52

Goodbye Mr. Black: Episode 5

This revenge did not set up the way I thought it would, but it does give us the room to explore other aspects of our hero’s betrayal and loss of love. There’s a fun caper element driving his scheme, and I’m happy to see the formation of a Scooby gang, even if we’re not given a full glimpse of his endgame just yet. That’s the thing about this guy—even when he’s laying out his plan openly, I’m never quite sure how much more is going on below that surface.

SONG OF THE DAY

Emotion Boy – “안녕에 안녕” (Goodbye to Goodbye) [ Download ]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

 
EPISODE 5 RECAP

Black/Ji-won shows up to crash Mari’s party at his old home, holding out a hand to her saying that he’s come for her. The rest of the partygoers look on curiously while she reacts emotionally, almost reaching out to take his hand.

But Sun-jae steps in, calling her “yeobo” deliberately (which is only used between spouses) and telling Black they’ll talk when the party’s over. His men escort Black away, and Sun-jae hisses a warning to Mari to calm herself, since everyone’s watching.

Swan hasn’t gotten a good look at Black from across the party, but her oppa Ji-ryun has, judging from his look of shock. When she asks who the man is, though, Ji-ryun doesn’t tell her and merely suggests that they leave the party.

The alliance of evil is going strong, and Director Seo is pretty rattled to see the Sunwoo Group heir rematerialize—has he found proof to clear his name? Teacher Baek, on the other hand, acts much less worried since Ji-won’s a wanted murderer, and warns Seo to watch what he says. Still, behind Teacher Baek’s back, Seo cackles that the old man is totally nervous despite acting calm.

Meanwhile, Mari is desperate to go see Ji-won, angry that Sun-jae said he’d died. Sun-jae insists nobody could have survived that explosion, and reminds her that they’re married now. It keeps her from going after him, but she does take out an old jewelry box containing Ji-won’s proposal ring.

As Black waits in his old house, he imagines his father still here, suggesting a fishing trip like the good ol’ days. But by the time Sun-jae goes to see him, he’s already gone. Instead he gets a phone call, and Black asks why he married Mari—it takes away one of his reasons for coming back. Sun-jae says he thought he’d died in the blast after they found his dog tags, and Black points out, “Why was that all you looked for? You should’ve searched for me.”

Black hangs up, ignoring Sun-jae’s demand that he meet. Sun-jae joins Mari in bed and says he couldn’t meet Ji-won. She doesn’t say anything in response, but places her hand on top of his.

Teacher Baek is furious at Ji-won’s return, but decides that he doesn’t have to get involved in this fight just yet. He’d thought to give Sun-jae a chance, but decides, “I have to take the chairman’s seat.”

To that end, he’s been working on securing a casino and resort deal, which would make his company, Sunwoo Distribution, a holding company. (Recall that Sun-jae owns rival (frenemy?) company Sunwoo Construction; Sunwoo Group is the parent corporation and the crown they’re all after.)

Over at small-time internet outlet Panda News, an informant calls in regarding yesterday’s case of dead man in the mountains. The caller is Sung-min, our con man from Thailand, and Swan perks up at mention of the case, taking down the name and address Sung-min offers.

The tip identifies businessman Park Ho-shik—and aha! He’s the silver-haired man from the victim’s funeral, whose license plate Swan noted. Does that mean Park Ho-shik is a murderer?

Editor Woo-jin shuts down her speculations and her plan to investigate, but Swan is determined to sniff out this connection. She guilts a co-worker into taking her to the address, where they note a couple gangsters outside letting in scantily dressed young women.

Swan dabs on lipstick and heads in, saying she’s here for a posted job notice. She acts a little helpless, showing her Thai ID and saying she’s here to make money, asking him not to report her for this. The gangster likes that answer (or maybe just her vulnerability), and leads her inside.

Sun-jae gets the report that Ji-won entered the country under the name James Black; he’s got a French passport now and has served in the Foreign Legion for the past several years.

Mari’s back to her normal mood this morning, and Sun-jae thanks her with some relief “for everything.” As he changes, she suggests having the scar removed from his arm, which came from Ji-won’s bullet. (Funny how he got hit right through that big blood bag strapped to his arm!)

