I finished my rewatch of A Gentleman’s Dignity a few days ago and watching I’ll Find You on a Beautiful Day made me have some final thoughts on Yoon/Meahri.

1
5

    I have always said that I’m not one who minds age gaps–even large one. Noona romances are my most treasured catnip for pities sake, so that was never my dislike with the Yoon/Meahri romance. My issue with that romance stemmed from the fact that Meahri had no personality outside of “loving” Yoon. In the first ep before she’s ever on screen (she doesn’t show up until the next ep, or even the ep after that. I don’t quite remember) she calls YiSoo and tells her to tell Yoon the next time that she sees him that she (Meahri) has gotten really pretty. Not anything about her as a person—just that she’s attractive now.
    Every time we see Meahri after this she’s either a) begging Yoon to love her or b) begging whoever she’s in the scene with to tell her something about Yoon/Pass something on too Yoon. Even if the other character has something bigger going on in their storytline, it will get touched on briefly so that she can go on obsessing over her “oppa”.
    She’s told separately by her brother and by Yoon and I think even by YiSoo in her capacity as friend/former teacher that if she really wants to be with Yoon–a 41 year old man with his own law firm, who is settled in his life–she needs to work on herself and bring something more to the table than being pretty and being the daughter of a wealthy family. He’s wealthy enough on his own and if he just wanted “pretty” he could have had that a dozen times over. In spite of this–in spite of being told this by her object of affection himself, she never takes it to heart. Instead she bursts into tears and sobs about how much she loves him and how she literally can’t focus on anything else to do or be anything else because she loves him so much and that maybe she’ll work on herself after they get together but until that happens–she can’t do anything.
    Yoon has a scene after the two of them get together were he takes his wedding ring to the memorial site for his wife and he leaves it there. He seems so lost and heartbroken, but he says that he’s determined to follow this path to the end. He apologizes to his dead wife and says that he’s determined to be with that child. Every single character on that drama refers to her, often as a child. Not in a mean or insulting way, but as a fact. She’s 24 by the time drama ends but for all intents, purposes and actions she’s a child. She feels more organic in the long lost son plot than she does as the love interest in her own story.
    What does this have to do with the lovely I’ll Find You on a Beautiful Day? Actually, not much. But I was looking at the character Hwi. I love her. I love her vivaciousness, her energy. She’s kind and encouraging and loyal and confident and a bit bratty, a lot sassy and an all the way around great character. We see her interact with–I’m blanking on his name (of course I am) but Eun Seob’s friend, YW (I think, I’ll just call him that for this post whether its right or not). And even though he’s a solid decade older than h

    2
    1

      her he doesn’t treat her like a child.
      I’m in no way shipping them —let me repeat that in case someone does read this and tries to take me out of context, I am in no way shipping Hwi and YW but if in a few years after she grows up–maybe. Maybe she goes to college in Seol, and she goes to visit her old friend/her big brothers old friend to bug him for free food. And they do what they always do. Laugh and tease, talk about books and their meanings. Maybe they have an offshoot of the Goodnight Book Club that starts out just the two of them, or she goes over, taking a break from classes and friends once a week and the two of them facetime the rest of the group so that they still are part of the club. And over the years they find themselves falling in love. I wouldn’t be mad at it. Why? Because even though he’s known her her entire life (like Yoon/Meahri) and he watched her make the transition from child to teen to adult, she’s not treated as a child.
      In the Goodnight Book Club everyone from the tiny little boy (who’s name I sure as shoot do not know) to the older ahjummas is treated as an equal. Their opinions aren’t looked down on or shoved aside because they come from someone younger.
      Maybe its a flaw in the writing for Yoon/Meahri that their coming together has never, not once made sense to me. Not even in a “kind of if you squint your eyes and tilt your head”. At most I think that they should have had a torrid, sexy love affair. But Yoon respected her brother too much for that. And I don’t think he was attracted to her, at all. I’m not saying that A drama that came out over a decade ago that is completely tonally different from this one should have showed them in a bookclub together. But, what I do think is, looking at Hwi’s character, and her interactions with the people who are older than her–I could easily see a man like 41 year old Yoon falling for Hwi. I could see him resisting it with everything in him because (and I’ll say she’s 24 like Meahri, because to say it with her being all of what? 16? Now is super squicky) she’s so much younger, because she’s his friends little sister. But not being able to resist being drawn to her because she’s so awesome.
      All of this to say that I didn’t ship Meahri/Yoon because of the age gap. I didn’t ship them because Meahri sucks as a character. But if Meahri had been written the way that Hwi is—it would have been a different story.

      3
      3

        Even though I haven’t watched a gentleman’s dignity I can follow your reasoning and kinda agree with them! Wouldn’t mind if these two get together sometime in the future when Hwi is in uni or doing a job and has seen the world!! But like you said THATS NOT TO SAY I SHIP THEM!!

        2
        0

        I loved ‘ A Gentleman’s Dignity’ and I wholeheartedly agree with you. Earlier this year, I’d started a rewatch of the drama but stopped at the 3rd episode because of school. I’ll go pick it up again.
        Hwi is honestly my favorite character in ‘I’ll go to you when the weather is nice’. It makes me so happy watching Kim Hwanhee continuously grow as an actress.

        2
        0

        I totally agree with you.
        I’ve already told you that even if I loved the drama, I didn’t like the Meahri – Yoon part at all.
        I always had the feeling Meahri just wanted to married Yoon because she wanted to get married to him, but not because she loved him. She doesn’t even love herself as she only sees her as pretty, wealthy and young. She gets him by insisting. I never thought those two could ever be happy together, and that made me really sad, because Yoon deserved much better.

        As for Hwi, she’s a girl turning into a woman. She has her own personality, she relates to other as equals and she knows her place on Earth is not to be a vase of flowers to be admired. She is a gem, and she knows it. And she’s loved and she loves herself. And what’s more important, she makes her happiness depend on her.
        If only there were more Hwis in this world and Mearhri…

        1
        0