eun is stunning. I want to watch their story -- the cliché most popular boy in school falling for the poor, bullied girl. When the girls were tripped and drenched in curry, I had a fleeting thought that maybe Nam-joo helped Joo-da up, but I had an epiphany in the middle of their baking cakes. The reason Nam-joo borrowed Dan-oh's whipped cream was because Joo-da was standing next to her! Then it hit me that Joo-da bumped into Nam-joo in front of his motorcycle, so it must be her pig keychain that he was thinking about, and he was really staring at Joo-da who sits next to Dan-oh.

In Nam-joo's "I'll give you a chance to thank me" scene in the manhwa, I wondered why Dan-oh did not recognize Joo-da's character since she saw their characters in the bathroom scene and saw her character in Kyung's scene, but I realized the manhwa obscured Joo-da's face. Kyung is such a dick. Dan-oh doesn't even act like she likes him when she found herself making a Baek Kyung love refrigerator.

I can't wait to meet our mystery boy to find out if he is also self-aware or if the manhwa writer wrote his character to like Dan-oh. Thanks a bunch for the recap, @LollyPip!

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Omg. You mentioned the cake scene. It made my heart flutter. I am in love with Nam joo. Can we have him fall for Danoh? No? Because she treats him with disdain...lol like the way she treats Kyung. She treats all the guys with this air of pained superiority, it cracks me up...and her best friend is a bully, but she's so funny...Danoh is in the rich b*tches clique, allright, like BoF, except that she's just So. Nice. I hate to see her being made a pawn for The Greater Good. It hurts. And that's why this drama is so amazing. It makes me feel all these feels...I thought my heart died when Hyun bin faded to black in Alhambra...this drama has brought it back to life, so yayyyy!!

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dan oh is so funny! She loves the cliche story when she thinks she's a heroine but wheb she realizes she's just an extra she said it's childish and sworn the plot story :)))

I can't wait to watch how dan oh and rowoon's character will make a love line. Hope that ratings will rise on their next episode

5
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I LOVE that this drama is not taking itself serious at all ....

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

After watching the first episode I went on to bing the manhwa and it was totally worth it!

I think reading it has made me more excited for the drama, especially since they said the ending is gonna be different!

They did shift things around a bit, especially with Danoh's character herself, but she still has that signature determination so that's okay. I'll grow to like her. Can't wait for the other characters to become self-aware and for the appearance of no. 13!

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I’m totally fine with Dan Oh being extra (no pun intended......) hyper, high pitched, and eccentric in this drama. It’s easier to tell whether she’s in heads or tails because she’s different from her heads character. But then again, her Tails thoughts are really outspoken too in the webtoon. One of my favourites still remains when she calls Haru her hot pink hehe.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hello, may I ask where you read the webtoon? I only managed to read season 1 of the webtoon... have to pay for season 2 but the website doesn't let me pay haha

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hello, I wanted to ask if the drama is corny? I liked it based on the recap and have decided to watch it, but I don't like corny dramas. In the recap, it was compared to BOTF and I never liked that drama, I'll be more than happy if someone who had watched the drama could help m, thank you ^_^

1
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I would say more witty than corny - anytime there's a moment that could be even a little corny, the show makes good of it!

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you. If so, I would like the show actually :)

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It is actually somehow making fun of BOF and is quite witty. Pretty great as of now.

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It is brilliant and satiric, it pokes fun at all the drama troupes.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Then it's a fun drama, thank you ^_^

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

wtf is BOTF

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Boys Over Flowers

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This was a great first episode. I wasn't bored for a minute!

I love the energy of the heroine and how she's ready to take control of her life. She's so funny! She's a new kind of FL!

The casting is great. All the actors seem to come from a manga. I really liked how they filmed the scenes, it's beautiful, the places, the lights, etc.

5
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is like those rare few rom coms where i actually find the pacing fast enough for me like the story isn't being dragged at all compared to many other shows if they can keep this pace up im totally in for the ride

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

A breezy, easy watch. Such a confident premiere! EVeryone clearly knows what direction they're heading for and what they're doing and I love LOVE Dan Oh. Her disappearing into the background and ghost mouthing when she realised who the leads were nearly killed me, I was laughing so hard (after midnight, natch) .

If this had been released earlier this year, I would have written a 'Hey! It's me' about Dan Oh (the eternal sidekick determined to live her own life- it's in my drafts but there wasn't a character I felt I fitted....until now!)

Just thoroughly, thoroughly charming and I look forward to discussing this all with you!

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lol her soul leaving her body after the reveal is soo funny. I still crack up and I lost count on how many times I’ve seen it already!

Dan Oh is definitely a “hey it’s me” character. She came out a month later too bad.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

oh my God thank you sm. I was waiting for this 😘😘😘😘

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The brilliance of this show is that we can't even judge all the other comic book characters for being shallow or annoying as of yet, because they literally just are shallow comic book characters and until they also become self aware, they will remain that way lol.

19
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I know! You can tell the writer of the webtoon must really despise lazy writing by the way she's picking manwha tropes apart.

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, she clearly has a bone to pick haha. I'm quite apprehensive about if they can keep this up but there's only one way to find out: wait and see

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

There is that, but let's be brave!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Maybe we are all in a comic. We are all characters on a stage. @ally-le had a blackout on Open Thread. She will be the first to be self-aware. *STARES*

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

All the world’s a stage,
And all the men and women merely players;
They have their exits and their entrances;
And one man in his time plays many parts,
His acts being seven ages. At first the infant,
Mewling and puking in the nurse’s arms;
And then the whining school-boy, with his satchel
And shining morning face, creeping like snail
Unwillingly to school. And then the lover,
Sighing like furnace, with a woeful ballad
Made to his mistress’ eyebrow. Then a soldier,
Full of strange oaths, and bearded like the pard,
Jealous in honour, sudden and quick in quarrel,
Seeking the bubble reputation
Even in the cannon’s mouth. And then the justice,
In fair round belly with good capon lin’d,
With eyes severe and beard of formal cut,
Full of wise saws and modern instances;
And so he plays his part. The sixth age shifts
Into the lean and slipper’d pantaloon,
With spectacles on nose and pouch on side;
His youthful hose, well sav’d, a world too wide
For his shrunk shank; and his big manly voice,
Turning again toward childish treble, pipes
And whistles in his sound. Last scene of all,
That ends this strange eventful history,
Is second childishness and mere oblivion;
Sans teeth, sans eyes, sans taste, sans everything.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

*Claps* Brilliant!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

This premier topped Tale of Nokdu for me. It was such a breezy fun watch but at the same time it's also very smart. The BOF parody right off the bat had me lol-ing. I am a little worried about how they'd fill the rest of the episodes since so much content was given right away but hopefully they'll keep the sidekick narrative for long because Dan Oh's dialogues were hilarious and made me pity secondary characters.

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is the best premiere I've seen in a long time - even Be Melodramatic, which I love with my whole heart and soul, did not captivate me to this extent straight away. Dan-oh is filled with so much personality and just rules the screen, I love her to pieces already. Possibly my favourite thing is that normally, when a premiere jumps straight into the story (say, Suspicious Partner), I feel like I haven't had a chance to get to know anyone yet. That wasn't the case here. I'm so excited for next week!

5
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I had not heard of this drama at all & I started it just to see the gifs of DanOh I saw on the fanwall. I expected a typical BOF teen drama. It was such a pleasant surprise. I absolutely LOVE DanOh she’s hilarious. She’s so funny & I love how she embraced her leading role character.

I also really really missed puppy, it’s good to see LJW again even if he’s kind of a jerk.

I have already watched ep3 & 4 & it’s just as good as these one I hope it goes on like this.

6
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Whoa, read the recap, this show sounds so unusual. A sort of a twist on W. I can't imagine where this will go, but it sounds interesting.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This wasn't even on my radar but turned out to be by far the most compelling of the fall shows. DanOh=love.