Sun-jae’s expression darkens when he hears his father’s voice outside, insisting on seeing him. Mari offers to handle it, and Dad offers her some freshly caught eels and accepts the envelope she gives him. When she says that Sun-jae’s still home, though, Dad hurriedly exits; looks like their relationship is still on the outs.

Dad’s a taxi driver and gets a call from a hotel, where a sharply dressed passenger gets into the car. Ha, it’s Black, and he takes off his sunglasses and waits for Dad to recognize him in the mirror, shooting him a sly smile.

The building turns out to house a casino, and Swan’s job is serving drinks. She’s too busy looking out for silver-haired Park Ho-shik to think much of the man who tries to get her attention, seemingly acquainted with her. He asks a gangster if he can take her with him while surreptitiously swiping his phone, and from a separate room, informant Sung-min watches the security cameras. Is some kind of sting going down?

Phone Swiper transfers files from (onto?) the phone before returning it undetected, and Sung-min calls the gangster to get the hack going. Then Sung-min spots Swan on camera and gapes.

Swan spots Park Ho-shik at a table and sidles near, quietly telling him she’s from Panda. Ack, she thinks he called in the tip himself, but he’s annoyed at her hovering and has her escorted away.

Black eats lunch with Sun-jae’s father, oddly blasé about walking about in the open. Or should we call him Ji-won again, since he’s apparently not taking this double identity plotline to heart?

He assures ajusshi that he’s got a plan: He’ll turn himself in to find his sister Ji-soo, since only family members can file missing persons reports. As the chaebol heir, he still has his inheritance, with which he can hire an army of fancy lawyers to defend him in court. Um, please tell me that’s your sham plan, and that you have a super-genius real plan up your sleeve.

Ajusshi makes up an excuse to slip away and call Sun-jae, and I’m dearly hoping Black anticipated this.

Sun-jae meets with Teacher Baek, and has his confident face on, saying he’ll handle the Ji-won situation and warning Baek to just take care of the resort plans and not disgrace the name of Sunwoo Group. Teacher Baek smirks that it’s a good thing Sun-jae’s not scared like before.

Sun-jae’s father calls to give him the tip about Ji-won’s return and his intention to turn himself in, which makes Sun-jae sit up in alarm. He asks what to do about Ji-won seeking his inheritance, which worries both of them. Ji-won just tells ajusshi that he’s going and saunters off looking smug.

Ji-ryun’s mother shops with her friends, and disapproves of their gossiping that Mari has another man on the side, and that she might divorce Sun-jae and take half his company. Then Mari gets up from the table behind theirs and greets Mom politely, making the old biddies cringe.

Mari’s at the department store to meet with May, the woman representing her investor boss who’s close to finalizing a deal with Sunwoo Group. Mari’s purpose here is to help grease the wheels between May’s boss and her husband, and the women browse through men’s clothing while chatting about May’s boss wanting to have dinner with Sun-jae. May comments about living with a man, and the name of her company is MRB. Mr. Black, I presume? (The show hasn’t connected those dots for us yet, but hey, they’re right there.)

Sun-jae meets with his father and asks for notification the next time Ji-won contacts him. Dad assures Sun-jae that he’s on his side over Ji-won’s, eager to keep their relationship going, and then asks hesitantly whether Sun-jae had anything to do with everything five years ago regarding the chairman and Ji-won. Sun-jae doesn’t answer, but it makes him tenser.

Ji-won shocks Mari by showing up at the department store in plain sight, and asks if he can try on the clothes she’s picked out. In a flashback, we see Mari pestering Ji-won to change his clothes and swearing to make him wear only what she tells him to from now on. With that memory in mind, he tells her now that he wants to wear what she’s chosen.

He takes the clothes into a dressing room, and Mari talks to him through the door, telling him to come to the house if he has something to say to her.

Ji-won pulls her inside, and reminds her that he’d asked her to wait, and that they’d promised each other. He asks about the card he sent her, and she replies, “What card?” She tells him not to seek her out like this again.

But Mari’s deeply rattled, and as she sits in her car battling tears, she thinks back to the card he mentioned, which she discovered amongst her father’s things while preparing for his funeral, which he’d kept from her. The card had been sent from Thailand while Ji-won was on the run, and he’d told her of his plans to die officially in order to disappear, telling her not to be shocked if she heard news that he’d died.

He’d signed off by writing, “I won’t leave you behind and die. I love you. Ji-won.” Wait, she knew he was alive all this time?

Ji-won buys the outfit Mari picked, while she sobs in her car—and nearby, Sun-jae watches her from his own car.

May meets with Teacher Baek’s team regarding the resort plans, and says she and her unseen boss will be ready to sign a contract as soon as Baek’s company buys the land. He returns that he’ll purchase the land within the month, provided that MRB deposits their investment within a week—a whopping 20 billion won.

May reports to her boss that Baek came out strong, but assures him that he’ll make back his investment right away.

Ji-won drops in to see Ji-ryun, telling of his plans to send Killer and Sun-jae to prison together, though we don’t hear exactly how. He promises Ji-ryun to keep it a secret that he came to see him, and they smile at that.

Rumply editor Woo-jin barges in to speak with Ji-ryun, before realizing there’s someone else here. He’s friendly with Ji-ryun and demands money and the car, and mentions Swan’s name—he’s on his way to handle that case, and takes off once he’s got a credit card and car keys.

Ji-ryun explains that he introduced Swan to Woo-jin’s internet news site, and asks if Ji-won isn’t curious about her. He says flatly that she’s probably fine, and when he hears that Swan’s still looking for his sister, he tells Ji-ryun to pass along that she can stop, since Ji-won will do the looking.

Ji-ryun reminds him how stubborn Swan is, and how she persists in believing that he’s alive. He advises Ji-won not to get caught if he doesn’t intend to see her.

At the casino, Swan keeps an eye on Park Ho-shik, who’s not having a great gambling day. She gapes to see Woo-jin join the crowd—and my, doesn’t he clean up nice. He instructs her to leave, since he’ll get to Park, and fires her yet again. Something tells me it won’t stick.

Fancy Woo-jin seats himself next to Park Ho-shik, and Swan tries to hover with limited success. Now Park is flanked by watchers on either side—Woo-jin and Phone Swiper—though he doesn’t notice. Probably because he’s too busy losing all his money.

Swan returns to the bar and overhears gangsters talking about getting rid of Park tonight, and hurries to warn the man to flee, because he could end up like that dead man on the mountainside. Ack, that doesn’t seem wise! Park recognizes her from the funeral and outs her as a reporter, which makes Woo-jin grit his teeth at her interference.

At least he thinks fast and knocks over a stack of betting chips and accuses the casino of cheating. That causes a stir and gets him punched in the face, and Swan blurts, “Editor!” as she rushes to his side. Oy, did everyone skip their brain juice this morning? She really is terrible at this undercover thing.

Adding to the chaos, the alarm bell rings—the police are raiding. Gamblers scramble to collect their money and leave, while police officers pour into the building. The gangsters running the operation blockade the doors and pack away their cash, dropping it down a getaway chute.

The gamblers are directed out via back exit, and Woo-jin chases Park Ho-shik outside (though not without first running his manly jewels into a pole).

Swan, meanwhile, gets seized by the gangsters—and then a masked man flies in and knocks them aside, shielding her protectively. It’s Ji-won, and he tells her to stay still if she doesn’t want to get hurt. She can’t see his face but her eyes widen to hear his voice.

Ji-won shoves her away, hand symbolically slips out of his, and he resumes the fight, handily subduing all the gangsters.

Ji-won runs off before Swan can get a good look at him, but she catches up as he’s riding off on a motorcycle. She holds out his compass and tells him with shining eyes that she knew he’d be alive… and the guy raises his visor to reveal an unfamiliar face.

Still, she remains convinced that her rescuer was Black. Woo-jin catches up to her and reminds her that Black is dead, urging her to let go now. A flashback reveals to us that Woo-jin was smitten with Swan at first sight, when Ji-ryun brought her to the paper, and he’d been flustered to hear her say she had a husband. Then when he’d seen the photo, he’d recognized the man as Ji-won.

Now, he reminds her that Black’s dead and she’s not actually married. Swan replies that even though it was a fake marriage, Black cooked eggs for her, drew notes, and gave her a name—how could she forget him?

The police emerge from the raid empty-handed (are you entirely incompetent?), and the gangsters report to Killer not to worry. Killer instructs them to clean up the mess, make the delivery, and track down Park Ho-shik.

This is what eavesdropping Sung-min has been waiting to hear—he’s been listening in all the while, and now makes a call to say the bait has been taken.

Park Ho-shik is taken to the Panda office (where Woo-jin pointedly makes fried eggs), and he’s a rather ungrateful rescue victim, grumbling that he’s being kept against his will. The team reminds him that he can leave through the open door, but Park is wary of Swan’s warning that the gangsters are after him.

Mari makes the rounds of her hospital, where she spots Ji-won in the distance. He tells her he’s wearing her outfit and suggests they head out, taking her for a drive to the sea, referencing their old promise to be married on the beach.

The gangster delivery turns out to be a truck packed full of apple boxes containing cash, taken from the casino before the police got to it. The truck heads out first, followed by the gangsters in a black car—and along the way, a sedan cuts in between the vehicles, swerving madly and acting like a general menace.

The crazy sedan gets pulled over by police, forcing the gangsters to a stop, and then another truck stops next to them, blocking the gangsters’ path. Aha, Sung-min is the wild driver, and I can only presume a heist is underway.

Sung-min tells the truck driver to continue on, and then his team stations a decoy truck in its place. Ha, we’re going full Italian Job on this, are we?

The decoy truck is manned by Phone Swiper from the casino, and when the gangsters catch up, they’re following the wrong truck.

The real driver gets taken out of the equation too, when he stops for a woman who’s stranded by a car stopped middle of the road—May, ha—and gets carried off.

The gangsters arrive at their destination and unload their apple boxes… full of apples. So our con artists unite with the real truck, and revel in the mounds and mounds of cash they’ve just diverted, which answers my question of where MRB is gonna get their 20 billion won of investment capital.

That sum gets transferred over to the Sunwoo Distribution account, to Teacher Baek’s satisfaction. Only then, he gets word that his own delivery has disappeared. Muahaha.

Ji-won takes Mari to the beach, telling her he missed her while she remains quiet and distant. Her voice hardens as she tells him to listen up: “You should have died.” She lays it all out for him: how she married within a year of his death, how she gave up looking for Ji-soo, and how good Sun-jae is to her. She’s happy, she says, and Ji-won shouldn’t have come back.

Ji-won grabs her arm intently, saying that he doesn’t care if she forgets him, but that she can’t be with Sun-jae. She fires back that she chose him, telling him that it’s too late.

Ji-won says she has to at least hear this, and starts to name the last person he saw before the explosion, which we know was Sun-jae. But that’s when her men arrive to collect her, and she shakes off his hand.

Swan returns to the scene of last night’s run-in with Black and finds a car parked there with a black box, and gets the footage from the owner. She reviews the footage, and which captures her rescuer walking by after the fight—and it confirms that he was Black.

Ji-ryun gets a delivery of apple boxes, which Black calls repayment and interest. Ah, so Ji-ryun was funding him all this while?

Sung-min video-calls Ji-won to confirm that Baek’s stolen money got returned (in that investment), and when Ji-won tells him he can keep the leftover cash, Sung-min lies that there was none left over (while having already taken his cut).

As Ji-won talks, headlights flick on in the distance, catching him in the glare. Sun-jae’s behind the wheel, and he suddenly guns it, shooting for Ji-won, who jumps out of the way just in time. But then a motorcyclist comes at him and strikes him with a pipe, knocking him to the ground.

After confirming the footage, Swan says aloud, “Goodbye, Black.”

Sun-jae gets out of the car to crouch over Ji-won, saying that Ji-won should have sought him out (instead of Mari). He grabs Ji-won’s lapels threateningly, just as a voice shouts his name—Ji-won’s video call is still in progress, and Sung-min can see him. Ji-won says, “It’s okay, he’s my friend.”

They drive… somewhere… and we’re back to feigning ignorance—Sun-jae says he was merely signaling Ji-won of danger with his headlights, and Ji-won pretends he doesn’t know Sun-jae’s a murderous backstabber.

Instead he acts like he’s been away for a long time and finds it strange that Sun-jae hasn’t identified his killer yet. Sun-jae sees the truck they’re driving alongside and considers swerving into it (on Ji-won’s side), but Ji-won grabs the wheel and merely cautions him to be careful.

Sun-jae reminds Ji-won that he’d offered him help five years ago, but Ji-won didn’t come. Ji-won answers that he couldn’t go, because of the man who “killed” him. Sun-jae holds his breath, waiting to see if Ji-won’s on to him… and Ji-won replies that it’s that man who smelled of gunpowder, aka Killer.

Sun-jae asks, “Are you sure?” Ji-won returns, “And if not?”

 
COMMENTS

Okay, phew, so Ji-won does have a master plan. It wouldn’t have made sense for him not to have more up his sleeve, but I’ll be honest, this show is just sloppy enough that I wasn’t sure I could trust it. I’m definitely feeling the directorial shortcomings in this show, and they do sometimes intrude on the flow of the story, which contributes to that uncertainty of where it’s going. Some plot uncertainty is intentional, in that we can’t know what twists and turns our hero’s got in store for his payback scheme. But I can’t help wishing we had a more assured, skilled director at the helm here.

Plotwise, I’m still flummoxed as to why Ji-won outed himself right from the start—who tells a Count of Monte Cristo story where he goes through all that effort to invent a new persona for himself, and then just introduces himself as Edmond, not the count? What is the point of that? Isn’t that sapping your conflict before it even has time to grow into a plot?

Still, it’s so early in the game that I have to believe that choice this is part of the grand plan, and that there’s a reason for it that will reveal itself later. Otherwise, it’s just too strange to explain… which isn’t to say that it can’t just be bad planning. But I’m willing to wait and see what Ji-won is working on.

I do like that we get this cat and mouse game going, and having his identity out in the open creates a wholly different dynamic than if he were to come back pretending Black was a different person, driving his traitor friend slowly insane with the uncertainty, and creating all sorts of angst with his lost love who’s sure it’s him but told it’s not. (Gah, why is that not our setup again?) But this gives us the twist of having Mari onboard with her choice, which was not something I was expecting.

I think I like this better, because it makes her interestingly complicated, that she knew he wasn’t dead but chose to move forward with her life, and therefore his return is actively unwelcome. If she’d been totally blindsided when he came back, I’d have felt sorry for her in a general sense, but in a way that makes her the victim in all this. I found it enlightening to have her comment that she was becoming more like Sun-jae the longer they were together, and so I see her choice in this episode as the first step in her aligning herself with her husband against Ji-won.

True, she doesn’t know that Sun-jae was the one who tried to kill Ji-won, but for now she’s making her choice with eyes open. I’m curious to see how this affects Ji-won’s perspective on his revenge—does it make him see Sun-woo’s usurpation any differently, if he can’t see Mari as “stolen” if she doesn’t see it that way? Or does it just add fuel to the fire?

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , ,

52

Required fields are marked *

i'm with you on the "sloppy" part... perhaps it's just not what i would have thought a revenge plan would look like, but man is it hard to believe that jinwoo's got a hold on things sometimes T____T maybe that's the point, that his plans are just very ... not covert?? idk how to describe it.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just catch up with the drama and I still feel it's funny on how he outedhimslef like that.
In my opinion it better that there's person whispering that there's someone who looked like jiwon, lot of people suddenly said the same, Sunjae looked around and the saw someone familiar back. That person turn back and looked at him , he said hi, said his fake name but sunjae still didn't believe him. He move really close and whisper, "yes, I am your dead friend jiwon, now smile for the people"
They smile and people clapped, brought to mari attention and they met.
He hugged her and said "i am jiwon and I came for you"
And clapped while saying how beautiful she is to the people.

Why you have to outed yourself in public, you are accounted for a murder, at least not for the public or just let mari knew not sunjae cause she is important in your life.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ugh. I had such high hopes for this drama... because I have not learnt my lesson from getting my hopes and dreams trampled on by dramaland. But this... I do not know where it is going. I definitely see the sloppy. The very sloppy.
God, give them strength, or give Me strength. With all my heartbreaks recently, CITT, Yong Pal and SO MANY MORE, i do not think my poor heart can take it again

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

And somebody please PLEASE PLEASE, explain the reason behind him revealing who he was. Because i cannot stop scratching my head in confusion.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yaiks! I planned on waiting for a few more eps to marathon this but seeing the comments for the past few eps I'm on the fence about it.. Should I still start? Or wait a bit? I love both leads and only heard good things about the 2nd lead..

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watched the first episode and stopped around 30 minutes in. Lee Jin Wook's acting was quite bad in imho. Wasn't natural at all and he was a bit stiff in deliverance. Editing is horrible and extremely chopping which distracts the flow. The only saving grace is Moon Chae Won. Thank goodness for recaps because I didn't bother to watch ep. 2 and 3. I just went right in at ep. 4 and I felt that I didn't miss much. Again, the only saving grace in ep 4 was Moon Chae Won.

So, to answer your question, don't start the drama. Wait a bit because that's what I am doing from now on.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, I see! Thanks for the heads up. Will check out the recaps then. Hope things improve in the next episodes.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ljw acting is good, all the cast is good, if you heard only second lead is good it' not right, the first 2 ep show second lead role emotional intrigue when the first lead shown as positive n haven't much conflict that's why people see heavier acting at second lead but the first male lead emotional conflict start in ep 3, you'll see his acting, you will heard more praise with his acting

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I want to dip back in for the sake of the leads (and second lead Rim), but goodness the sloppiness levels are off the charts.

I'm not watching any dramas live post-Cheese, I learned my lesson the hard way there but even if I was following along for GMB, I'm less annoyed simply because the sloppy levels are so up front from so early on. We haven't got a Bad Guys-calibre thriller suddenly turning in its last eight episodes into, well, whatever GMB is ;0

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

<this show is just sloppy enough that I wasn’t sure I could trust it. I’m definitely feeling the directorial shortcomings

I watched the opening episodes a while back, and dibbed back in to watch the rest... and I'm definitely feeling the sloppy. I had to skip-watch, some parts just feel boring. Other parts just feel utterly uncompelling – like not well-thought out or written. Like Swan. The extent to which she helps Black, a stranger whom she essentially doesn't know. It just feels like a very romanticised notion to me. But then her whole interaction with him is, she was handling him like a guy she's romantically interested in despite knowing there is a woman in Black's life (and he was pretty touchy-feely-looky, given that!). Sure, it's paving the way for the OTP but, well, I just don't get it/her.

I also can't help find some of the directorial choices really off, like some of the scenes were just tourism ads for Thailand and off-tone. I mean, if I'm on the run because someone thinks I'm a killer... walks on the beach, floating lanterns and arranging Christmas presents aren't going to be what I'm doing.

The premise of the story is fine, but I just don't feel the execution/details add up right now. Not really sure I'll continue to be honest, Neighbourhood Lawyer has more thrill for me so far than this – and I expected the opposite given the revenge-stop-at-nothing thriller that this is.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think Mari was already married when she got the letter so it was too late to wait for him. In the flashback Sun jae is in the funeral attire of a family member.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I think Mari only married Sun-jae because she thought Ji-won had died, and that she didn't read the card from Ji-won until after she was already married (because her father hadn't given her the card). I think we're meant to presume that she believed that despite his message, Ji-won really did die in the explosion-- or at least that it was easier for her to believe that.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Judging from the screenshots alone, LJW looks like a madman lol.

I've decided to read recaps for now and will start watching once the plot actually develops. I was under the impression that Swan WOULD be part of his plot so I'm just at a loss right now, lol. How much more entertaining would it have been if Swan was actually his partner in crime? Oh, show, what could have been. Swan could have had that girl, May, her role! That would even be more interesting.

So, until MCW gets a bigger part of the plot, I'll be quietly reading recaps on the sidelines.

(ALREADY WAITING FOR MCW'S NEW DRAMA. I'm like, kinda done with this drama atm. LOL.)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I also felt like Moon chae won didn't have much to do may be she will be part of the 'revenge' plan in the future.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree that this drama is very poorly executed-- my expectations went way (WAY) down from the first episode. I'm annoyed that they're even starting to ruin MCW's character for me, 'cause she's the highlight of the show for me. Swan has a lot of street smarts-- no way do I buy that she would've been that clueless at the casino.

Lol (and rawr) @ Editor suddenly being all suave and well-coiffed. Not looking forward to watching his heart get broken. Can someone please give Rim a leading role as a confident but sweet smitten-kitten?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"a leading role as a confident but sweet smitten-kitten" kinda reminds me of Surplus Princess...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Prediction:
Mari is the one who "took" Ji-soo. At this point, I'm still assuming that Ji-soo is alive somewhere, at it was to save her life.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sigh ... Cant they changed pd?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That last screen cap is gorgeous!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What they did with this awesome book? The poor execution, so-so actings, weird storyline. Goodbye Mr. Black is another failed adaptation/remake.

By the way, I like Song Jae Rim-Moon Chae Won chemistry. I'm hoping more their scenes together than her with Black.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

seeing the comments above, i think i'm the only strange one who enjoys watching this drama.... i barely notice the sloppy.. i think it's interesting.. at least it's semi-unpredictable^^

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

You are not alone.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I enjoy the drama too even though I dislike the directing.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me too love this drama, why? This drama isn't cliche, in many revenge drama the lead hiding his identity, but this drama the lead shoing as himself at least to his enemy, curious what's next n the acting is good, i'm crying at ji won n mari confrontation, feel sad for both of them

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I still like the drama but it feels such a waste, it gets me that he might not survive since the way it shown is not so belivable, it maybe a good idea to outed himself, but he is accounted for murder not just random disappearance.
Part of it i think because he supposedly changed but nothing really changed, i hope it picked up at ep 4

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love Moon Chae Won so much and this show is making me nervous! This is her comeback drama and I want it to be best for her. Sigh.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I do agree in the sloppy directing. I don't think that this is much about the script. Moon Chae Won agreed to do it, which means the script is something. Also, Baek Ji Yong agreed to do the OST. She told in an interview that she only does OSTs for dramas if she likes the female lead and if the drama is good. Thing is, Moon Hee Jung has written beautiful scripts and is also experienced in melo and revenge. Han Hui is not really experienced in directing, moreover, something like this. You see, the action scenes are actually okay but if they were treated with the most appropriate framing and phasing, its a would be grand. The story is actually good. But the direction of the drama is, you're right, unpredictable, I wonder if it's intended or we're plainly lost in the directing.

HOWEVER, I still enjoy the drama. I love the story, the difference to usual revenge dramas, minus the sloppy directing. I enjoy the drama because there's something deep in it and there are rewarding moments. And I love the acting!

Just kind of disappointed that it's episode 5 and we're all missing Moon Chae Won. Was thinking if Black would ditch Mari first before Swan totally gets in (because when he unloves her, she'd start her way to him, shouldn't be it?)

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sorry for the typos! Lol.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, when she first signed in, the PD wasn't this one.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That thing.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For now, I still can follow this drama. I think the directing is bad, but not the whole drama. I believe the script is good, the problem is with the direction.

Yoo In Young is such a gorgeous woman. I feel bad for MCW, but could not help it, at least for now I feel like YIY is the female lead. maybe I am too favour of YIY that I wish she is the female lead instead.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not enough MCW in episode 5, so I kept fast forwarding a lot. I am watching because of MCW. The story is good, the 2nd lead actor is full of charisma. Too many Mari and Cha Ji Won. I just hope I will see more MCW in the upcoming episodes

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Rim ♥

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Mind games!

I think he will be playing mind games not only on Sun Jae but also on Mari. (Who gets married less than a year after your first love dies!?) Probably because his mind and heart is still scarred he may not be able to scheme as well as we hope, but I'm liking it so far.

I didn't understand at first why Mr. Black (please keep calling him that because I fell like happy conflict free Ji Won 'died' when his friend betrayed him) outed himself so early, however I feel like even though his identity may be revealed not everything he is doing will be. (like the business deal)

I don't get the Monte Cristo vibes from Black himself since his cover is blown( which I'm ok with); however who says Ji Soo can't do that herself later on? I'd be extremely pissed if I were her.

Love the Scooby gang! Can't wait till Swan and Sung Min meet again.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

To whoever complaint about Moon Chae Won's less screen time let me remind you that this drama is male centric. It talks about Mr. Black and how he get revenge. Means, he's the main point. He involves with so many characters including his ex lover and the next lover. Don't blame PD or script writer for the less screen time. Moon Chae Won accepted this drama already when she already knew it's all about Mr. Black, not Swan. So... stop complaining and just enjoy the series. If you don't like then just leave it.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Male-centric...just like 99.9% of the dramas out there...

And people are allowing to express displeasure because even if it's a '''''''''male-centric'''''''''' drama, she's still the female lead. It's baffling that Inyoung has more screentime than her (I'm not complaining, because I love her, just a general point) and people like you saying 'OH SHE KNEW WHAT SHE WAS GETTING INTO' is really not helpful, so step off.

http://i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/newsfeed/000/540/816/41d.png

^ this was me while reading your comment.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes this is male centric drama with the main story is about revenge not about romance, in this kind of drama usually female lead not getting much screen time, seem like some of you waiting for romance drama, in this drama revenge part will be the main focus

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i think it would be better if she ended up being the mastermind behind his betrayal and SJ turning to the dark side, rather than being just another victim. it would make up for some of the shows other faults. sadly, thats not the accepted norm for these shows. think i'll drop this one for now and maybe pick it up once its finished. maybe.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Whatever it is, I love super duper love the chemistry between Woo jin and Swan OMG RIM WHY ARE YOU SO ADORABLE <3

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Still enjoyed these drama very much!!! Hwaiting Mr Black ^_*:))

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I still find this drama very interesting n enjoying watching it!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The issue for me is in the consistency of the storytelling. The drama plays such serious beats mixed in with lighter ones without really melding them together successfully, and there seem to be so many side characters + stories that don't connect with the plot aside from maaaybe being Black's manipulation (or Ji Soo's, who is likely alive and also seeking revenge?) I was thrown off by this episode's bad take on an Ocean's Eleven-type heist, and for a minute there, it could have been an entirely different drama.

With that being said, though, I plan to continue watching this because I'm a sucker for watching strong female heroines fall in love.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Loving all the cast and so far.... Great drama to me:))

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I enjoy this show and it doesn't bother me that he revealed his identity because that was what i like the most because it's not expected in Kdramas

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well this drama has surprised me, and not in totally bad ways. I still love the lead characters, and even some of the supporting ones. I think Black's agenda is starting to take shape, so I'm sticking around for the long ride.

The whole casino scam was one big satisfying one-up. I'd say this is one 'smart' revenge drama, if a bit on the slow side. Still worth watching!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just think that Ma Ri have a reason for marrying him even when she knew Ji won was still alive ,giving that she married after one year which means she never even waited ..so what happened? is it to protect his wealth maybe ? or as u said she just chose to side with her husband now and leave Ji won !! and tbh I was like 100% she would marry sun jae keke or else why we have Suwan there ? they had to shove Marry away so the love story goes well XD

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

great great drama !

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love this drama

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

oh wow. when sunjae's father calls sunjae to inform that jiwon is back and he is afraid of the money is taken from them. phew like father like son!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

and not to mention how shameless sunjae to live in Cha's manor omg.. at least get a different house to live!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Swan get soo stupid in this episode I just can't

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *