egads tells you to read a book: Post #2

Admittedly, I don’t read nearly as much as I used to. Likely the biggest blame for this lies with the glut and ease of streaming media. However, two other contenders have done their damage. First, returning to school to study literature, linguistics, and writing left me with little time for recreational reading. (And truthfully, it’s now difficult to turn off the analytic reading muscles and just enjoy the story.) Second, I got older, and when you get older your eyes get older, which means you might not be able to read in bed without your glasses like you used to, or worse, your progressive lenses mean you need to position the book just so in front of your face, which means you can’t lie comfortably and read like you had done since you could first hold a book on your own. I would tell you to not get older, but that doesn’t seem like a good recommendation.

So, in order to bring up my yearly completed books count, I’ve made an effort to be more mindful of the time I spend reading and to decrease the amount of time spent mindlessly watching shows that I’m not actively enjoying. This is not to say that I’m giving up dramas (yeah, no, that’s not happening), I’m just giving up watching the bad, the boring, and the rage inducing, while also trying to return to books. But truthfully, sometimes books can be bad, boring, and rage inducing, and I’m learning to let go of those too. By now, you all have either drifted away or are wondering if I’ll ever get to the book recommendation. I will. Here we go.

This week’s recommendation is the newest novel by Lisa See, The Island of Sea Women. I’ve been a fan of See’s work for years, but I think this is her most compelling novel in a while, and it appears that she has done some fairly deep historical digging in order to write about a particularly difficult period in Korean history.

The Island of Sea Women takes us to Jeju Island during the Japanese occupation, through World War II and the aftermath, and weaves in events during the year 2008. The haenyeo, the women divers, of Jeju Island harvest seafood to provide food and income for their families, and the novel gives us the first-person account of the diver Young-sook through her childhood, haenyeo training, marriage, and more.

As she does in most of her novels, See centers the novel on a friendship between two women. Here we have Young-sook and her childhood companion and friend Mi-ja. They learn to dive together, they go on lucrative assignments to the freezing waters Vladivostok, Russia together, and they marry and have their first children at nearly the same time. But just as colonial forces and war brutalize the Korean people and nation, so do they have lasting effects on the lives and relationship of the two women.

I don’t want to give spoilers, but if anyone has even a passing curiosity about Korea during the Japanese occupation and the aftermath of World War II, this book will reveal many of the day to day trials Korean citizens, especially the women, endured as they worked to keep their families fed and safe. I found the minutiae of the haenyeo craft fascinating, and learning the sheer physical and psychological toll this job entails, I’m even more boggled by their strength and courage. Add in the pressures of patriarchal cultural norms, subsistence living, war, and other challenges, and honestly, I’m floored.

One thing to note, this is not a light-hearted read. Not that it’s a dirge, but See does not romanticize the dangers the haenyeo face each time they dive, nor does she shy away from the cruel viciousness of occupation and war. (Warning: I was listening to the audio book in a public space when something particularly shocking and brutal happened, and I quite embarrassingly burst into tears.)

While not a perfect novel (I found the ending somewhat rushed and too emotionally “perfect.” Hmm, where have we seen that before?), I do think it’s one that should be read by those that do not understand the very deep scars embedding Korean society. Not only does See delve into the wounds caused by outside forces, but she also does not shy away from the corruption and violence Korea inflicted on its own people.

I also think, that you, as sophisticated drama watchers, will be able to see the cultural implications of the novel’s plot and characters that the average reader does not. Again, let me know what you think and if you have any recommendations of your own.

19
32

    Well, I guess I got a bit wordy. Sorry.

    1
    1

    I’ve been looking forward to your next recommendation! This sounds really interesting. I’ll have to see if my library has it.

    2
    0

    OK. This is interesting. You exactly write about me who have forgotten how to read books because of drama. As same as you, l am trying to back to reading and I start with history since I like golden age of middle east history. I might digging in korean history as historical drama is my favourite.

    I am looking forward for your next recommendation.

    1
    0

    I also have stopped reading more or less. Too much going on in my life. Dramas take so much less effort. But I don’t like that I’ve become more of a viewer than a reader. So thank you for this recommendation. I just ordered it from the library. I don’t promise to read it, but I’ll look it over and give it a try.

    1
    1

      OK, I have it and I’ve read the beginning. I also peeked through the rest of the book. I like it. I like that it’s as much about strong women and women’s friendship as it is about the suffering that occurred under the Japanese occupation. Thanks, @egads.

      1
      0

    Thank you for a good book review @egads. Like you I love to read, but I can’t read as long as I used to – old eyes…
    I’ve think that I’ve read other books by Lisa See, but when I looked up the list, I didn’t recognize any.
    With that, however I saw this book previously and have wanted to read it. Your recommendation seals it.
    “Daughters of the Dragon” by William Andrews is also REALLY good but it is a hard read. The story is about a Korean adoptee going to SK to search for her birth mother, and instead finding her grandmother who was a Comfort Woman in WWII.
    The author did a great deal of research and just so happens to have an adopted daughter from Korea.
    A good book is hard to put down and I’ll add your recommendation to my audible book list.
    thanks!

    3
    2

      Thanks for the recommendation. Really the eyes have been the most annoying thing about getting old.

      2
      1

        For me it’s too much looking at screens – on my phone, iPad and laptop… And my eyes get dry then blurry.
        When I try to sit and read a book I get sleepy.
        aging is certainly not for weaklings is it?

        2
        1

      Daughters of the Dragon was only 99¢ for Kindle, so I have it downloaded and am gonna start it soon. Thanks

      1
      1

        I think that’s what I paid. But it’s worth it. He has another book, but it isn’t 99 cents.

        0
        0

    I’m loving your recs Egads! And I don’t think it was wordy at all:) I’ve been getting back to reading this year and hearing more audiobooks as well, so I always love a good recommendation since my library is not well stocked, but I can always get a book put on hold and sent over. I’m actually reading one of Lisa See’s books: Peony In Love. So far it is very interesting and I just want to read more about this time period in China and all the writing the ladies did during the transition in power. I still can’t with foot binding though, man, women always have it rough!

    1
    3

      Peony in Love is probably my favorite Lisa See novel. The foot binding….man, she really evokes the reality of that and how it affected them physically for the rest of their lives.

      I think that’s why I like her books so much because these are the details of women’s lives we don’t get in the history books, and yet they have major cultural ramifications. This is also true of the haenyeo.

      2
      1

      Audiobooks is what helps me get books read anymore. I listen to them while working in my garden. However when the book is good I get caught up in it and don’t stop working for hours and then can’t move my back for days.
      Peony in Love is on my shelf – but I can’t remember if I read it. Oh well….
      Like the rest of you beanies here I’m not reading as much as I used to – but I’ve always loved books about and by Asian authors. We should come up with a list.

      2
      2

        I love audiobooks. That you can read and do all sorts of other things at the same time is great. Do you use Audible? I’ve also used some of my credits for a few of the Great Coursed they have, and have really enjoyed those too.

        2
        1

          I do use Audible. In fact I was a member of Audible before they were acquired by Amazon and thank goodness I still have all the books I bought (which were plenty). Before that I checked out cassette tapes of books from the library. But when my sons gave me a iPod for my birthday everything changed.
          I used my latest credit to get Michelle Obama’s book but I haven’t started it yet.

          2
          0

        I’m the cleaner of the house and I always have to be listening to something in order for the tasks to go faster. I was surprised when I got through an audiobook pretty quickly. Either I was engrossed in the book or I did way too much cleaning, hehe.

        1
        1

          Back when I lived in MN – I cleaned empty apartments and apartment buildings to help with my rent. Because it usually took HOURS to do several buildings and apartments, I went through a LOT of very long books! However turning up the sound to listen over the vacuum caused me some hearing loss and tinitus.
          To this day I can’t get ready for a good clean anywhere without a good book on hand.
          I also listen in when working in my garden – which is fine until I realize I’ve been working for 3-4 hours straight and I’m exhausted. Just a wee problem…

          love love audio books.

          There was a time when I’d be reading a couple of hard books and listening to an audio book and would get confused about what story I was reading.

          1
          4

            I clean and read too, and my ears have also suffered some damage.

            1
            0

            So our generation is going to the ones with severe hearing loss and tinitus as we wobble around the assisted living places with cell phones in hand.
            haa

            1
            0

            I always come out fine in my hearing tests, but my ears always hurt, like they are itchy so maybe its my allergies. I hate wearing earphones but its necessary in my house, so I play my book only just a little over the sound of water and then I pause it to vacuum. It’s really inconvenient when I get to a good part in a book. So I wait for the chapter to end which is probably why I take forever to clean haha😂

            2
            0

            I had NO IDEA that turning up the ear buds to hear the book over the vacuum cleaner was damaging my ears.

            1
            0

      A book that is also REALLY good – a memoir called “Wild Swans” and it’s actually banned in China. I loved it and gave several copies away.
      https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0036QVOIW/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1

      0
      0

    I just finished In “Order to Live” by Yeonmi Park and “The Island of Sea Women” is on my list after I finish “Barracoon” by Zora Neale Hurston. I’ve found myself taking a long time to read anything the last few years. I used to read several books a month.

    2
    1

      You might also like Without You, There is No is No Us: Undercover Among the Son’s of North Korea’s Elite. The author, Suki Kim went undercover as an English teacher in North Korea, and it’s both fascinating and terrifying. There were portions that made my blood chill when considering the similarities between the personalities of leaders of NK and the US.

      2
      3

        Maybe after the next election? (I’ll put it on my list.) I’m eying “Nothing to Envy: Ordinary Lives in North Korea”.

        1
        0

        @egads – because of you I purchased more credits so that I could download “Without You There is No Us” – the narrator sounds really good from the sample. I’ll let you know after I listen to some of it while working in my garden or *shudder* cleaning my house! haha

        2
        0

        hi there @egads– I got up early this morning and went out to work in the yard so i put in an audiobook. It is now mid afternoon and I just finished it.
        For some reason I thought it was the book you recommended on N Korea, but instead it is “A River in Darkness” – by Misaji Ishikawa.
        It his story of moving to NK from Japan (repatriated) in the 60s when he was a young boy with his parents and sisters. His father was South Korean and his mother Japanese.

        The reader is excellent but the story is heartbreaking. I was driving in the car with tears streaming down my cheeks.
        It is good, (only 6 hrs ) but heartbreaking as anything.

        Now I need to read/watch something cheerful and fluffy – oh wait I’ll turn my brain off and watch Arthdal!

        2
        1

          I call that needing a brain cleanser. Light, fluffy, and no angst in sight is necessary after so much emotional involvement.

          *takes note of A River in Darkness

          1
          0

    Thanks for the recommendation! This sounds like a great read. I’ll be picking up a copy from my local library later this week. I only started getting back into reading for fun last month. Grad school really sucked the fun out of reading for me but I’m finally starting to see the light again.

    2
    0