6
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am so excited you are recapping this, @lollypip. I am squealing like a Candy Girl!!!! *SQUEALING CUTELY*

Ten Reasons Why I adore this show

1. Our heroine...she's the spunkiest, zaniest, most foul-mouthed, most irreverent, most jaded heroine ever. I LOVE HER TO BITS!!!

2. The directing. It's sharp, and smooth, and the editing is spot on. No awkward pauses, no pained dragged on smiles that linger a little too long. Everything just breezed along. I couldn't believe it when it ended...it was too short for me.

3. The tongue-in-cheek lines, the rolling eyes, the snarky remarks at the cheesiness between the leads by our Sentient Heroine.

4. The crackling chemistry between the Cold Fiance and Our Heroine. Has a scowl ever looked more divine? I'm crushing on him, help...and he's a jerk. I ADORE JERKS!!!!

5. The cheesy BoF Candy plot...omg, my heart fluttered...that Candy guy was ABSOLUTELY DEVASTATING I ADORE HIM!!!!

6. The humour was laugh out loud...the zappy sound when the scenes changed, the switch to a new scene, the repeat dialogues every time she tried to make her own scene..just crazy funny.

7. The heartbreak...I felt my heart break for her being cast into the shadows...

8. I hate the Candy Girl with a vengeance...I felt very sad because I had thought our heroine had a love line with the Candy Hero...but it turns out I'm wrong.

9. It has brilliant similarities with MY own drama. Ahem. Errand Boy Girl has suddenly morphed into an actual drama. Talk about coincidences.

10. I love the freshness of the plot. I love that there are two stories in the drama, and the Candy Girl drama is as rivetting as the Drama behind the scenes.

What is going to happen next?

I predict

1. Jerk Fiance will fall for Our Heroine.
2. All the guys will fall for her.
3. Something bad may happen to her...no, please, no.

7
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Be open minded, don't folllow your predicitons. Just be open minded so you wont be dissappinted, i wasnt but you might.
Just know that this drama will be amazing

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Right. Keep expectations low. Way to go. 😁😁😁😁

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Such an entertaining show! The lead actress is really cute and she seems really energetic (all that running around has to be tiring for her!) The boys are a little annoying, I only like the blonde guy, Lee Tae ri.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dont worry. none of them are the lead. The boys will get better and hopefully the drama would just keep on getting better and better

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

thanks for the recap/insight...am not familiar with this show or the manhwa but this recap is making this so interesting:-) thank you

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved loved this premiere. Happy to see all the beanie love.

Kim Hye Yoon is just nailing this role. Her self aware exuberance is just too good and am rooting for her .
The whole BoF main plot is so ridiculous yet so funny. I died laughing. A3? Really.

Amidst all this am so happy to see Lee Jae Wook. With a earring to boot.

Am reading the comic and I don’t mind if the show goes in a different direction. The manghwa itself is well done and makes for an interesting read.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Indeed Amazing 3! And I love how their name is in reference to a paper size too. This writer is so witty.

I def do not mind the changes here and there especially it if meant a whole lot of crackfest for us. Hoping this drama keeps its momentum.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I can't even tell when was the last time I enjoyed a K-drama this much. Everything works about it. I love how confident the female lead is and I am also a sucker for protective love interests. I just caught myself today, thinking about the drama and theorizing. I didn't see that name reveal coming, I was flabbergasted haha

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I KNOW I KNOW I AM LATE (real life took over) BUT EXTRAORDINARY YOU is a FUN ADAPTATION! I like the changes and I like how fast paced the first episode was because the world building and introductions are FUN(ny)! I probably watched the first episode 8 times already (seriously) and the BTS clips whenever I need a break from papers and college.

6
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

ITS DAMN AMAZING THAT IM CRYING. This is just as I expected, THIS SERIOUSLY DID JUSTICE TO THE MANHWA LIKE T.T Im so happy that im literally crying right now.
Kim Hye Hyoon literally nailed Danoh. Everyone suits the charavcters. The author mustbe crying tears of joy rn. This is literally bomb.

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

YAY, thanks for the recap @lollypip! This drama is so refreshing. I was sucked in instantly. I didn't know much about the show or webtoon going in to this, so everything was exciting. This first ep did a great job of setting up the world and characters quickly, but in a way that was still gripping and clear.

I was not expecting the twist at the end that Dan Oh is a side character. They really did a good job of making me think she was the lead! Overall I was really impressed with this breath of fresh air and already cannot wait for next week's episodes!

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Why is there a copy of the manhwa book inside its own manhwa? 🤔
Anyway yay for another school drama added to my favorites! I love the extra main character Dan Oh. It's my first time watching the actress. She's really good. I recognize the manhwa heroine and female bestfriend from webdramas, nerd classmate as the nerd programmer and Kyung as Marco in MOA and of course Lee Tae-ri from TMTETS.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Think guy with scar on hand is Baek Kyung whom I suspect is abused by his father. Lead played by that guy from SF has no scar in his hand

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

He is Kim Rowoon from Sf9. Same company with Jung Haein

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

she is too cute to handle. i wish i had her as a lil sister hahaha

i'm waiting on 4 eps, but i hope even tho it's cutesy it's enough to keep my attention the story seems dynamic enough. ty for the recap, i will come back to it!

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks LollyPip for the recap!
I loved every second of the show 😊
It's just what I needed, especially when Melo ended...

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Forgot to say that one of my favourite moments was when the pack of wipes appears out of nowhere in Danoh's hand. I was there with Danoh with "what?" "how?" "from where?"... and then laughing like crazy 😁

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm really liking this as well and the subtle hints that Dan oh's supposed fiance also seems to be awakening in some ways. Having had my fill of destined lovers in drama, I like the idea of an anti-fated romance.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Is it anti-fated though? He seems to be drawing her and keeps showing up to save her.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

OMG this show and its heroine is so extraordinary. Love how they spin all the swoony tropes in rom-coms into this hilarious not-so-cliche manhwa-like drama. All the puns, from the show's title to the character names, are so clever.

I found Dan-Oh reactions understadably natural. But Mr.Squiddy is quite fishy at the moment. How much does he know? How does he feel about it? And the mystery 'real' leading man is so mysterious. I'm so hooked.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Since this is the show that makes fun of all cliche tropes of shojo manga, a twist will be much appreciated... like the heroine that turns out to fall for Dan Oh all this time because of her kindness.... That would be the best twist everrr....

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks @lollypip for recapping this show!

I am hoping this to deliver what W: Two Worlds couldn’t in terms of a satisfactory ending and am cautiously optimistic as it is based on a webtoon. I was wondering whether the webtoon concluded. I wonder what they mean by “they will be creating an ending that will likely deviate from the manhwa itself, out of necessity”. The fun but also the anxiety of the show is in wondering what a happy ending for characters in a manhwa would entail!

My main questions after Episode 1 were: Why do some characters gain consciousness? And what will make Dan Oh be able to act as she feels rather than as it’s written for her? The premonitions seem to have started with her touching the book but what started her awareness? I wonder whether the holes she is seeing are portals to the real world (a la W)?

I saw the title of the show written as “(Extra-ordinary You)” in my subs and in the light of Dan Oh’s discovery that she is an extra the title makes so much sense now. She is not supposed to be “extraordinary” but “extra ordinary”, making her an extra rather than the main character of the story.

I found the whole references to F4 through the A3 absolutely hilarious. I love how the show made fun of Boys Before Flowers.

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lollypip, thank you for the recap.
What a treat ! Kim Hye-Yoon is wonderful as Dan-oh. The director is doing a great job. The show is fast, light and funny. Looking forward to future episodes and recaps. Squee !

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didn't watch this when it aired last week for fear of loving the show and waiting for the new episodes. And here I am, couldn't resist. I love it! Hye-yoon is killing the role as Dan Oh! *off to rewatch the 4eps while waiting*

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved the premiere of this drama and so far I have enjoyed all the episodes. Unfortunately, due to the lack of time, it wasn't until today that I was able to read the recap and comment on it.
Thank you so much @lollypip for your insights.☺️

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *