171

Joseon Gunman: Episode 4

We’re here! With the requisite backdrop set and the conflict established, we now get to the meat of the present-day story, and I’m just about hopping in anticipation to see where we go from here. I suppose we can think of the first four episodes as the “childhood portion” of many a sageuk drama, only we got lucky in not having to say goodbye to the characters who engaged our emotions and drew us into the story in the first place.

SONG OF THE DAY

The Solutions – “Sailor’s Song” [ Download ]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

 
EPISODE 4 RECAP

Yoon-kang and his father make their way to the rendezvous point on the next mountaintop over. There, Merchant Choi Won-shin perches in a tree while his henchman stands by with Yeon-ha. Park Jin-han is aware that they have two gunmen at large, and Yoon-kang says with determination that the numbers are even, and they have the ability to take them.

Dad goes first, with Yoon-kang to act as his backup. Back in the city, Officer Moon gives his troops the order to move out. The question is whether they’ll be of any use with their delayed start.

As the appointed time arrives, Park Jin-han advances slowly and has to tamp down his impulse to rush in to save his daughter. The second gunman gets antsy and shouts at him to show himself, and Park shouts back, “What are you so afraid of?”

He remains hidden as both gunmen scan the horizon, and Choi Won-shin fires at what turns out to be a rabbit. Park Jin-han makes his rush at the second gunman, who runs and leads Park right into Choi Won-shin’s sights. Choi steadies his aim…

But an arrow flies at him and lands in his arm. Go go hero goooooo! Yoon-kang has spotted the sniper and shoots from afar, and now Choi Won-shin joins his henchman in running away. Yoon-kang steadies his aim and takes a careful shot at their retreating backs. His arrow finds its mark, landing in the henchman’s arm. He briefly goes down, but the two gunmen manage to keep running.

Yeon-ha is freed and the family is reunited, but the danger is far from over. As Park leads them back down the mountain, a shot fires at them: Choi Won-shin has doubled back and is intent on seeing his task through. Park Jin-han tells his children to go first while he takes him on, ignoring their protests.

Lord Kim presides over another meeting of Sugu politicians and aristocrats, reminding them that Park Jin-han’s assassination is not their ultimate objective—that would be to bring the king to his knees. Tasks are assigned amongst the members: Minister Kim is told to handle the wrap-up of this case, another nobleman is to manage the royal investigative bureau, and yet another is put to the task of quieting officials. They’re cooking up something big, aren’t they?

Minister Kim comes home to news that his son has arrived. Given the reference to this being the child of the other lady of the house, we can deduce that this isn’t a legitimate son, and Minister Kim is far from pleased to receive him. In fact, he barely even spares him a glance, curtly saying that he doesn’t care to see him or hear his useless greetings.

The son is Ho-kyung, who makes a few sincere attempts at conversation, but gets shut down each time. You can see his heart sinking at every instance.

Minister Kim sneers at his son’s lofty ideas of changing the world: “Go and see whether the world will change according to your wishes.” He reminds Ho-kyung of his (half-)low origins and calls him not a revolutionary but merely a child who’s jealous of the things that his betters have.

In a flashback, we see Ho-kyung speaking with Teacher Hyun Am, who advised him to keep his family ties quiet. Even if he’s an illegitimate child, it would be an obstacle were it known that the son of a powerful minister of the old guard is leading the forefront of the Kaehwa movement. Ho-kyung hadn’t liked the idea, but Hyun Am had advised it as a temporary measure, until Ho-kyung was accepted on his own terms.

Ho-kyung heads back home (well, to Soo-in’s home, which is more his home than his father’s) and finds Soo-in pacing in front of the front gate, anxious for news. She apprises him of the situation and pleads with him to accompany her to the mountain—just to the general area, which will be safe because the officers will be there. She can’t stand to remain at home doing nothing.

In the forest, a shot rings out and Park Jin-han tumbles, taking a bullet to the leg. He forces himself back up and continues, while Yoon-kang, having sent his sister to safety on horseback, now prowls the woods with his bow at the ready. Just as he uses his last arrow, he spots his father in the distance, motioning him over, and they take cover in a cave.

Yoon-kang asks what the men are after, and Park Jin-han says that he doesn’t know yet. He’s digging into connection with a local merchant organization (of which Choi Won-shin is a leader), but hasn’t yet figured out their motive. He informs him that one of the gunmen will have a scar on his left arm from their skirmish.

Ho-kyung and Soo-in ride to the base of the mountain, where they find the officers still searching for our good guys. She worries that this is taking longer than it should, just as Yeon-ha comes riding down on her horse and tells Soo-in frantically that her brother and father are still fighting, and that they have to call in the troops. Ho-kyung offers to head up the mountainside to deliver word, but Soo-in worries that there’s no time. Thinking fast, she pulls the pistol out of her sleeve and fires into the air.

In the cave, Yoon-kang urges his father to hang on until backup arrives. He’s taken aback when his father apologizes for putting his family through so much suffering, accepting blame for killing his wife. He admits that he did try to save her, but failed when plans went awry.

