326

Mr. Sunshine: Episode 8

With a big mission upon them, the Righteous Army is moving as many pieces as possible, hoping to secure the safety of their fellow comrade. Ae-shin’s secret is on the brink of discovery, but that doesn’t deter her from this mission. She continues to fight for what she believes in, forcing those around her to choose if they’ll fight with her or against her. It’s not a simple decision, choosing which side you’d risk your life for, but that’s the deal when you admire someone so earnest in her beliefs.

 
EPISODE 8 RECAP

We return to the triangle of jealousy, where Hee-sung tells the two men that he doesn’t want to develop bad intentions yet. Eugene labels this newly revealed side of Hee-sung “the nobleman’s son,” and Hee-sung asks if that bothers him. Eugene responds that he hopes that Hee-sung remains as his neighbor, Room 303. He warns Hee-sung not to put Ae-shin between them or speak of patience again because he may not end with just a warning next time.

Dong-mae observes the tension between these two and comments that this is exciting to watch. Now, he’s not sure who to hate more, and he hopes that they can make his life easier by getting into a fight and eliminating one of the two. Dong-mae walks into the hotel, leaving the two men to finish their business.

As Eugene turns away, Hee-sung says that Eugene revealed his response only after putting Ae-shin between them. Eugene demands to know what he revealed, and Hee-sung clarifies that Eugene’s claim about patience implied that he’s tolerating something.

Hee-sung asks why Eugene is tracking down slaves who served his family thirty years ago, and Eugene admits that he’s not eager about this search, as it’s tied to his painful past. Eugene says that Hee-sung was there that day too, in his mother’s womb, when Hee-sung’s grandfather declared to nine-year-old Yoo-jin that a parents’ sins are also the child’s sins. Eugene quotes Hee-sung’s grandfather and associates Hee-sung with his family’s sins, and he warns Hee-sung not to get in the way between him and his parents, lest he be tempted to find sins against Hee-sung.

Before Eugene leaves, he turns back around to tell Hee-sung that he can complain about a painful splinter under his fingernail, but he can’t talk about pain in front of someone whose heart has been ripped out — that’s a matter of shame. Eugene walks into the hotel, and Hee-sung’s face crumbles.

That night, Eugene tends to his wound, and Hee-sung stands in the same spot outside as the hotel’s evening lights turn on. The blowing laundry in the yard reminds him of when he first met Ae-shin, and he wonders if he’s meant to be the heartbroken one.

Dong-mae walks aimlessly through the village and thinks about Ae-shin’s skirt brushing his fingers. He stops in front of the bakery, and the owner offers him hard candies, which he’d bought previously because they reminded him of Ae-shin. Dong-mae says that he wouldn’t buy such useless things and says that the candies were so sweet that they were bitter.

The owner of Hwawollu, the prominent Japanese restaurant, urgently meets with Dong-mae regarding his grim fate. He had no idea that the Japanese-disguised server was a part of the Righteous Army, but Hayashi, the Japanese ambassador, will likely not accept this excuse. He’s trying to escape with his life, and he thought that the only person who would buy the devalued Hwawollu would be Dong-mae.

The Musin Society takes over Hwawollu, and Dong-mae walks through the corridors as the new owner. He sits in the room where the American, Logan Taylor, was shot dead, and he wonders who will be next to die.

Ae-shin practices her shooting and thinks about Eugene — him shooting himself with the gun and passing by her carriage slowly after being released from jail. She returns to the hideout, where her teacher Seung-gu comments that the sporadic sounds of her shooting indicated that she may be distracted by her thoughts. Ae-shin admits that she couldn’t focus and asks about the woman she saved.

Seung-gu gently scolds Ae-shin for her audacity to face their enemy head-on. Both her and Eugene risked revealing her identity, but Ae-shin says that there was no other way. To her relief, Seung-gu reports that the woman, So-ah, is alive and that she thanks Ae-shin for saving her life. Seung-gu tells her to forget this woman and her name, as all members of the Righteous Army are nameless, faceless, and just live as soldiers. If Joseon survives, being remembered as “soldiers” is enough, he says.

Emperor Gojong looks out at the peaceful night sky and comments on how it contrasts the precarious state of the nation. His trusted minister advises him to summon the American soldier who was involved with the punished Japanese soldier. The minister explains that this American solider seems to have returned to Joseon as a homecoming, and Gojong welcomes this news that the American solider is a Joseon person.

The minister suggests that they invite the Joseon-American soldier to the court while the American ambassador is on leave, since they may be able to obtain more information. As a part of their strategy, the minister advises Gojong to invite the other country ambassadors as well, but they will place Eugene at the forefront.

Hina receives an unaddressed envelope under her door. As soon as she reads the message, she burns the letter, and we see that it’s been stamped by one of the emperor’s advisors.

The next day, Hina visits Eugene at the U.S. embassy and relays the unofficial invite to the palace by the emperor. He must show up in his Western dress without his arms. As the messenger, she doesn’t know the context of this invite, but she offers some words of advice to make up for her switched key blunder. She advises Eugene to only speak in English and use the translator to communicate with the emperor. Eugene infers that she must have switched the keys on purpose but offers to turn a blind eye.

Eugene looks at the sky outside, and little Domi asks what he’s looking at. He responds that he’s wondering if he’s the blue sky or the black bird.

A servant finds Ae-shin’s grandfather to announce Seung-gu’s arrival, but Grandfather is also looking at the sky. He remembers the prominent words of young precocious Eugene, who commented on how one black bird could ruin the blue sky. Grandfather wonders how this child grew up.

Grandfather meets with Seung-gu, who reluctantly asks for money to buy a secret ticket for So-ah to escape to Shanghai. Grandfather asks Seung-gu how long he’s been teaching Ae-shin, and Seung-gu responds that it’s been about ten years now. Worried about Ae-shin’s safety, Grandfather asks if she’s equipped to protect herself, and Seung-gu assures him that Ae-shin can protect herself better than most men.

Grandfather knows that Ae-shin’s shooting skills aren’t just being used to protect herself and wonders how else she’s being utilized. He recalls that he funded the Righteous Army when Sang-hwa (his son and Ae-shin’s father) went to Japan, but that money ultimately contributed to his son’s death. He knows that he can’t prevent everything, but he requests that even if Ae-shin is utilized, to utilize her less often and in secret. With that, Grandfather offers Seung-gu the money to save lives that need saving.

Before Seung-gu leaves, Ae-shin offers to pack him some food, or in other words, she asks to talk. She says that she heard his conversation with Grandfather and requests that she help So-ah get to safety. She saved So-ah and wants to see this through. Seung-gu honors Ae-shin’s wishes and wonders where she gets her audacity and willingness to risk her life.

Emperor Gojong meets with Eugene, and as Hina recommended, they converse via the translator. Gojong expresses his delight and appreciation for Eugene returning to the motherland and saving the Joseon woman. He asks Eugene for any advice regarding Joseon-America relations, but Eugene doesn’t offer any. Eugene clarifies that he’s a solider — not a politician — and that his loyalties lie with the U.S. He further claims that he simply saved the woman’s life, not because she was a Joseon woman. He says that he can’t offer any advice that would benefit Joseon.

The translator mistranslates Eugene’s message by saying that Joseon should accept help from powerful countries, including Japan, but Eugene doesn’t correct the translator. At the translator’s words, Gojong’s face falls with disappointment. The minister excuses the translator, for he knows that Eugene can speak Korean. The translator’s eyes widen in shock, and he runs off, implying that the translator intentionally mistranslated the message.

Gojong asks Eugene where he’s from, and Eugene says that he doesn’t know. Assuming that Eugene is being disrespectful, the minister scolds him and urges him to tell the truth. Eugene clarifies that his parents were slaves, so they adopted the surname of his father’s first owner, as is custom.

Realizing his mistake, the minister mentions the upcoming event for the elderly ministers and ushers Eugene out. Once he leaves, the minister apologizes to Gojong for not thoroughly checking Eugene’s background. The emperor says that Eugene’s cold demeanor indicated that he wouldn’t have shared anything beneficial regardless, and he looks thoroughly disappointed. As Eugene leaves, he takes a look at his pawnshop receipt for the emperor’s banknote.

Hee-sung’s mother searches through her house for Eugene’s ornament, and her husband proudly says that he sold it at the pawnshop because she was so repelled by the item. She chastises her husband for selling an item full of grudge and fears their fate if Eugene were to return demanding this item. She imitates his gun-threatening move to remind her husband of that traumatizing experience.

To retrieve the ornament, Hee-sung’s mother visits the pawnshop and notices a familiar pocket watch. Choon-shik reveals that it belonged to her son, and she gets livid. As she leaves the pawnshop, she runs into Hee-sung, who tries to wiggle himself out of the situation, to no avail. His mother shows him the pocket watch and scolds him for pawning an item that his grandfather gifted him.

Hee-sung asks his mother if anything happened during the year of his birth and maybe on the day of his birth. He asks specifically about a nine-year-old slave boy, and his mother gets uncomfortable, noticeably reaching for her neck. She pretends to be clueless and hurries off to make lunch. She warns Hee-sung to stay hidden at the hotel, and Hee-sung gives her a sorrowful smile.

As Hee-sung walks away with the pocket watch in his hand, he remembers the day that his grandfather gave him the gift. He was facing the other way, but he can hear the pleas of the servant who begged for his farmland back — the same farmland that Hee-sung’s grandfather sold to buy that pocket watch.

The tailor’s assistant recognizes Hee-sung on the road, but Hee-sung doesn’t recognize him, cheekily claiming that he can’t remember men’s faces very well. The tailor stirs his memories by reminding him when he was first measured for a suit, and Hee-sung then gladly greets the man. Noticing Hee-sung’s size, he comments that the suits that Ae-shin bought and sent to him every year must have been small on him. Hee-sung pretends to know what he’s talking about, and once the tailor leaves, he seems to find a glimmer of hope in the engagement, knowing that Ae-shin still thought of him year after year.

At the medicine shop, Ae-shin opens the secret drawer where she keeps her shooter disguise. It’s the suit that the tailor mentioned, and that’s why it was probably a small fit — because it was for Ae-shin, not Hee-sung. Ae-shin notices that she’s missing her mask, and she realizes that Eugene took it from her.

When Eugene returns to the embassy, he finds Kyle typing away on his typewriter. Eugene jokes that he’s finally writing that poem, and Kyle says that it’s actually an essay suggesting that the two of them go on an adventure before the ambassador returns. Eugene offers the next line in that essay: “No.” Ha, these two are great.

Kyle mentions that he found a black mask in Eugene’s office, and Eugene says that it belongs to a woman. Kyle teases Eugene that he must have let a woman into his room, but Eugene responds in Korean that he let someone into his heart. Unfortunately for Eugene, Kyle understands the word maeum or “heart” in Korean, and he teases Eugene that he knows about that this is about the noblewoman. Eugene grumbles at everyone around him being such a quick study at languages.

Eugene invites Kyle for tea and shows him the pawnshop receipt for the banknote. At this point, everyone is looking for this banknote to take control of Joseon, even the U.S. ambassador. Kyle says that this banknote holds Joseon’s money rights, ginseng distribution rights, and the railroad concessions, so the U.S. ambassador can take control of one of these things if the banknote is relayed to him.

Eugene isn’t sure what to do and says that there are two options: leading Joseon to its demise or delaying this. Kyle disagrees and says that the U.S. needs to stop meddling in Joseon. Besides, the U.S. will take control of the Philippines and not have a stake in who takes control of Joseon, he says. Kyle says that the banknote should be returned to Joseon, since it belongs to them.

This comes as a surprise to Eugene, and he says that this is an odd thing for an American to say. Kyle says that these words come from a poet (not an American) and explicitly repeats what he implied, saying, “Eugene, don’t become a dangerous man, Yank.” Kyle says that he hopes that the last line of his poem reads that being deployed overseas was like a picnic.

He leaves Eugene with those words, and Eugene thinks about the royal translator’s mistranslation and the minister’s flustered reaction to Eugene being of a son of slaves.

Eugene finds the minister at his home and seems a bit surprised to see him in humble clothing chopping wood. Eugene tells the minister that the translator lied and manipulated the translation to favor Japan. The minister asks why Eugene is disclosing this now, and Eugene admits that he had a change of heart.

The minister expresses doubt about Eugene’s confession, saying that he doesn’t quite trust the former slave who fled to the U.S. in his youth. Eugene says that it’s up to the minister, but his reason for meeting the minister came from a place that was more difficult, more dangerous, and burned hotter than shooting a gun. Though now, Eugene realizes this may have been a misstep.

Gwan-soo finds Eugene and explains that Japanese-siding Minister Lee has ordered all the streets of Hanseong to be searched to find the missing geisha from Hwawollu, or as we know, the Joseon woman in the Righteous army. Eugene watches from afar as Ae-shin’s carriage arrives at a search stop, and Ae-shin readily exits her carriage to comply with the search.

The soldiers show Ae-shin the sketch of the woman they’re looking for, and Ae-shin pauses in a moment of recognition. The soldiers accuse this Joseon woman of disguising as a geisha to earn money and condemn her for abandoning her nation. But Ae-shin expresses sympathy for this geisha. Eugene watches the carriage pass by and thinks about Hee-sung’s mention of his fiancée.

Alone in the medicine store, Ae-shin looks out the window and remembers the night that So-ah was dragged out by the Japanese soldier. She thinks about Eugene intervening to confront her enemy. Her thoughts are interrupted by her maid, who suggests that they leave before drawing attention. Ae-shin agrees and says that she needs to prepare to leave for Jemulpo, the meeting spot where they would smuggle So-ah out of Joseon.

Grandfather looks worried as he hears the sounds of preparation for Ae-shin’s trip to Jemulpo. Meanwhile, Hayashi explodes in anger about the geisha causing the death of his soldier. He can’t make any moves to capture the geisha because his actions could be associated with his foreign affairs work, so he orders Dong-mae to go to Jemulpo and cover the ports while the Joseon soldiers search the streets.

Dong-mae finds the ship ticket dealer and watches the poor man getting beat up by his men. He threatens to use his sword if the ticket dealer won’t reveal the information they need, so the ticket dealer leaks the exact time and arrangement to meet the woman in secret to board the ship to Shanghai. Dong-mae tests the ticket dealer by asking if he meant that he was meeting a man, not a woman. But the ticket dealer insists that it was a woman he was told to meet, and this confirms the validity of the information.

Seung-gu arrives at the U.S. embassy, and the American soldiers surround him, holding him at gunpoint. This parallels young Seung-gu being surrounded by the American soldiers after the deadly battle that killed his father.

When Seung-gu meets with Eugene, he claims that he’s here to get repaid for the alcohol Eugene used when they met previously at the graves. Eugene realizes that this is Gunner Jang, and he asks if the geisha is safe and if he’s the leader. Seung-gu plays dumb, and Eugene says that he just took a shot in the dark.

Seung-gu asks why Eugene is hanging around Ae-shin, and Eugene plays dumb by saying that the person he was with was a man, not Ae-shin. Seung-gu realizes that Eugene knows Ae-shin’s secret and quickly grabs the gun by Eugene’s desk. Aiming the gun at Eugene, Seung-gu asks why he saved the geisha. Eugene comments that Seung-gu’s student is just like her teacher.

Seung-gu cocks the gun, but Eugene informs him that it won’t work because the spring isn’t installed. Eugene shows him the missing piece, and Seung-gu realizes that this must be the gun that his mechanic friend disassembled. Seung-gu puts down the gun, and Eugene mentions how all the men around Ae-shin try to kill him despite the fact that he’s only done anything to help.

Still mistrustful of the Americans, Seung-gu suspects that Eugene has ulterior motives for helping them. He doesn’t trust Eugene, who may look like a Joseon person but is an American soldier nonetheless. Eugene tells him to just take his money and leave, and Seung-gu warns that he’s asking for quite a sum.

Dong-mae and his gang walk through the train cars on their way to Jemulpo, scanning the fearful passengers for anyone suspicious. Dong-mae and Yujo stand stationed at the ship’s entrance, and they check for anyone remotely suspicious. Dong-mae stops a familiar face, and he recognizes the man as one of Hayashi’s assistants. He realizes that Hayashi sent a man down there because he doesn’t trust Dong-mae.

It’s last call for boarding, but their target is nowhere in sight. Dong-mae looks to the ticket dealer, who looks just as confused not to find his customer. Dong-mae notices that the merchants they scanned on the train haven’t boarded the ship, and he quickly realizes that he’s been misled. He found it suspicious that the information provided was too accurate and too easy. Hayashi was misinformed about the geisha escaping on the boat — she’s taking the train.

As Dong-mae calls his gang to head towards the train, a gunshot from behind them distracts the gang from their mission. Yujo leads the gang towards the man who shot the gun, and more gunners shoot at them from all sides. Dong-mae yells that this is just a distraction to delay them from catching the train, and as he’s about to turn, a bullet nearly hits him from above. He turns to its source, and the gunner quickly hides on the rooftop. It’s Ae-shin.

Dong-mae yells at his gang in frustration and realizes that he needs to call Hanseong to inform them of this mistake. He runs toward the telephone building, and Ae-shin follows him from above. She aims her gun at the telephone and hits her target just as Dong-mae runs into the building. The phone is fried, and Dong-mae looks out the broken window to see a black-clothed figure running away on the rooftops.

Eugene currently looks at the donkeys carrying a fleet of luggage, and he thinks back to his agreement with Seung-gu. In a flashback to Eugene’s office, Seung-gu explains that the woman is not yet safe. They’ve spread the false information about the geisha fleeing Joseon via ship, and the Righteous Army plans to hold up the captors at the port so that she can escape via the 1:00 train. Fortunately, the train only runs twice a day, so the captors will lose her.

Eugene asked Seung-gu why he was divulging all of this information, and Seung-gu reasoned that Eugene shot his arm to save this woman, so he can finish his work. Seung-gu requested that Eugene help from the American side and let the woman pass the checkpoints smoothly without a search. Eugene corrects Seung-gu, claiming that the woman he saved was Ae-shin, not the geisha. Although Eugene complained about having to repay such a big debt for alcohol, he didn’t refuse the request.

To cover up this mission, Eugene recruited Kyle to go on their adventure. As they prepared for their personal trip, Gwan-soo told Eugene that he’d been doing some thinking. Eugene laughed worriedly because every time Gwan-soo did some thinking, it had always gone against Eugene’s initial plans. Gwan-soo connected the dots that Kyle’s random trip with a stranger was timed perfectly with when the streets are bustling with searches, so Kyle must be trying to help this stranger.

Eugene looked tentative in response to Gwan-soo’s perfect deduction, but this time, Gwan-soo made a supportive suggestion. He offered to accompany Kyle because this is his job as a Joseon person. He seemed to know the implications of their journey and was willing to support the Joseon cause.

Back to the fleet-carrying donkeys, the geisha So-ah, now disguised as a man, thanks Eugene for his help. She apologizes for searching his room, which happened because So-ah expressed doubts about him. She asks why he’s helping her now, and Eugene says that he’s decided to go with delaying the demise of Joseon. Kyle passes by on his horse and assures Eugene not to worry. He shares the next line of his poem: “Let’s go!”

In his hotel room, Hee-sung looks defeated that this pocket watch keeps coming back to haunt him. He wallows in his misery, lying on the bed and thinking about how his fiancée is using the suit she fitted with the tailor. As he broods in his room, we see the watch tick to 1:00.

Ae-shin runs along the rooftops and hears the train whistle as it departs. She barely takes a moment to find relief when a bullet shoots near her. She shoots back and hits her target, and she continues to flee. Right at her tail, Dong-mae collects the gun from the man she shot and chases after her. He climbs onto the rooftop and aims his gun at the cloaked figure. As he concentrates on his target, he slowly recognizes the eyes of this cloaked figure.

Suspecting that his target may be Ae-shin, Dong-mae struggles to pull the trigger of the gun. He’s got a clear shot, but he chooses to aim slightly off and hits her leg as she leaps between rooftops. Ae-shin crashes down to the ground mid-sprint, and she winces in pain from the impact of her injury and fall.

Dong-mae runs to the site of Ae-shin’s fall, but she’s escaped the scene, leaving only a small pool of blood. Yujo catches up to Dong-mae and reports that they’ve missed the train, so Dong-mae orders his gang to return to Hanseong and head north to Shanghai. He plans to stay behind to confirm a suspicion.

Kyle and his entourage near the Hanseong exit gate, where Joseon soldiers execute their searches. Gwan-soo announces Kyle’s title and explains that the servant in the back (So-ah in disguise) is also a part of Kyle’s party. The Joseon solider approaches So-ah suspiciously, but Kyle jumps off his horse to express frustration that an American solider is being held up for a search. The Joseon solider defers to Kyle’s authority and lets them pass through without a search.

Injured Ae-shin breathes heavily in pain as her maids tend to her wound. The bullet left a large enough wound that they need to stitch up her leg, and Ae-shin’s loyal maid volunteers to do it. Afterward, they burn the blood-covered clothes to cover up any traces of Ae-shin’s injury.

Kyle and Gwan-soo successfully escort So-ah to the docks and wish her luck in her journey, and Kyle gives her his hat. She rides away in a boat through the night, and both Kyle and Gwan-soo look relieved.

Dong-mae sits on the train tracks at the station and repeats the mantra: “Don’t come.” He desperately hopes for Ae-shin not to show up, but his wishes don’t come true. Ae-shin and her servants arrive at the train station, and Dong-mae says that it’s quite a coincidence that she’s here this morning.

Ae-shin explains that she’s coming back from the temple, hence the mourning garments. When she tries to pass by, Dong-mae stands in her way. She orders him to move out of her way before she kills him, and Dong-mae scoffs, saying that he would be faster at that. Ae-shin doubts him and asserts, “Is that so? Even though I could [kill you], I don’t think you could [kill me].”

Ae-shin looks at him with a fierce look, and Dong-mae remains silent, looking exposed by her words. She passes by him followed by her servants, and Dong-mae stands on the tracks, utterly crushed by Ae-shin’s words. He says, “I told you not to come, but you came anyway and even knew… that.”

In the train, Ae-shin hides in a carriage and winces as she ties a cloth around her bleeding leg. It took all her strength to walk normally in front of Dong-mae. Having escaped his gaze, she crumbles in pain, out of plain sight.

Hee-sung stands outside the tailor’s shop, pondering what Ae-shin’s suits were used for. Meanwhile, her other two admirers run into each other at the mechanic’s shop. Eugene waits to pick up his fixed music box, and Dong-mae stops by to fix his sword. He tells Eugene that it was his sword against guns, and since he can’t wield a gun as well, he only managed to hit his enemy in the leg. Eugene tenses up at this news, and Dong-mae requests that Eugene inform him if he notices anyone limping.

Later that night, Ae-shin visits the medicine shop. Once she’s fully inside, she allows herself to limp through the shop, and she stops when she notices another figure there. It’s Eugene, and her eyes light up at the sight of him. They’re both glad to see each other and ask the other about their injuries.

Eugene says that Dong-mae was looking for a man limping from a gunshot injury, and he asks if that person is Ae-shin. She jokes that she did get shot in the leg, though she’s not a man. Ae-shin asks that he keep this a secret, and Eugene says that she’s indebted to him once again. Ae-shin proposes that they call it even now, this secret in exchange for that time she let him onto the boat to see the ceramist.

He jokes that he regrets being indebted for the boat ride, since he rowed the boat himself. She says that it’s too late for regrets and admits that love is harder than she thought. She apologizes to Eugene, for everything he’s endured for her. Eugene says that they can give it up if it’s too difficult, but Ae-shin refuses. She says, “Since we can give it up anytime, let’s not today. Today, let’s continue walking this path.”

Ae-shin asks what the next step is after introductions and a handshake. Eugene says that they probably can’t do it because the next step is “hug.” Before he can continue, Ae-shin runs to hug him. She tells him that she already learned “H” in the alphabet, and they stand quietly in a gentle embrace.

 
COMMENTS

Okay, that was kinda cute. I’ll admit that I’m not a huge fan of this main couple, but I do find the whole alphabet romance kind of cute and rudimentary in a nice way. With all the action building up, it’s nice that these two still have a nice rapport and find some solace in each other. While their intentions don’t completely align just yet, Eugene is slowly but surely taking steps to side with saving Joseon, and we know that makes him the leader in this admirers’ competition. While I wasn’t very keen on the idea of three love interests for Ae-shin, I actually don’t mind it too much because I am all about the two angsty second leads. One is cursed with the sins of his forefathers and another is cursed with a forbidden love. It’s only a matter of time until Hee-sung puts together the pieces to figure out Ae-shin’s secret, and I can’t wait because so far, the reveal of Ae-shin’s secret has only brought out the best in these dudes.

I’m loving Ae-shin more and more as this show goes on — her forthright manner with the guys, her blind courage, her stubborn loyalty to her values. She manifests the heart of the resistance, and she’s such a force. I think Grandfather and Seung-gu are well aware of Ae-shin’s potential in the movement, and they might be the only ones keeping her back from going rogue. Not that she hasn’t gone rogue already — she was a complete savage in her confrontation with Dong-mae. How could you crush Dong-mae like that! He was completely defeated, and she totally knew what she was doing. He’s got the cruelest fate of them all, and those puppy eyes aren’t helping me hate you. Not that I wanted to hate you in the first place, Yoo Yeon-seok.

We’ve all come to admire the cinematography in this show like a broken record, but it truly does elevate everything, including the wonderful imagery. Though not subtle, the parallels of the present day with our characters’ pasts are timed and portrayed beautifully. The quick flashbacks remind us of our characters’ intentions, their motivations, and their demons. I do wish the show would be better at balancing their subtleties and their explicit messages. Sometimes, I need to think too hard about the vague references. Other times, I need them to stop with the slow motion and dramatic music because yes, I get that this is a super important and beautiful/tragic/cool moment.

I’m happy that our comic relief characters did something noble for a change, and it makes me extra proud because the bar was set so low for them. Kyle and Gwan-soo are great buffer characters in our group of angsty and volatile leads, and I like that they flew under the radar with the Joseon soldiers just like they fly under the radar with viewers. If anyone needs something to do while watching this show, please keep a record of Kyle’s poetry lines and draft a poem by the end of this show. I would love to see if it makes sense because that would be the ultimate gift and plot twist.

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , ,

326

Required fields are marked *

Ae-shin is such one heck of a bad ass woman.

Oh, and that hug ♥♥♥

11
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hurray for Kyle! Please let him be a good guy until the end of the series.👍🏻

I am still not hardcore ‘shipping Eugene and Ae-shin although I can’t help but root for these two together even if I’m not seeing a happy ending in their future.

8
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's going to end so bad...for everyone.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I stay up in bed, tossing and turning all night, worrying that everyone dies. *cries*

8
reply

Required fields are marked *

Funny, many people don't like them together. I suppose you beanies have seen them both, KTR and LBH in other dramas, with more suitable partners in a OTP. It makes sense then, to reject them now as such.
But story wise, I feel they have to become the OTP, because of their relative equally power and intelligence. Also, it will be easier for Eugene to turn into a savior of joseon than for Dong mae.
Me, I am ok. Have never seen them before in anything, so I am perfectly buying their characters and the way they are falling for each other.
I hope we get a relatively happy ending, but I doubt it 😖

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My big worry. Will Hee-sung turn bad? How many times have I not liked, then grudgingly come to adore a character only to have him/her turn bad? Please be good.
And the hug. SIGH. My hub said, "why isn't Eugene hugging her back?" I've thought about it--and I think it's because in Josen, even thought he's American, he's also a slave still. And slaves don't hug noblewomen. (At least not until they've told the noblewoman the whole truth.)

Just a guess.

5
27
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, and when Dong-mae shot Ae-Shin. My husband said, "he's going to shoot her." And I said, "NO way! Any man who saves a woman's writing and can recognize it--he'll know it's her and he won't be able to shoot her."
I was SO wrong. He recognized her. He knew it was her. And he shot her (in the leg) anyway. Okay, so he didn't kill her--but wow. I did not see that coming.

8
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, way I see it, either Hee Sung, or Dong Mae, will go dark.
Hee Sung knows her secret and forces her to marry him.
Dong Mae knows her secret and forces her to be His Woman - have to put that in caps to make it more dramatic.

Ae Shin will say witheringly:

To Hee Sung: "Go ahead, and tell the whole of Joseon. I will never marry you! I would rather die, you coward!"

To Dong Mae: "Go ahead, and tell the whole of Joseon. I will never be Your Woman! I would rather die, you traitor!"

The response from Hee Sung or Dong Mae:

" Think about your grandfather. And the people who are close to you. Collaborators, all. A crime punishable by death."

Silence from Ae Shin.

14
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow, you just gave me a chill. This could happen.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Augh! Excellent dramatic possibilities. (Dang it!)

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Omg I really hope that gets touched upon...

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

If Hee-sung and/or Dong-Mae decide to go this route, Ae-shin might respond, "Go ahead. You will have me but you will never have my heart."

I can see her saying something like that.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

My first comment here!! I didn't think he was going to shoot her either, but at the same time I totally understand why he couldn't have entirely believed that it was her right off the bat! Or at least, that was my impression :)

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The next day--when he was sitting, waiting--and he said, "I hope you don't show up" (talking about her) I think he was still hoping that he hadn't shot her--that it was somebody else. But now he knows for sure. (And welcome! Good to have you as a "vocal" beanie.)

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ohhh, maybe that's it: until he's told her the whole truth about being a slave. That's also very American and very Marine imo, to feel all your cards must be out on the table. But I admit, I was like whaaat, you told her a hug was next and now you're standing there like a log?

11
15
reply

Required fields are marked *

Unless they replay the scene at the beginning of the next episode and finish the hug. But this is fairly normal in kdrama-land, to have one hug but the other doesn't.

6
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

One of my biggest pet peeve! Ugh!

8
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

...mine is the wide open eyed kiss...

3

Eyes wide open with the dead lips. Smh...why kiss at all then?

5

Well, even when I'm wrong about what's going to happen (and I often am) I still like to guess. But yeah, you're right. One sided hugs are common.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I hope he hugs her back in the next episode.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've been trying to figure out the one-sided hug bit in kdramaland. Could it be the person not hugging at first is unsure of his/her feelings, but usually after a second or two they reciprocate because they know their feelings are mutual? I think we're all expecting the first scene of the next episode to see him reciprocating.
Does anyone know if this writer has done something similar in her other dramas?

0

He's frozen in shock. I think that despite his verbal overtures, he's still basically the same kid inside who was brought up to feel inferior to the nobility. The very careful distance he maintains between them stems from the inferiority complex that has been ingrained in him. It's going to take a lot to break down that wall, so the way I see it, next episode, he'll

A. Continue to stand there frozen, hands balled at his side
B. Hug her back
C. Pull her in a hug as she steps back in embarrassment at his stony response...slow-mo, of course
D. Hug her back, and when she asks, what comes after "hug"? answers "Kiss", and kisses her.

11
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

D. Hug her back, and when she asks, what comes after "hug"? answers "Kiss", and kisses her.

+1 for potential hotness. K dramas are so tame though...

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

It will be C. I think. Writer's always do that, give viewers hope in one episode, then take it back in the next one.
I haven't watched many dramas, but this pattern has been consistently happened in kdrama.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

They're only doing one step a week, so the kiss should come the week after.
But then what happens the next week??? Wish they'd go there.
But most probably that's when she finds out he's the son of a slave. What a dilemma to test her beliefs in the class system.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh my God, I just love everything you wrote @yyishere

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's a Korean drama thing that in some instances one person hugs and the other doesn't reciprocate. I suspect it is for the benefit of the audience; perhaps it's intended to temper carnal feelings when watching "G" rated dramas. You see the same during kissing scenes. The actors take it only far enough (touch lips) for the audience to get the idea. It's not always like that though.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

My only hope for more skinship is that it's broadcasted on tVN, but being set in the time period it is, we may just get chaste hugs. I would that she kisses all the boys though. That hate-love thing she has with Dong-mae is what thrilling romances are made of (and no, I've never read a romance novel in my life). ;)

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

You have hit the nail on the head. Its the G rated thing. But I also think it might be a message to young people to take it slow.
Does he have a grand father? I get the feeling that there could be a hidden blood relative to fill us in on his family background

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I kind of think Hee Sung will fight for Korea in the end, he does love his family but I have a feeling he doesn't like them either because of their values.

I see Eugene being quite conflicted, he does want to hug her back but due to their different status he can't really I guess? And Aesin doesn't even know he was a slave...

8
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

He could fight against the Japanese . As much as he might loath the old Korean class distinction, being used as a tool by the Japanese might gnaw at him even more.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I felt like pulling Eugene's hands towards Ae-shin UGHH

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

okay gotta take note of the poem

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap!

We are officially a third of the way through, and I (so-far) like the measured pace the storytelling is taking.

I think this is my second favorite episode so far - we got action, and the beginning of romance. I'm looking forward to the next episodes.
There are many to choose from, but my favorite scene today was that beginning, where Hee-sung got told about himself. I loved it to bits. And I feel like this is the first time Hee-sung has to actually face the legacy of his forebears' evil. Perhaps confronting it may make him a better person in the end, because this whole I-put-on-a-carefree-facade isn't working for me.

I am excited for the next 16 episodes and for all four leads journey to becoming. Let's hope there won't be any disappointment down the lines.

11
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That was my favorite scene too. I was even tearing up. I don't understand what people don't like about Eugene. I love his character and LBH is crushing it.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmmm - also on a kinda unrelated tangent, this is the first Kim Eun-sook drama where I am totally head-over-heels in love with the main couple. This is my 3rd drama that she wrote. I didn't care about Si-Jin and Mo Yeon from DOTS (I was way more invested in the second leads and the bromance), and I wasn't even interested in Kim Shin and Eun-tak's romance from Goblin (there again, I was invested in Reaper and Sunny's romance and the bromance). So Mr. Sunshine kinda marks a change for me. But I would like another unforgettable bromance if it can be had. Kthxbai.

10
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

OMG ladyjaye, I've read your comments since yesterday and I feel like we have exactly the same feeling about the show. Thank you for putting it into words!

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me too!! Should we form a club?

3
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I would like to join too! This is my favorite ongoing drama right now and definitely the best KES drama I've ever seen!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Count me in. I would like to join too.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me five! I never watched ANY of KES drama because I don't like typical overwhelming romance that I would never expect any in real life.
I found this one appealing because the problems which poured in this drama just enough and the romance is subtle yet rich and touching my heart.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

...count me in...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This weeks episodes were great with both the action and story and have been my favourite yet.

There was one scene which really hit me and it was the ending scene when AS and EC hugged. The shot was done in a way where AS lower half of her face was covered in EC arms and I thought that was beatiful ❤

In my opinion it mirrored when AS diguises herself as a freedom fighter and basically showed how with EC she could be herself and feel protected and open with him. In that scene he became her comrade and her heart was his. I just thought it was lovely and had to share my thoughts on it!

I realised that if any lesser actors were casted in these roles this would've been an alright show but this cast alleviate it for it to become a well-made and magnificent show and I am wholeheartedly ready to go with them on this journey!

19
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Totally agree with your comments. You said it so well.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Nicest comment on this forum so far!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

...totally agree -- the female lead is the WOW factor in this saga -- definitely punching above her weight...

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Maaajor heartbreak alert for Dong Mae. Although I already feel it, my heart ache for you Dong Mae.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel terrible for Dong Mae! That was kind of harsh of Aesin to speak to him like that. Why do I have a feeling he will die for her at the end? :'(

6
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

It will be the best closure for him, I can't see any better way.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

...she was harsh in the way she spoke to him...? he shot her after their eyes locked! the fact that he didn't kill her was redeemable?

5
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think he would have shot her if he was for sure the gunner was Aesin. I felt he shot her just to confirm, and too bad for him his suspicion was true. Like Aesin said, he won't be able to kill her

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

...so you shoot first and ask questions later...?

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not me, definitely it applies to Dong Mae

0

Not to mention he stalks her. I don't find his actions related to Ae Shin cute or swoony. They are downright scary. I think he's sexy in his interactions with Yang Hwa and when he is leading his gang around town. Even in his interactions with Eugene and Hee Sung. His voice is mesmerizing and he has gravitas ( I would say swagger but that doesn't due him justice).

12
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

*Ae Sin

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, I think it's creepy and weird that he stalks her, but maybe that's what he thinks love is, or express love. He didn't have a great upbringing and was outcasted in Joseon, pretty much he's hanging with the wrong crowd

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like him better with Yang Hwa too.
The scene when he grab Ae Shin skirt still gives me chill, yet not in a good way.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

...Not to mention she saved his life once...

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you so much, Llama. I've been refreshing this site for hours. (I watch the episode, then read the recap to see what I missed.)
I appreciate your efforts in recapping this drama!

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dong-mae is going to be the death of me. Those eyes; those lips. I don't know how any woman could stand with her face inches from Yoo Yeon-seok's face and not maul him with kisses; I know I wouldn't be able to stand the temptation. He plays Dong-mae with so much emotion, subtlety and tragedy. Every time his heart gets broken, I want to hug him (which would probably get me killed). I care more about his character than any other character in this show. Never in my life have I so badly wanted the bad boy to be the lead.

11
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

...well, I think being the lead for him would be a long shot... the actress who plays the lead (and also, like him, is considered a "junior" in the acting field), far outpaces him -- at the very least, she has more than just two expressions...

2
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

He already did become a lead, his last drama was Romantic Doctor Teacher Kim and he sure has more than just two expressions ¯\_(ツ)_/ ¯

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yoo Yeon-seok may be the Prince of Asia, oh sorry, that title belongs to Jang Geun Suk, however, Lee Byung-hun is an International Star -- need I say more...? You are right -- actually Yoo Yeon-seok has 3 expressions: sullen, smirk, half-a-smirk -- thanks for pointing that out in your stickman...

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0

You know what, I'll just let you do this childish act as you please. Have fun dragging Yoo Yeon Seok since you're so keen in doing it, as if it's a form of getting back when you're unhappy that people are praising him and not LBH. Since you seems to like dragging and fighting childishly like this, I'd also suggest you to visit Koalasplayground and camp in Mr. Sunshine related posts and you could use this negative energy of yours there.

0

He has played "the lead" in a couple of movies. Kdrama is not the only way an actor works in Korea. She was one of "the leads" in one of the most controversial about and critically acclaimed Korean movies in recent years, The Handmaid. None of the people in this drama are considered "hack actors". There are no idols in this one either. Personally, I think Lee Byun hun is getting too old to play 30 something anymore. I know his hasn't got a line in his face yet but he still looks like an older man. He's also playing the same guy he always plays, the brooding man of few words, icy stare guy. I guess in Korea that trope never grows old.

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

He's not playing 30 something. The age of his character is 40 which is his almost real age. He was 8 when the incident of his parents dying took place which is the same day Heesung was born who is 32 in the present day as per his mother. So 32+8=40

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same! Can YYS get the girl?

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

YYS already did get the girl in a few of his other works ㅋ Well here in this drama there is no way for him to get the girl and Dong Mae himself has resign and recognise that reality. His story with Ae Shin in here will be about him having a one sided love for her, how he will nurse his feelings on his own, and how he will wield his swords mostly for her. It's gonna be all about the angst and I'm so in.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

DM should have a spinoff drama.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Any woman?!! I would stay miles and miles away from DM and Yoo Yeon-seok! How can she like a violent murderer and traitor?!! She once saved his life and in return he turned out to be the enemy of his nation! How can she feels any sympathy for someone so cruel?!

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Of course I would never want to be around someone like Dong-mae in real life. But that's the beauty of dramas, a person can indulge in their love of the "bad boy" in complete safety. And I can understand staying away from Dong-mae, but I don't see any reason to stay away from Yoo Yeon-seok.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't remember the last time I was so utterly in love with the bad boy. Maybe never.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap dramallama! I’m curious - do you pronounce your name “dramaLama” or “dramaYama”?

Not gonna lie, I was kind of confused the first couple of episodes. But the story clicked for me about episode 3 or 4 and I now find myself more and more invested in these characters, their relationships and their futures. I agree with others - the main couple’s relationship is only meh for me, but I love love love Ae-shin. If I remember correctly, hasn’t this writer been criticized in the past for not having consistently strong female characters? If so, she seems to have corrected that issue with Ae-shin. Hopefully we will continue to see her strength, conviction, and sense of duty until the end.

And as much as I love Hee-sung, my heart is 100% with Dong-mae. Yoo Yeon Seok continues to impress me with his acting and his portrayal of this tragic character is ripping my heart apart. The scene in the shop with his hand touching and then grabbing her skirt, and the scene of him walking away in the rain, looking so utterly defeated was so poignant. And then to have him sitting on the train track, clicking his sword back and forth, willing her, begging her not to come made me even more sad. And to have Ae-shin gut punch him like she did - don’t hurt his heart AND his pride Ae-shin! (I know, I know, he DID shoot her in the leg...but, but it’s Yoo Yeon Seok...I just recently watched Reply 1994 and I can’t watch Chilbongie get hurt again. And I’m afraid he might end up dying as an act of sacrifice here...)

6
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

YYS is 😍😍😍

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've never watched any of his shows, but his Dong Mae is tearing me up here. I went into this drama for LBH, and I don't know, there's so much chemistry between Dong Mae and Ae Shin, two of them together in a scene just fills the air with so much tension and excitement. He shot her in the leg, and I liked it! What a twist! I didn't see that coming at all. It made his character even more fascinating, the fact that he shot her, despite suspecting that it was her. But he aimed for her leg, instead of her head, which showed he didn't want to kill her, but was testing to see if it was her.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

You should watch the movie Mood of the Day if you want to see a more upbeat YYS as the leading man. I may have watched it a few times...

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

He's adorable in Mood of the Day!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am absolutely baffled by the sympathy some people have for Dong-mae. The man is absolute trash. He's cruel and violent. I could not believe he actually shot Ae-shin after realising it was her. Even if it was just a suspicion, how can you shoot the woman you supposedly love???He seriously needs to sort out his life. Its not everyday feel sorry for yourself coz you had a horrible beginning. He 100% deserved Ae-shins' savagery.

15
21
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think he wanted to make sure it was Ae-shin but wasn't 100% sure. Dong-mae still had a job to do - and he's good at it - so if the shooter apparently wasn't Ae-shin, he could track him/her.

7
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just have to throw this in here - why is she "in disguise", jumping around rooftops with a VEIL fluttering behind her??? Very discreet and brilliant, everyone will definitely understand that's a man! 🤦🏻‍♀️

4
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's what I was wondering-- she could've hidden her hair in her hat. I guess they chose aesthetics over logic. Unless she's not trying to hide the fact that she's female?

3
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

...there are plenty of guys walking around with all kinds of ponytails...

1

Yeah, gotta love the manes of glory! But I'm pretty sure part of the deal for a man adopting western attire was cutting his hair.

Another Beanie pointed out what a big deal that was for Koreans at the time because they were raised with the Confucian idea that they shouldn't cut what their parents gave them. (I'm assuming fingernails and toenails were excluded from that rule).

1

For that matter, why is she disguised in (heavy) black, western clothing anyway when she'd blend in more easily on the ground disguised as a male peasant, with a braid? And possibly stand out less against the sky in white than in black? Seriously, don't ask. 😂
Maaaaybe it's easier to hide the long gun under a western coat.

2

@bbstl

Lol @ the impracticality of wearing a long, heavy coat while doing parkour.🤭 But you're right, it can definitely conceal her weapon easily. And probably no one would suspect that a man in western clothes would be a member of the Righteous Army, but then again, no man in western clothes would have a ponytail... 🤨

I think they just wanted her to look like a shexy ninja when she's jumping from roof to roof. I do like the the look of the coat and hat on her-- it reminds me of something Ingrid Bergman could've worn. 🕵️‍♀️

1

She needed the veil to help her fly across the space between the rooftops. Like Superman and his cloak.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, silly me! I didn't take aerodynamics into account 😉

0

I thought the same thing!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The veil also works like a safety net. It fans out from the base of her skull behind her head like a parachute if she were to suddenly take a tumble from the roof. Hope that helps. *beams*

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

...I guess she had to improvise last minute, since Eugene had previously unmasked and didn't return it... (it fit in his pocket)...

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

...sorry again typo -- "unmasked her"...

0

Yes, thank you. I agree. This will start his downward spiral, and I'm not sure he'll recover. It depends on what other circumstances affect his outcome whether or not he sees the light or hates Joseon even more.

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

...here, here! for DM it's all about power -- as in the incident with the hem of her skirt, he wanted to show her that he had power over her (and we did see the fear in her eyes) -- then when he shot her, knowing full well that it was her when they locked eyes, he again was trying to show that he had power over her, but this time she looked him straight in the eye and without a lick of fear relayed to him that she knew he had shot her on purpose (the great defender that he was) -- he's a bully and she would have none of it...

7
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didnt interpret the skirt pulling scene as a show of power, he was on the floor, she was standing up. He was just holding on to the edge of a skirt. To me, he is a pathetic fan boy of Aeshin who can never even dream of being spoken to kindly by her. Eventually he let go and walk out in the rain, leaving the shop before he finish what he needed to buy out of embarrassment perhaps for revealing his feelings to Aeshin.

In the scene where they show all the dreams of the 3 guys, his was just merely working for her. How pathetic can it gets.

As for the shooting, he doesnt know full well its her, if he did, he wouldn't have needed to go to the train station and verify it.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

...you can't judge that scene by today's standards...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

he knew and she knew full well that he purposely shot her -- didn't you see how big his eyes got when they both locked eyes on each other -- that was a sign of recognition... (...here's the show of power: "I can stop you lady" and he did - the blood spatter proved it -- however, it so happened that she and her team outfoxed him by removing her quickly, so that he couldn't find her to gloat over her); and then at the train station, she looked him straight in the eye, letting him know that she knew what he did -- his last words were after she brushed past him "you [already] know"...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love Dong Mae, but I love him being a reprehensible villain . . . with a core of pain . . . but still, a twisted and terrible killer for hire, hello? He is a really bad guy! That he's being played by an actor that people crush on so hard is getting in the way of the story IMO. No one on the street is confused about who he is! But I do wonder at him being able to wander about the hotel like a normal customer.

8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I understand why Dong-mae turned out to be a violent abuser, and a heartless murderer, but I feel ZERO sympathy for him!! He's cruel and violent, though I hope he redeem at least part of his bad deeds!

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree, he did have a terrible childhood, but that was mitigating factor, not justification for his current bad deeds. Just like in court, mitigating factorsmay reduce the defendent's sentence, not absolve his crime completely.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm pretty sure I was staring at the screen screaming HUG HER BACK YOU GIANT FOOL!!!!!!!! HUG HER BACK!!!!!!!! Otherwise, I'm glad the action is finally picking up a little. I still don't know where this is going but at least it's going somewhere!

9
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

HAHAHA I had the same reaction

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

So I wrote this song for Dong Mae because he’s breaking my heart, and I need to laugh...

Sung to the tune of I’ll Make A Man Out of You from Mulan

~ I’ll Make A Fan Out of You ~

Let’s get down to business, gotta win your heart
You’re a noble’s daughter, I’m a butcher’s son
I’m the saddest guy you ever met
But you can bet before we’re through
Miss Ae, I’ll scrub a pan just for you

I may look ferocious, but I’m a lamb within
Spend my free time sewing, crocheting and cooking
See this pumpkin from my backyard
That I planted just for you
Somehow, I’ll make a stew just for you

Me the man
I must be swift as a lightning cleaver
Me the man
With all the force of a steamed tofu
Me the man
With all the strength of a wok on fire
Mysterious as the dark spot on my spoon

Episode 8

What a wonderful episode, possibly the best in the drama so far. I loved the ending scenes so much.

- The roof scene where Dong Mae and Ae Shin lock eyes, and he widens his eyes in shock over the barrel of his rifle

- The scene where Dong Mae sits on the tracks, and keeps saying over and over, please don’t show up, please don’t show up

- When he says, she knows...

- Hee Sung standing in front of the tailor’s shop, staring, realizing the truth

- When Eugene says “Hug”, and she just flies to him, and hugs him so tight, so sad, it made me cry.

If you want to read more about Dong Mae, check out my fanfic at

https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1358280/mr-sunshine-dong-mae-s-story-love-revenge-socialdivide-turmoil

12
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

Love the song! :)

I will check out the fanfic as well.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks! 😁😁😁😁

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thk u! Now another show- related thing to do, in addition to rewatching earlier episodes while eagerly waiting for the weekend to turn up.

I am desperately trying to earn karma so i can upvote yr stories!

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

You are so nice, and I'm so happy you like my story. 😊

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Always happy to sing along with a YY song 🎶 even if our Dong Mae paths are diverging and I'm trying to let him follow his bliss as a stone cold killer 😏

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am crying me a river over our diverging paths. 😢😢😢😢

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sometimes these things happen, we must wait to see what *i>Fate has in store for him! We can still remain friends 👯 :)

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love the way you write. So much detail. I can imagine everything. So, The Fiancé is where you’ve stopped, right? I couldn’t read anything about Hee-sung yet.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you! I'm so happy you read my story. Haha. Yeah, stopped before Hee Sung makes his appearance in my head, and waiting for inspiration to kick in before I go on.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for posting the link to your fanfic! I'm enjoying it and never saw that site before. Fanfiction.net has finally added a category for Mr. Sunshine as well -
https://www.fanfiction.net/tv/Mr-Sunshine

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I see I'm not the only one that thought maybe there might be a poem from Kyle at the end that might end up making sense - and have meaning to the whole show! LOL!

I, too, wondered why Eugene did not hug Ae Sin back. I didn't think about the possibility that he was still very aware of their class differences.

I see Hee Sung putting all the pieces together bit by bit - I don't think it will be long before he's figured out what Ae Sin is up to.

If I was a man, I'd be head over heels for Ae Sin as well. I'm not surprised that she has three men in the palm of her hand.

I'm still amazed that there are so many viewers that aren't feeling the romance between Eugene and Ae Sin. I was on board from the moment their eyes met on the rooftop. Yes, Dong Mae is tragic - and I could see him ultimately sacrificing his life for hers at some point - but I don't see them ever being together as she sees him as a traitor to Joseon (and boy did she gut punch him with her words!). I'm still trying to figure out how Hee Sung's character will go. He seems to be disgusted by his family's cruelty....but will he end up becoming like them in order to secure Ae Sin as 'his' (he says he doesn't want to do anything with bad intentions *yet*), or will he step up and do something in order to make amends for his family because it torments him?

12
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Again, another agreement. It seems the writer is setting up Hee Sung's character to come around and join the Righteous Army.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

P.S. I haven't forgotten about your "Pretty Please" request re: Lee Byung-hun...

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

i didn't think the one side hug was about class isue. Eugine always mention about his slave parent when needed without hestitate

for me, that was about surender of love statement. It was like, "i'am all yours, without need to take back anything from you" how romantic the hug was, and eugine is such a gentelman.

I gues, we will have more posesif hugs first before kiss scene.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, he brings it up sometimes, but Ae Sin doesn't know he's a son of slaves. He does know what the class difference is between them even thought she does not. He doesn't know yet how she will react to the news once she knows either.
Your theory has valid merits too, and I'm willing to admit that I don't know for sure why Eugene didn't hug her back yet. I just know that I really wanted him to!

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think to him, his hugging her back would mean a commitment, for her it's still a mysterious adventure. Plus, at first I think he was just plain shocked. He didn't expect her to fly to him on a wounded leg or understand the English word HUG. SURPRISE!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Alphabet Romance was really cute. Im still Chilbodongmaed so my heart is still gutted along the railroad tracks where she basically shot him, albeit figuratively.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

...sometimes 2 shots do make it right..

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love Kyle!!! He’s such a sweetheart to balance Eugene’s stoic!

By the way, anyone can tell me how old Ae-shin is? Hee-sung might be around 30, Eugene in his late 30s, and I’m wondering how old Ae-shin is.. given the fact that she’s been training with Gunner Jang for 10 years.. So she might be starting really early..

5
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

I thought she was around 30 or late late 20s. Isn't she the same age as Hae sung? He's nine years younger than Eugene. And as time goes on and she changes her hair to an adult she'll look older.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hee-sung is 30, Eugene is 39, Ae-shin is 26.

1871 - Eugene was 9 years old, Hee-sung was born.
1875 - Ae-shin was born (So Eugene was 13 years old)

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

where did you find this info?

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I read through dramallama's ep 1 recap.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hee-sung is 32( remember the scene where his mom was telling his dad about his age).. Eugene would be about 41( he was nine when hee sung was born, hee sung mother went into labour the same day Eugene parents died) and Ae- shin would be 27(remember the scene in Tokyo where Wan-ik kill Ae-shin parents the year was 1875 and the present year is 1902 .

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes you're right, I forgot that the present year is 1902. But I think Eugene is then supposed to be 40, Hee-sung 31, and Ae-shin 27. Hee-sung mom might have mentioned 32 because Korean age is 1-2 years older than Western age.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

In Ep. 1, the present started in the year 1902 (When Eugene came back to Joseon). I think if we refer their age according to Korean age,

- Eugene is 41 (He was 9 in 1871);
- Hee Sung is 32 (Born in 1871, and his mother mentioned about him being 32 in earlier episode);
- Ae Shin is 28 (Born in 1875. She started training with Gunner Jang at 19 yo. When Gunner Jang said he trained her for almost 10 years, it was in ep 8 which I think is already 1903 in present time?)
- Dong Mae's age is not known but he should be around 2-3 years older than Ae Shin based on their child actors look?
- Hina's age is not known

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for this! I kept track of their ages during the earlier episodes but now I'm starting to lose track of what year is it as of the latest ones. So we're now in 1903?

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I assume so, since during convo between the Japanese soldier and the geishas including So-A, one of them said "it will be spring soon", which means they have entered a new year during ep. 7/8?

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, we are now in 1903, I was able cross-check it with some historical events (Korea buying the battleship) and character dialogue "spring will come soon".

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

If I'm not mistaken, according to Korean age a person is 1 when they are born. So if Eugene was 9 in 1871 that means he as born in 1863. Hee-sung would be considered 1 when he was born in 1871 (making him and Eugene 8 years apart not 9) and Ae-sin would be 1 when she was born in 1875. So in 1902 Eugene would be 40, Hee-sung would be 32, and Ae-shin would be 28 according to Korean age system.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

First week: Love mentioned
2nd week: handshake
3rd week: Hug
4th week: Kiss??
5th week...
I'm sorry you're not a huge fan of the main couple - I am a huge fan of the main couple.
And you're also getting Yoo Yeon-seok mixed up with Dong-mae. I'm a fan of Yoo Yeon-seok, but Dong-mae, not so much.
Maybe I should have mentioned first how much I appreciate your recap, esp when Kyle and Eugene are speaking English, because on Netflix the subtitles don't show up and I rely on them! And I miss stuff (a daydreamer, me) so I depend on you.
On to read others' comments. Thanks!

9
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I came around to be a huge fan of the main couple too! They're so compatible despite their different background, goals and age-gap...

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love it when Dongmae addresses Ae-shin as 'my lady'... Tugs at my heart all the time

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

...he also addresses Eugene as Sir...