A flashback to thirteen years ago shows us that Park Jin-han had initially complied with the ransom order, holding off the advance of his troops. That got him into hot water with higher-ups and he had been ordered to advance anyway, and thus he had given the order. But he hadn’t given up his wife, vowing instead to save her independently.

With a small contingent of men, he had breached the enemy campground and swooped in to save her, only to find a dummy set up as distraction while the enemy swarmed around them. Park Jin-han had leapt into battle anyway, cutting down dozens of men, and in a rage the enemy leader had killed her.

He admits now to Yoon-kang that that was the first time he’d regretted becoming a soldier. Yoon-kang sheds angry tears hearing this story, asking why his father never told him this before. “Why did you let me hate you?” he asks. Park Jin-han just sighs that he couldn’t save his wife, and felt he deserved that punishment. “Forgive your father,” he requests.

Yoon-kang struggles to collect himself, but one look outside the cave brings a welcome sight: The soldiers are making their way up the hillside.

But the troops are unaware that the two gunman have spotted their advance. Our heroes are out of arrows and Park Jin-han takes stock of his badly injured leg, making the decision to go out alone—to near-certain death. Park insists that there’s no reason for both of them to die, and that he feels safe to leave now, seeing that Yoon-kang has become so strong.

Yoon-kang is having none of this, so Park does the only thing he can do to win this argument and knocks Yoon-kang unconscious. He apologizes to his son and then walks out to face the gunmen, his sword at the ready.

Limping heavily, he leads the gunmen away from the cave as quickly as he can, and the pursuers track his trail of blood. Park ambushes one gunman and strikes him down, just as a gun fires behind him. The bullet strikes him in the side, and Choi fires a second one right into his chest. Park Jin-han falls.

As the life ebbs out of him, his assailant reveals his face. Choi confirms, “Yes, it’s me. Your hunch was right—that’s why you are dying.”

Choi helps his injured henchman hobble away, and Park Jin-han dies.

Yoon-kang awakens in the empty cave and realizes his father has gone ahead without him. He races through the woods to find him, but it’s too late; he comes upon his body by the stream. Rushing to his side, Yoon-kang begs his father to wake up and cries, “I still have things to tell you. I have things I haven’t said yet!”

He sobs clutching his father’s body, and that’s how the officers find him.

King Gojong is incredulous when he receives the report—Park Jin-han was killed for being a traitor. This is outrageous, but the Sugu faction has been busy covering their tracks: A full confession was given to the royal investigative bureau by one of Park’s own men, incriminating him completely.

That informant—the mole, working for Choi Won-shin—had confirmed that Park Jin-han orchestrated the snipings, and was planning to kill Heungseon Daewongun next—Gojong’s own father.

Under the Sugu mastermind’s orders, the informant feeds the authorities the story: Park Jin-han saw Daewongun (who’d ruled as regent when Gojong was a minor) as an obstacle to the king’s future and decided to eliminate him.

Gojong refuses to believe it, but the evidence is lining up neatly. Minister Kim pours on the pressure for him to act quickly, and even the queen urges Gojong to comply, warning of the consequences that resistance would elicit. She reminds him of how powerful the opposition is, and how they have ruled Joseon for so many years. At least by going along, Gojong can stay alive.

The household falls into mourning as Park’s funeral is prepared. Yeon-ha and Yoon-kang are stricken with grief, while Soo-in is wracked with guilt, blaming herself for taking the group on the outing in the first place. Ho-kyung tries to lend a helping hand and tells Soo-in that it isn’t her fault, but she’s not consoled.

She offers to handle preparations for Yoon-kang, but he declines, wanting to do it himself. “I’ve done nothing for him,” he says brokenly. “I will at least make the final arrangements myself.”

Just after he leaves, officers storm the house and read the king’s order: As punishment for traitor Park Jin-han’s crimes, his son is to be executed and his daughter to be made a slave. Yeon-ha is dragged out and Park’s body claimed, while officers are sent out to apprehend Yoon-kang.

Unaware of the uproar, Yoon-kang visits Choi Won-shin, who initially puts on a sympathetic face and extends his condolences over his father’s death. The air turns tense when Yoon-kang states that he’s here to find the gunman; he informs Choi of his father’s suspicions of the merchant group.

Choi Won-shin isn’t going to give up anything easily, and points out how many merchants there are in the association. Yoon-kang offers up the challenge: “If you’re innocent, cooperate with me.” He asks for the chance to search the organization from within, and adds that he has a clue: The gunman has a scar on his left arm.

Yoon-kang gives Choi some time to consider the offer, but warns that if he rejects it, he’ll consider Choi his first suspect and make sure to check his arm. His doggedness is enough to warn Choi Won-shin that he can’t leave Yoon-kang to poke around on his own, and he decides that he’ll have to tie up this loose end.

With the house being guarded by officers ready to arrest Yoon-kang at first sight, Soo-in and Ho-kyung step aside to plan how to circumvent them. Ho-kyung offers to secure Yoon-kang berth on a boat abroad and instructs Soo-in to bring Yoon-kang to a particular dock. They don’t have much time if Yoon-kang wants to flee the country.

Still oblivious to these developments, Yoon-kang makes his rounds in the marketplace to finalize his father’s funeral arrangements. He doesn’t notice Choi Won-shin following him through the city, awaiting the right time to strike.

Thankfully Soo-in finds him moments before the officers do and quickly informs him of the situation, urging him to make his escape quickly. Not bloody likely with Yeon-ha imprisoned, and Yoon-kang bursts out, “Father died while trying to save Yeon-ha. How could I leave her and run away on my own?!”

Soo-in persists in insisting he save his life, because although Yeon-ha is facing a dire fate, at least it isn’t death—not like him. And who will ensure Yeon-ha’s safety if he dies? She begs him to stay alive, which means running.

Just then, they’re spotted by an officer, who sounds the cry and alerts the others. Yoon-kang and Soo-in run for cover and lose their tail, but find their exit blocked by an inspection point at the city walls. Yoon-kang instructs Soo-in to go through first, saying that he’ll force his way if necessary, and tries to avoid being seen.

That doesn’t last long, and an officer peers at his face and recognizes him in no time. Yoon-kang acts swiftly and takes him down. Then the next, and the next.

There are many of them and only one of him, but Yoon-kang is a trained fighter and resourceful to boot. He fends off his attackers with a seriously impressive array of maneuvers, breaking through the line and dashing through the gates safely, where he grabs Soo-in and continues their flight.

They duck for cover in the woods as the guards pass them by, and he notices how she shakes with fear as he holds her. So once the coast is clear and they have a moment to catch their breaths, Yoon-kang apologizes for involving her in everything.

He asks where the boat will take him, and registers that it’ll take him to a foreign land far away. He asks ruefully, “Then when would we be able to see each other again?”

The answer is clear to both of them. He admits, “I wanted to spend every day with you. I wanted to talk with you every night. That was the first dream I’d ever thought to have. But now, it will have to remain just a dream.”

But first things first: He’s got to flee, and they head to the location Ho-kyung indicated. There isn’t much time, and they have to make their goodbyes here, with little fanfare and great reluctance.

Soo-in promises to protect Yeon-ha and hands him the compass she’d once shown him, to guide his way. The moment weighs heavy on Yoon-kang, who can’t quite bring himself to say goodbye or turn away.

She urges him to live, promising, “We will meet again. And if we meet again, we will not separate. Like your dream, we will spend all our days together. But you must promise that you’ll stay alive.”

He promises. “I will live, and I will return.”

He finally makes his way to the boat, turning back for one last look. That’s when Soo-in races toward him, and he holds her close as she cries. He kisses her, and tells her to be well.

Then it’s time to leave, and the boat sets sail. Their eyes remain locked on each other for long moments, until Ho-kyung’s voice cuts through the air shouting her name. He’s galloping toward them, just barely ahead of dozens of officers. Arrows fly at the boat, and Soo-in leaves with Ho-kyung on horseback.

Yoon-kang watches their retreat intently, hardly registering the arrows barely missing him. Out in the field, a lone sniper crouches and aims at him—it’s Choi Won-shin, here to finish the job. He fires—the bullet lands—Yoon-kang is shot. Right in the heart.

Soo-in screams as he falls backward into the water. The officers rush to the waterside and Choi rises, satisfied. Yoon-kang sinks underwater.

Soo-in tries to go to him, but Ho-kyung holds her back—it would only get her arrested too.

Ho-kyung informs Soo-in’s parents of the day’s events, and how the officers eventually gave up looking for the body. But there’s no way he could have survived, and everyone assumes that he’s died.

Soo-in, meanwhile, is locked in her grief.

But as we all suspect (given that he’s our hero!), all is not lost. In the morning, a group of men aboard a boat wonder what to do with the almost-dead person they’ve discovered. Their leader, identified as Kim Ok-kyun, states that they’ll have to keep him with them till he wakes up. He’s dripping wet, and must have been the one to fish out our hero—the one lying unconscious with a shattered compass, having taken the brunt of the bullet’s force.

The group is headed toward Japan, and Kim Ok-kyun finds this whole situation amusing. For now, he claims responsibility for the man whose life he saved.

And then, we’re three years later.

Choi Won-shin and Hye-won walk through the bustling port to meet a man who will be instrumental in a deal they hope to strike with an influential man named Yamamoto. It’s Yamamoto’s trusted representative they are welcoming today, a man named Hanjo. “So our fate depends on this man,” Hye-won muses.

Soo-in has made the trip to the harbor as well, intent on buying something as soon as it arrives in port. She calls it valuable, something she must have. So when Ho-kyung reports that it is confirmed for arrival today, she breathes in relief.

A fight breaks out on the pier amongst a group of sailors, and it looks like it’s set to turn into a pretty violent melee. But then a shot rings out and one of the fighters goes down with a bullet to the arm, and everyone’s attention turns to the source of the gunfire.

On an arriving boat stands a man holding a pistol, dressed in a modern suit, and looking mighty familiar. Eeeee!

He raises his gun and fires a second shot.

 
COMMENTS

Yessssss. I knew this was coming, I was expecting it, and I’m still pumped full of excitement.

That’s something the show does well—taking something expected and still managing to stir my excitement. That’s a tough gig, because there are certain steps this story (or any story) must go through to fulfill the premise we already know, which makes it predictable to a certain extent. But you can’t just take shortcuts because emotional connections and character development take some time to build up properly; when you don’t do the work of establishing your premise, then you run the risk of speeding so quickly along that we don’t connect or care. And I’d rather care.

Now we’re in full-on Count of Monte Cristo territory, which is one of those narratives, like Cinderella stories, that can be done over and over again and never feels old to me. I will watch them all and I will be suckered in every time (granted it’s done well, of course!). Who doesn’t love a great revenge story, driven by a badass hero with a reinvented identity and an old love? This is also where we’ll probably deviate more significantly from The Princess’s Man, which is great because while I loved that drama and found it pretty gripping, I’m all for this one being its own new thing. Even if that new thing is really an old thing dressed up in new duds. New turn-of-the-century duds with spectacles and a fancy pistol. All good things. (SO EXCITED.)

Part of my enjoyment is probably very specific to Lee Jun-ki, but can you blame anyone for finding him electric? He just gets better and better, doesn’t he? He has a way of immersing himself in the moment, full of pathos and immediacy, and it just sucks you right into his emotional maelstrom. Great acting on its own isn’t enough to buoy a sinking ship, but he has a way of picking good projects that allow him to shine, so really I see this show as a win-win on the Lee Jun-ki front. But here’s a case where even with a lesser actor, I’d probably find the character appealing, because he’s got such a rich range of development ahead of him, going from the innocent, privileged young man to someone more worldly, intense, driven, and tinged with darkness. What’s not to like?

Truthfully I have to admit that I’m rather surprised at the volume of negativity in the comments, since I’m so all about this drama. Which isn’t to say you’re not all entitled to your opinions—if you’re disappointed, you’re disappointed, and don’t let me tell you how to feel. But no matter—I’m loving this show, and ultimately nothing outside of the show itself is going to dim my enthusiasm for it. Who wants to join me over here in the lovefest corner where we can bask in our enjoyment?

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , ,

171

Required fields are marked *

I loooobe jun ki and I love the show as u siad I can expect everything but still wanting to know and watch its like watching remakes and feeeling a blast !!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What I am so glad about this show is there wasn't like 10 episodes more where he was still "lost" somewhere. I am amazed about the concept in this drama "just cut to the chase". I am so looking forward to see how this drama continues. After the 4th episode I am really into this drama.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So in love with this drama right now. Hopefully it will get better.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Never a fan of these kind of stories, now I'm sooo Gunmanized! Lee JunKi has been my favourite everything so how can I not love this? His western look is...breathtaking... and the whole story is not so complicated to follow, the OTP chemistry is right on. So I'll keep watching and waiting for your recaps!!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh my gosh! This drama was so good! It is actually my first time to get addicted to kdrama. Love it! And and...the leading man is amazing <3

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I totally love this too. It's my new fav. It's beyond awesome!!!! Jun Ki's awesome, his character's awesome...everything. I love it when the hero is multifaceted in a way where he/she's slightly amoral or has a darker side. 'Cause face it, no body's really that pure and perfect, especially with all the emotional baggage the hero usually gets. I'm anticipating the fact that Jun Ki will be doing good and bringing change, but at the heart of it, he'll be doing all this for revenge.

I started out not really liking Soo In, but I like how she's really grown and she manages to be brave and spunky even while being quiet and lady-ish...I think it's all about timing; Soo In knows what the situation calls for...when to be brash and when to step back. I really like her now.

I for one am really curious about what'll happen to the sis though. Wiki said that the sis died with the father but obviously that didn't happen...I hope she stays alive so that there's still hope for a family reunion.

I'm hoping for some bromance between the male leads...but there'll have to be some major trauma incident added for that to happen, because with Ho Kyung as the son (albeit, illegitimate) of one of the men who orchestrated the father's death and the story about treason, Yoon Kang'll be out for blood.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wait is that dude standing to the right of Jun Ki at the end on the boat the dude who played Cho Rip in Warrior Baek Dong Soo?! I loved that drama! Well fusion.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Stared at the last pic for a long time. ^^ I love this show, so joining the lovefest. I wonder if Soo-in thinks Yoon-kang is really dead? I am so excited for their meeting!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think the fast recapping is because of the excitement but who would blame you!!

First of all I've been in the love fest team. Sure the story is a little predictable but I can not bring myself to hate it. ? I am too excited and so far all the characters to me are perfect and well acted! Ofcourse our hero to me is a league of his own and I couldn't help bit shed a few tears at their goodbye.

I wish I could wake up and be Wednesday day already:(

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Awesome awesome episode. I love every aspect of the show. Despite LJK being my bias, i can't help appreciate the overall quality of the show. I don't think similar themes are a disadvantage...like everyone else i would watch and probably enjoy the 1000th version of Cinderellas and Counts.

It kind of amazes me to see all the bashing because I feel the show and leads have done a bang up job till now. And lol at non korean viewers being more critical than actual korean viewers. I usually love reading comments coz of the spazzing but man JG's viewers are hard to please. Really does discourage people from reading them.

Well save me a spot in that corner because this show has been love for me right from the start.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This episode is Dae-bak!!! Really love Junki in action. And i love it when he change to his costume as the Joseon Gunman =)

can't wait for the next episode. Finally, i found the drama the i like and for keeps =)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i am with you JB! i am joining the bandwagon of Lovefest Corner! I also electrified by JunKi!!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This drama is my favorite this time around (my excitement with You're surrounded is dwindling atm). A great revenge-driven action saeguk with romance as a bonus. The script is very well written and well act. I forced myself to finish Arang and the Magistrate (because I want to delete the files) but I imagine I can enjoy this drama just fine.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap, Javabeans! And I will join you in the lovefest.

Sooo love this drama.

Love all the strong wise women in this drama. It's as if every time a woman opens her mouth in Joseon Gunman, all this wisdom pours out. And I sooo loved the way LJK looked so gratefully/worshipfully/respectfully/son-ly up at our heroine when she was encouraging him. It was as if she was his mother..and his tutor. I loved heroine as encourager! She was wise and strong and yet greif-strucken at the same time.

All the acting is so good. And loooooove illegitimate son. Ready for the show-down between him and his dad.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm definitely in the love it corner. Yes it is a bit predictable, but I'm loving how it keeps my excitement up. I'm think the last time I felt this way was with another Lee Junki drama... Two Weeks. Maybe I just love Oppa and can't say anything bad about his shows. One thing I was not expecting was that Ho-Kyung was Minister Kim's son. But I guess it would make for great conflict later in the story. Next Wednesday cannot get here quick enough!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh I forgot.... the episode had two of my favorite things in it... Oppa in a gat and Oppa in a suit!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's probably just me, but that is twice, now, that Soo In has closed her eyes and blindly shot her derringer into the air. The next time, I want to hear a pained SQAAAWWWK and see a dead duck land at her feet.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

...and cried afterwards, you forgot shedding tears.

Oh, well, at least she appears to be behaving like a 20something finally. No more squeaky voice or tweenage pouting, thank goodness.

(I really do love this drama but LORD did she get on my nerves in ep 1-3)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, especially I`m glad of you...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, the first time, a broken sword blade did land at their feet.
I think closing her eyes (or squeezing her eyes shut?) is a pretty natural reaction to the fear of having to pull the trigger of a dangerous weapon for a first-timer, especially since she was not aiming for anything in particular.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

True--and I think a lot of what Soo In does makes perfect sense for a sheltered little rich girl character--but it's still peculiar when she does it twice.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sheltered yes and the fact that no one has taught her how to use a gun properly. I'm guessing Hanjo is going to teach her later.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oooh, I hope so. Great opportunities for skinship. I still haven't forgotten the measuring tape scene in AATM.

0

You read my mind lol.

0

Notwithstanding Jun Ki's playfulness, one of the things this show is lacking, like a lot of Saguek, is dialogue that is clever instead of earnest and a bit more humor.

I'd settle for something like, when the father and son are going to the mountain, the younger says: "I'll go round behind" and the older says "Good, you've got the younger knees."

. . . Or when Yeon Ha gets put on a horse, her brothers says: "You ride until you meet the palace guards. Father and I will stay here and bond by killing people together."

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm just in my corner, doing a little happy dance at this drama finally getting SO GOOD. (now please do well in ratings, for oppa's sake!)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hullo ! Long time reader but first time to write here.
Thought it was a good way too start with Joseon Gunman ;)

Like javabeans I was also surprised to read so much negativity in the comments for previous episodes because they were really endearing to me and I can be a picky viewer.
However this episode felt a bit like a letdown and several times I was sucked out of it's world mostly I think because of the directing and writing. It seemed really sloppy and confusing at times.
For examples :
- the trail of blood from Park Daddy that Choi spots in the river are absolutely not realistic (as if blood would stick to rocks UNDER water like that)
- the sudden rain at Daddy's death. Unfortunatly it made me laugh during a scene where I would have like to, well, not. Was that really necessary ?
- the soldiers arriving in the mountain then the gunmen. That's the part where I got confuse. I mean, if the soldiers were so close why not alert them that the gunmen were there too ? They are 20/30 with arrows against two men with guns, even if there was casualties they could at least take them down.
All this just to lead to Park's death, I think that it was just sloppy writing.
- again at the end of the ep, the brawl at the port was just an excuse to introduce our new hero in a classy way. It happened in a previous episode too, where a bunch of guys come running out of nowhere and start a fight for who knows what.

All of these details appear like lazy writing and directing at times which is too bad since I think this show has so much potential. If only they were a little bit more careful with the editing and more consistent with the writing it'd be at least 10 times better.

I hope I won't find those flaws in the coming episodes because I'm already invested in the show and I love the characters.
Especially Soo-In, I think she's a good female character and I don't understand all the hate from the comments I read. She's brave, intelligent and she thinks outside of her little sheltered life and I can't wait to see her grow to be a confident, mature and independant woman.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

The problem I have with the writing for Soo-In is how passive and reactive she is.

For instance, once the book disappears, she never mentions it again. We know she is a student of the Enlightenment scholars, but, aside from a vague interest in knowledge, she has no opinions of her own on their goals. Once Yeon-Ha is taken off the screen, Soo-in, aside from telling Yoon Kang about it and crying a lot, she has nothing to say about Yeon-Ha or her fate.

Would it have hurt the writer, when Yoon Kang talked about his sister, for this woman who knows and cares about both of them to say: "You must hide! Let us try to find out what happens to her?"

Even in the family scene after Yoon Kang is shot, it is brother, father, and mother who argue about the political and practical risks to the family. Soon-In just goes to her room and mopes over her loss.

This sort of thing that suggests to some of us that the writer really doesn't have any sense of or interest in Soo-in's inner personality. Far too often in these first episodes, she's just a plot device, assigned certain reactive duties in the story, like the swords, the rifles, and the derringer.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

In what "I" watch, she did mention the book. She said that it hurts her but there's nothing more important than life. She's sure that her teacher will understand too.

This is quite understandable because not only her but Yoon Kang's life was in danger. Plus the guy she was trying to deliver the book was already dead. The book is gone but there are countless scholars educated with the ideas inside the book. All the crossdressing, carrying a gun etc. was due to the sense of responsibility and gratitude towards her teacher. I don't think it's ever been her primary aim to lead the enlightment movement or change the world. Not enough to put her life in danger. At least not yet. And we still don't know how she changed after three years.

AND, at the port she said she will save Yeon ah and take care of her. Even if she couldn't do it, it isn't because she doesn't care it's because she is not as powerful as those she's fighting against. In fact she was the one acting sane when all the soldiers were searching for Yoon Kang . He could be caught and beheaded if he acted too emotional. Not to mention she was the one saving his life.

Plus there's nothing more humane than mourning a death. The man I love is dead and I'll sit and discuss politics at that moment? seriously???

I'm sorry but I don't find any of the criticisms against her constructive. She's bashed ever since she was casted and her every single action is nitpicked and shown like a major problem. If you find her character passive and stupid or whatever, that means you haven't watched a k-drama. I'm not even a fan of her and primarily here for Lee Jun Ki. But I find all the bashing against her unjust and exaggerated.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I thought the sudden rain at Daddy's death was meant to be somewhat symbolic, like the heavens are crying with you at the loss of a fine and good man.

I also thought that the soldiers were only just arriving in the mountain and were stlll quite far away compared to the gunmen who were much closer to the cave. Even if they managed to alert the soldiers, the gunmen would have killed Park & YK first, as the gunmen were between them and the soldiers. Don't forget guns have a longer range and are more accurate/deadly than arrows.

Fights at ports are pretty normal in olden times, and are featured in a lot of historical Chinese movies/dramas. The guys were fighting for the right to carry the cargo/goods from the ship which arrived that day. Based on their dressing, they were from rival gangs.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the excellent recap. Love, love this series. If your interested Google rifles in the Joseon era. They did use rifles and one in particular was from the West, a Remington. Google has photo's of the rifles they used. I think this drama is casting perfection.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh my Gawd, that is a COLT PEACEMAKER in the last scene! The "Gun that won the West, a .45 caliber, single-action, one of the "Civilian" or "Gunfighter" or "Artillery" models with shorter barrel. Just the thing for a gentleman of quality, a US Marshall, or a Texas Ranger to use to resolve minor public disturbances with a great deal of authority and a minimum of fuss and bloodshed.

As I noted in a previous entry, it was said back in the day that "God created men equal, but Sam Colt made them equal." As a trained Joseon swordsman, all it would take for Yoon Kang to get good with one of those was practice.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think the ending of Ep04 ever mentioned what happened to Yeon Ha. Poor girl was having a happy life one moment, then orphaned and enslaved the next. I distinctly remember Soo In promising to protect her. The "3 years later" divider frustrates me, but I guess I'll just wait for the next episodes and wait for the explanations to unroll.

Lee Jun Ki is stellar. As always. He's the only Korean actor whose dramas I watch regardless of the plot because HE's the actor. It's not just his looks (although that's a part of it hehe), but dang, he's an excellent actor. Especially great with action, drama, and romantic suffering. The way he plays his characters, they're never two-dimensional. He either has the ability for picking great characters to play, or the ability to put more meat into the bones of any character.

I'm not sure what people found wrong with Nam Sang Mi, I think she's okay. I think the pre-"meat" (there it goes again ahem) part of the drama required her to be a younger character, before the traumatic events set in. Based on her character development in Ep04, I think she transitioned well into a more adult demeanor.

The Angel of Revenge/Count of Monte Cristo plotline is a classic, and I've always enjoyed watching well-planned revenge strategies executed flawlessly and relentlessly, so I hope Yoon Kang gets his own shot at fulfilling a vendetta.

All in all, can't wait for the next episode :) I agree with javabeans on this one. Lee Jun-Ki, thank you. Again. ;)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

In addition to the Colt .45, we know that Our Hero will be deploying a Marlin lever-action carbine in future. Both were sold freely in Japan by the time of this story (I'm still confused by what the actual date of the "Third year of Gojong" is supposed to be).

The rifles used by the assassins look to be Mauser single-shot bolt actions, which were standard issue for the Japanese army after the Meji Restoration. Why the drama links them to the incidents with the American Marines is a bit of a puzzle, as the US Navy used Springfield Trapdoor breech loaders at that time.

The rifles used in the drama are all wrapped in cloth, presumably for camaflouge. The three assassins must have learned to shoot in Japan. None of them was a particularly great marksman, but to be competent at all takes a lot of practice and plenty of ammunition, along with a place to practice. Which would have been hard to come by in Korea.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Beside camouflage, I think maybe they use cloth to protect the rifle and to get a good grip on it like today's gun-wrap.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

King Gojong assumed direct rule in 1873, so the Third Year of Gojong should be around 1875/1876. Yoon-Kang was away in Japan for 3 years and presumably returned to Korea in 1878/1879. This timeline seems to fit into the drama storyline as some Korean ports were opened to Japanese trade/ships after the unequal treaty signed in 1876.

Commander Park's second-in-command showed him a new rifle made in the US in Episode 1 which was vastly superior to the muskets that the Korean soldiers were using. I think this was when the US military action in Korea which occurred in 1871 was mentioned (3 dead Americans vs hundreds of Koreans) to emphasize the US's superior firepower.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am LOVING this drama. I cannot imagine what there is to dislike about it. I love everything!! LOVE Nam Sang Mi! LOVE Lee Jun Ki! Love the lighting and the cameras and everything!!

The one thimg maybe I don't completely love is Lee Jun Ki's make-up, which is a little cakey - especially around the eyes BUT!!! This is a minor complaint in a show this FABULOUS!!!!!!!!!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've just got to say that I am loving this drama and I hope it keeps it pace and also make sure it keeps its romance portion. I loved the chemistry and I'm actually pretty impressed wit Nam Sang Mi's acting here especially her emotional scenes in this episode! Well-done!

The writers/director are smart to keeping our interest especially with their cliffhanger. It's like we know what's coming and what will happen but they somehow keep our interest enough to anticipate for the next episode. Can't wait for next week already!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've read many bloggers, critics, neutral viewers, etc. singing high praises to this drama, especially the chemistry beteen LJK-NSM. I also find a lot of negitivity spreading all over many blogs & forums. And sadly many of them come from fellow LJK fans.

What are we trying to achieve here ? Seriously. To make neutral viewers/readers think this drama is totally sh*t and turn to other dramas ? Wait until Jo In Sung-Gong Hyo Jin couple arrives and the Jangs-drama gets into full swing. If this nitpicking bashing continues, we may find that what stands between LJK oppa and his success is nothing but ourselves.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well said.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What's your view that take you to see all these negatives are from most of Lee Jun Ki's fans? Seriously??

Most comments here are by the neutral foreign viewers. Some of them may like LJK but they watch many kdramas airing out there and also may have many biases.
OR, there "may be some" LJK anti-s or those annoying at the hype JB exceptionally voicing for this drama "may be the ones" ruining the good atm with their negativity while knowing this is a good drama.

There are a lot of loyal LJK fans (outside DB) following him as their only bias. Most of us don't write comments just to see other drama fans' opinions.

WE, most fans (may be all), neither have complaints with the acting of NSM nor the chemistry with Lee Jun Ki.

Since we like Lee Jun Ki as a multi-talented actor more than his looks, unlike other good looks only hallyu stars' fans, we know what is the good acting and we accept NSM as a good actress who can act par with LJK in the emotional scenes.

Please don't bash to LJK fans groundlessly.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recaps. Though I've watched all 4epi, I start writing my comment from this epi.
I've always like LJKS's action drama either modern or saegguk. Again, he's doing well!!! So far this drama gives me full of excitement, from fighting scene to cheesy love lines, from father's love to brother's agony. All just fit and fine Since both lead cast are experienced actor/actress, the chemistry between them is undeniable. I used up a few tears for YoonKang grief over father's dad and again for SooIn over YoonKang's leaving with gun shot.
So now, after all this past happenings, he's back as an Japanese merchandiser. Can't wait for next episode!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm so stoked about this drama! Like you, I had high expectations considering that Lee Junki has a knack for picking good scripts. Even though a lot of the storyline is "expected" based on the synopsis, it still throws you for a whirl and leaves you excited about what's coming next.

I knew the father was going to die, but I still cried.

Inasmuch as the Soo-In and Yoon-Kang courtship is adorable, I am looking forward to seeing how Jeon Hye-Bin's character winds up in the mix. There's something strong about her character, and although I have a feeling she'll be the unrequited love character, I am still cheering for her. :)

I was pretty excited they did a 3 year skip ahead to get us to the exciting points. The flashbacks will be interesting. Looking forward to more episodes!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Watching it the 2nd time kind of help me appreciate the little things that the show is trying to do differently from other sageuks. Maybe we will get flashback of the past 3yrs in Japan.

Although he hasn't change much in appearance, I love his grand entrance at the port. There is just no hiding behind a mustache or hood etc. Even the baddies sense something familiar about him.
This revenge is going to be so sweet and I'm so looking forward to it.

" My name is Park Yoon Kang. You killed my f-a-t-h-e-r, prepare to die"

I'm not a fan of King Gojong but his portrayal as weak and easily manipulated is spot on.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Awesome episode! Too bad that I wasn't able to join the discussion and can't understand where the hate is coming from. And yes its nothing new.. but he show still managed to give excitement. I initially didn't like Nam Sam-gil on the first episode.. but I don't know after she washed her face on the river that's when I find her endearing.. hahaha.. I know its weird.. but now I love her a bunch...
Can't wait for Wednesday!
Thanks for the recap!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes!!! Great ending for this episode. I can't wait to see how they meet up again. I hope Soo In was able to save Yeon Ha, that poor girl.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

State slaves can be bought with money if the state decides to sell her. The only way to really free her is by restoring their noble status. I think it will be hard for Hanjo to buy her if she is already in a gisaeng house.
He will have to prove that their father was set up in order to restore their noble status, free his sister and give their father an honorable burial.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL! When I saw Junki oppa confessed to her, I was thinking The Three Friends of Gag Concert. For Sangmi speedy relationship!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Huhuuuuu...i've found out some of negative comments come from the work of a blatant trolls (LOLing so hard at their unreasonable comments) :))

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Aha... Trolling is result of envy and imbecility, and it counts on such ...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you so much for your wonderful reviews! I am loving this drama, and excited that we have finally gotten to the good stuff! I have to admit I will watch almost anything with Lee Jun Ki in it. Very much looking forward to where this show is going!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lee Jun Ki looks much better in the modern outfit, he's not as handsome with a gat.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Anyone looks better without gat)))

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me, me, me! I'm all for the lovefest! Your excitement for the show is infectious, and plus I haven't seen enough revenge shows to be jaded by retreaded plot-lines.

Honestly, though- a show doesn't have to be ~*revolutionary*~ to get me excited. It's not the "what" anymore, with stories- it's all about the "how", and I am so there with this one. That shot with Yoon-kang in those glasses gave me ALL THE GOOSEBUMPS.

I don't understand the Soo-in hate at all. Her character was childish, but not overly so, and it matched well with Yoon-kang's character. And they now have matching sets of coming-of-age trauma!

Here's hoping Yeon-ha is okay. We didn't see her here, but I hope Soo-in managed to protect her. Looking forward to this week's episodes!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I must admit, i came into this drama with no info and was curious what the fuss was about. The first two eps were cute, but didn't care for the politics, not because of any flaws in story telling, just that it goes all over my head. That is my flaw.

However, watched up to episode four... and i am.... PUMPED!!!!!!!!!!!!

Yeah! This is what im talking about. Though i do hope it only goes up from here. FEEEELLLLLLLLLLLLSSSSSSSSSSS!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

hey javabeans,

im a silent lurker here. seeing there are lots of negative comment on this show, I figured I should drop you a note saying"pls include me in your lovefest corner" ahihihi...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I can't wait to see how the juxtaposition of Western ways with the Joseon norms plays out in this drama. The imagery of Lee Jun Ki in the boat at the end was so striking. Thanks so much for the re-caps. I am a recent convert to Korean television and I find that the English captions do not always reflect the actual feel of the dialog. I'm going to have to learn Korean!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm with you on being baffled by the negativity. I've watched worse for longer and far, far shallower reasons, and I think Joseon Gunman so far has been stellar in execution. I can't wait to see how this unfolds.

I think you nailed it absolutely on the head as to why I find this show so captivating, too, Javabeans, on the Lee Jun-ki part: his acting is so effortless in its full commitment. He cries. I cry. He dopily crushes on someone. I dopily crush on someone. It all feels so much more real and less affected than so many kdrama heroes. This is a guy who isn't going to stride around in fashion-forward, eye-gougingly awful trousers with his hands stuck in his pockets because he doesn't know where to put them in a scene as he's desperately trying to sound disaffected while tossing off his lines -- he's in it to win it and rip my still-beating heart out of my chest in one fell swoop.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Finally caught up after watching only 1 (?! I know how is that possible) episode after the premiere week (doing this at 5AM before a work day ... not smart). I am in LOVE, and I haven't been able to say that about a drama in a long time, quite possibly since the last sageuk a la Lee Jun Ki with Arang & the Magistrate. There is just something about him that really draws me into his character, and I find myself squealing at every little thing he does. He's not the most attractive actor out there right now starring in a drama, but he definitely has me the most attentive.

Cannot wait till today's episode and to see a whole other side to Lee Jun Ki and his character EEEEEKKK!!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Um excuse me! Lee Jun-ki is the prettiest of all the pretty men. They should have just dressed him up in girl clothes when they were running away - he can cross-dress too!

Lol, you know I'm teasing, right?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okay in the first 3 episodes I liked this show, but now I love it. I already had huge respect for the dad police officer. He's a boss. In this episode not only did he pull a Vegeta by knocking out his son and then sacrificing himself to save his world, but then he went and pulled a Boromir by getting shot 3 times and still being awesome! Yes, Boromir was shot by arrows, but I figure 1 bullet = 3 arrows, so same same.

I'm respecting the villain too. Not as much because he's not really that epic, but still some. I watched Faith too many times for me to take him seriously. In fact, I kind of like him still. Maybe I'll learn to hate him as the show progresses.

And our main couple knocked it out of the park. I'm entertained. I'm IN now. I wish I'd waited like a week longer to watch this episode b/c now I know what I'm doing tomorrow when I come home from work :-).

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *