212

Mr. Sunshine: Episode 13

It seems that everyone’s fate lies in someone else’s hands. In Ae-shin’s case, her fate relies on those who know her secret and whether they choose to protect her. Dong-mae’s fate seems to have always relied on Ae-shin, but he willingly gives it up to her. Hina’s fate relies on her father’s reach, and she desperately tries to escape his grasp. Much like Hina, Hee-sung’s fate lies in the shadow of his father and grandfather, though he seems to suffer through the fate befallen on him. As for Eugene, his fate seems to rely on everyone—his saviors, his known enemies, his unknown enemies, and his admirer.

 
EPISODE 13 RECAP

Eugene and Ae-shin ride through the hills on horseback on their way to the ocean. As Ae-shin catches up to Eugene, her hat flies off into the water, which is apparently the only thing disguising her as a man. Eugene puts his hat on Ae-shin, and she gets all giddy about him fixing the hat on her.

Ae-shin wonders if Eugene knows where they’re going, and he says that he’s following a map and heading east — toward the sun, into the fireworks. They laugh at his cheesy firework reference (what Ae-shin calls herself) and head on their way.

At the shore, Eugene prepares canned food, and Ae-shin comments that there are many fascinating things in this world: this novel food, the sound of the waves, and the horizon. She says that her imagination was limited and asks if Eugene misses anything in the U.S. beyond that horizon. He shares that he misses a few things, like the books, music, and hamburgers. (Googled it and yes — hamburgers were invented and popularized by this time.)

Ae-shin marvels at the canned food and asks if this hamburger tastes better than her current meal. Eugene finds her reaction adorable and watches her enthusiastically eat her meal. Ae-shin asks who he’s learning Korean from, and Eugene admits that Domi, the young boy worker at the embassy, is his teacher — a strict one, in fact.

She then asks who taught him English and wonders if it was the man he’s exchanging letters with (Joseph). Eugene explains his hardships in the U.S. and how everything seemed so big to him when he arrived — the land, the buildings, the people, even the sky. He followed Joseph because he believed that was his only way to survive. He says that he probably would have died without Joseph.

Ae-shin takes out the letter and offers to return it to him, but Eugene looks doubtful. She says that she can always take it back, so he snatches it out of her hand. Ae-shin asks why Eugene’s name is the same in Korean and English, and he explains that a name with the same pronunciation exists in English, meaning great and noble. Eugene credits Joseph for allowing him to live with this name. Ae-shin says that the name fits him, and Eugene jokes that he had a difficult time living up to it.

Ae-shin asks what Eugene will write in response to the letter, which asked how he’s doing with Ae-shin. Eugene says that he’ll write about going to the ocean but not seeing it because he was focused on seeing this one woman. He says that he’ll write that it’s unfair because this woman saw the ocean while enjoying canned food.

Eugene then offers coffee to Ae-shin, and she remembers it just being bitter. She takes a sip, and he asks expectantly if it tastes bitter today. Ae-shin says that the coffee tastes sweet today and says that she must be harboring a futile hope that she’ll one day travel further than she did today. Eugene asks where that is and if he’s there with her. Ae-shin confirms that he’s there because it’s just a dream.

Ae-shin’s servants worry about Ae-shin returning before dinner, and they cover up for her absence by fooling the other workers, claiming that Ae-shin is sick. Her maid pretends to serve their brewed medicine to sleeping “Ae-shin,” aka a lump of pillows, and chugs the whole thing herself. The two servants wink at each other as they successfully fool the young servant and distract her away from Ae-shin’s room.

Hina arrives at the pawnshop while the Il-shik and Choon-shik are working on her requested posters of her mother. She’s here with another job and asks if they can copy Dr. Machiyama’s stamp on her husband’s autopsy report. They ask who this Machiyama person is, and she warns them that it’s better to stay in the dark since she doesn’t intend to use this copy for anything good.

She notices the paintings of her mother, and Choon-shik lightly jokes that he can draw Hina’s mother with his eyes closed now because he’s painted so many posters. Il-shik scolds him and tells Hina that he hopes that they’ll hear news of her mother soon. Hina looks wistfully at her mother’s painting and says that her mother in the painting is now younger than her.

Dong-mae enters the bar and finds Hina drinking on her own. The host informs him that Hina has been drinking alone since before dark, and Dong-mae wonders what demons are chasing her to make her drink in such a bright and bustling place.

Each at their separate tables, Dong-mae and Hina take shot after shot in anguish. Dong-mae remembers Hina’s vow that she won’t stand losing anything more because she’s already lost her mother, her youth, and her name: Lee Yang-hwa. Dong-mae glances over his shoulder as Hina wipes her tears that she’s been hiding for so long.

Dong-mae carries drunk Hina home piggyback and asks if she’s going to stay carried even though she’s awake. She mumbles yes, and Dong-mae doesn’t seem to mind. She asks if she’s heavy, and he confirms that she is, with all that’s weighing on her heart. Hina says that Dong-mae drinks because time won’t pass fast enough, and she drinks because time goes too fast. This must be why bars never go out of business, she drunkenly wonders.

As Eugene enters the hotel, he tries to avoid eye contact with Kyle in the restaurant but completely fails. Kyle motions him over and asks where Eugene has been all day. Eugene nervously explains that he went to the east coast to strategically scope out the area when he had the chance. He asks Kyle if anything happened at the legation, and Kyle says that there was nothing — no Eugene, no horse, no canned food. Ha.

Kyle asks Eugene if he likes to eat documents, referring to the list of potential deployment locations that Eugene requested before he decided he wanted to remain in Joseon. Kyle assures Eugene that he dealt with Allen, the U.S. ambassador, about the issue and suggests that they conduct their regular check of firearms. Eugene chokes on his beer and nervously agrees to this.

At the ass crack of dawn, Eugene wakes the pawnshop duo and urgently asks if they have any bullets. The sleepy duo is clearly annoyed, but Eugene reminds them of the young slave boy shivering in fear, hiding in the box. Il-shik and Choon-shik show him their large pot of bullets and asks him how many he needs. Eugene looks surprised at their collection and says he just needs three.

At the firearm check, Eugene unloads him gun for Kyle with all the bullets. Kyle asks how many bullets Eugene used in his confrontation with the Japanese soldier, and Eugene reports that he used exactly three. Eugene belatedly realizes his mistake as Kyle asks why his gun is then fully loaded. Kyle shakes his head and says that those canned foods were his favorite, ha! In his petty revenge, Kyle sends Eugene running around the embassy in full gear as punishment.

As Eugene runs, Domi accompanies him and asks why he’s running this time. Eugene says that he miscalculated and responded with the wrong strategy. Domi can’t make sense of this, so Eugene shoos him away, too out of breath to explain further.

Near the trolley tracks, Hee-sung reluctantly meets with his father, who stages a run-in with Wan-ik through a deliberate rickshaw collision. His father, Nobleman Kim, introduces himself to Wan-ik and apologizes profusely for their collision. He also uses this opportunity to introduce Hee-sung and provides a gift of dried fish to Wan-ik for his ambassador role in Japan while Hee-sung studied abroad there.

Wan-ik suddenly seems interested in Hee-sung after knowing that he lived in Japan, and Nobleman Kim rambles on that Hee-sung is so modernized that he’s staying at Glory Hotel while in Joseon. Wan-ik asks about Hee-sung’s stay at the hotel, commenting on the hotel owner’s bad temper as a litmus test. Hee-sung responds that his stay and the owner are both great, and Wan-ik says that he’ll visit to have coffee soon.

Then, Wan-ik asks if Hee-sung is married — his real question all along — and Nobleman Kim says that his son is engaged to Go Ae-shin. Wan-ik doesn’t seem discouraged and says that an engagement isn’t a marriage. With that, he walks away with a satisfied smile.

As they walk through the street, Nobleman Kim tells Hee-sung that Wan-ik will help him secure a stable position, and that position will take care of him. Hee-sung remembers those same words coming from his grandfather and tries to hide his repugnance as he tells his father that he’s always been given this advice. Proud of his actions, Nobleman Kim leaves Hee-sung with a smile, and Hee-sung’s face falls as he hears the booming sound of his pocket watch ticking.

Ae-shin picks out some fabric for the young girl — now the worker at Glory Hotel — who wanted to make a vest for her younger brother, Domi. Ae-shin meets the girl at the bakery for more PPL rainbow cake and offers the fabric to her as a token of her gratitude for the girl’s loyalty. She’s referring to the girl’s refusal to reveal the identity of the person she gave the banknote to, and Ae-shin assures her that she protected something great.

We finally learn the name of this young girl — Soomi — and that she has four younger siblings. Ae-shin realizes that the fabric may not be enough, but Soomi says that it’s plenty to hand down the clothes. Later that night, Soomi stitches together a vest with the blue fabric and looks at it proudly.

The next day, Domi arrives at the embassy sporting his shiny new blue vest, and Kyle compliments him in English. Domi thanks him in English, and Eugene looks surprised that Domi can understand that much. Gwan-soo comments that Domi should know that much by now and disses Eugene by instructing Domi to teach their slow learner more Korean.

At the English school, the teacher shares good news of their anticipated school supply delivery at the embassy and asks for a volunteer to practice their English through a visit to the embassy. All the students shake their head in reluctance, but Ae-shin shoots her hand up, claiming, “I can do it!”

When Ae-shin arrives at the embassy, she yells at the passing soldiers, “Come here! Come here!” While the literal translation in Korean would work as a summon, her shouts don’t make any sense to any of the Americans. Eugene witnesses this and cringes hard before saving Ae-shin from further embarrassment. He receives the document from Ae-shin and corrects her summoning to “Excuse me,” trying his hardest not to burst into laughter.

Ae-shin claims that the school sent their best student to deliver this memo, and Eugene goes along with it even though he clearly doesn’t believe her. He calls for Domi and hands him the memo, and Ae-shin recognizes his new vest. She reveals that she knows his sister, Soomi, and Domi asks if she’s the beautiful and noble person who gifted his sister with the fabric. Ae-shin smiles at the flattering comments, and Eugene rolls his eyes at Domi’s way with words.

Domi thanks Ae-shin for her generosity, and Ae-shin uses this opportunity to tease Eugene for his elementary Korean. She tells Domi that Eugene hasn’t advanced to consonant attachments, and Domi regrets that they’re working hard on the basics. Ae-shin says that he probably could only write “come here” in Korean, since that phrase has no consonant attachments. Ha!

Domi admits that Eugene is a slow learner, considering his ambition, and Eugene gets flustered by this teasing. Ae-shin laughs at his reaction, and her maid notices how brightly she’s smiling. Later that night, the maid wonders if Ae-shin looks so beautiful whenever they go there because she likes Eugene.

The maid listens to Aunt drunkenly spill her hardships about living as the daughter-in-law of the Go family. She looks for her ring in her jewelry box, but it’s not there. Of course, it’s Ae-soon’s doing, and Aunt presumes that her daughter stole the ring when she was out at her archery meeting. She remembers hearing about Ae-shin being sick that day, and the maid nervously confirms that Ae-shin had all the snot and was coughing.

Aunt says that comparatively, her daughter Ae-soon is so great at informing them that she’s healthy by rummaging through the whole house for anything valuable. She demands that the maid find the ring before Ae-soon comes back to inform them that she’s healthy. The maid assures her that she will, and Aunt takes another shot of her drink.

Ae-soon arrives home with the ring on her finger and greets a baby boy upon arrival. Another woman swats her away, telling her to keep her gambling fingers away from her son. Then, Duk-moon (Wan-ik’s assistant and Ae-soon’s husband) arrives, and the other woman greets their husband, saying that their son was waiting for him. It seems that Ae-soon yields to this woman because she doesn’t have a child of her own. Ae-soon asks her husband if she should prepare his bath or dinner first, and Duk-moon just dismisses her, saying that it doesn’t matter.

Then, he stops and remembers his conversation with Wan-ik about Nobleman Kim. Duk-moon shares that Nobleman Kim is the wealthiest person in Hanseong after the emperor, but he has no wealth of customs or reputation. As a result, no family wanted to become in-laws with Nobleman Kim’s family, but Duk-moon says his in-laws promised the engagement because his sister-in-law (Ae-shin) has a questionable background. Since Ae-shin was an orphan and crossed over from Japan, her true ancestry is still uncertain.

Wan-ik asks if there’s any possibility of this engagement being broken and suggests to Duk-moon that his sister-in-law shouldn’t get in the way of his success. Back at the house, Duk-moon asks Ae-soon about the progress of Ae-shin’s engagement. Ae-soon hasn’t heard much after Hee-sung returned to Joseon, and Duk-moon rebukes her for not knowing anything.

Adding fuel to the fire, the other mistress tattles about Ae-soon’s gambling habit and takes glee in watching Duk-moon slap Ae-soon for being so useless. He criticizes her for not being able to bear a child and walks away fuming.

Ae-soon approaches the baby boy and takes out a piece of bread from the bakery, saying that she had some good fortune today. Her eyes are glued to the baby as he’s carried inside by a servant, and the mistress complains that Ae-soon only bought bread for the child. Ae-soon doesn’t seem to care about the harsh words and smiles proudly about the fruit of her winnings while rubbing her slapped cheek.

The rickshaw runner from earlier reports to Hina about Wan-ik and Hee-sung’s interaction as she smokes a cigarette. He shares that Wan-ik asked if Hee-sung was married, and Hina irritably says, “Oh fuck.”

Gwan-soo is dragged to Hwawollu, the fancy Japanese restaurant/geisha house, by his Japanese interpreter friend, and they meet with Duk-moon. Gwan-soo doesn’t know how to react to their meeting, since he has no business with Duk-moon, and he squirms uncomfortably between two geishas. Duk-moon asks Gwan-soo to report on the happenings at the U.S. embassy and shows him a big duffel of money as compensation for his work. Gwan-soo chokes on his drink and looks shaken by the sheer mass of money.

At the palace, Minister Lee insists that Emperor Gojong rest, as it’s late into the night, but Gojong says that he’d rather exhaust his body than be woken up by nightmares. Minister Lee offers to order medicine to help him sleep, and Gojong dismisses the rest of his servants from the court. Once they leave, Gojong admits his suspicions about everyone in this palace and their potential association with Japan. He wonders if he could be poisoned by the medicine.

Minister Lee shares some good news about their awaited missionary arriving in Jemulpo, but the emperor is still anxious about being manipulated in the hands of the Japanese. He needs to urgently meet with the U.S. ambassador in China for a loan to build their own railroads before Japan seizes them.

Ae-shin checks the secret medicine cabinet for correspondence from Eugene, and she laughs when she sees that Eugene had simply written words with complex consonant attachments. She responds with, “Good job,” and Eugene laughs in delight. Ae-shin reads another letter from Eugene asking if she needs a rower for the boat, and he adds that there are eleven characters with consonant attachments in this letter.

Eugene and Ae-shin arrive at Eun-san’s home, and the apprentice is ordered to collect the broken bowls as usual. Eugene gives Eun-san a bag of beer, and Ae-shin asks if she can have one. Eun-san refuses to share and says that rich Ae-shin can go buy them herself. Ae-shin can’t believe that Seung-gu is friends with petty Eun-san, and she mutters audibly that Eun-san isn’t that great of a ceramist considering he has so many broken bowls every time.

Eugene asks if Ae-shin knows who she’s talking to, and we revisit Eugene’s sudden epiphany of the Righteous Army’s connections. Ae-shin seems completely unaware of Eun-san’s identity, and Eugene just warns her that she’ll regret this later. When Eun-san walks away to hurry his apprentice, Ae-shin tries to grab a bottle furtively from the bag. But Eun-san catches her in the act and tells her to put it down, saying that he counted exactly seven bottles.

As they walk with the bowls, Eugene shares with Ae-shin that he belatedly realized that many people helped him escape Joseon, including Eun-san and the pawnshop duo. Ae-shin says that she should treat Eun-san better, but she still thinks that he was super petty with the beer.

Eun-san watches the two with a beer in hand and wonders why Ae-shin needs a rower to accompany her if they can walk across the frozen river. He seems to suspect the answer and looks upon them with concern.

Ae-shin compliments Eugene’s improvement in Korean, and she laughs at the mention of his two words with complex consonant endings. Eugene stops to soak in her laughter, and he says that he likes to see her laugh, but fears that he may make her cry. He then shows her the photo from Kim Yong-joo (the man who betrayed Ae-shin’s parents and attacked Eugene at the hotel), but Ae-shin doesn’t recognize anyone in the photo.

Eugene reveals that one of the names of the people in the photo caught his attention: Go Sang-wan. At the mention of her father’s name, Ae-shin stares at the photo intently and admits that she didn’t know her father’s face. She says that she was told that her father met a woman in Japan and married humbly before giving birth to Ae-shin. They died soon after, and Ae-shin was sent to her grandfather.

Ae-shin tears up as she looks at the photo and says that she’s been told that she has her father’s eyes and his stubborn expression is the same as hers. Her maid had never seen Ae-shin’s mother, so she said that they could see her mother by taking out her father’s features. Ae-shin correctly identifies her father in the photo and says that she knows that this is him. She cries, and Eugene reaches his hand out to wipe her tears, but he can’t get himself to make contact.

Later that night, Ae-shin asks her maid to tell the story again — the one that starts with getting married at seventeen. As she brushes Ae-shin’s hair, the maid retells the story of being married at seventeen and arriving as a servant at this house, and first meeting Ae-shin’s father, who was fifteen at the time. He was handsome, smart, and kind to all the servants, so they all adored him.

Ae-shin thinks back to her conversation with Eugene, who took back the photo for his investigation of one person in the photo who attacked him. Ae-shin couldn’t fathom how one of her father’s friends would have any reason to attack Eugene, and he told her that the most probable explanation is that this attacker was also a traitor. He promised to share any information from his investigation with Ae-shin, as this is her only source of information on her parents.

Back to her maid’s story, Ae-shin tears up as she listens to her maid marvel at Ae-shin’s resemblance to her father whenever she gets stubborn.

Ae-shin’s grandfather stares into the night sky and wonders how much longer he’ll live. Grandfather sends his servant on an errand to retrieve items from the paper shop and find out more about where Hee-sung is staying.

A man tries to exchange Japanese money at the pawnshop, but Il-shik and Choon-shik refuse to accept it. They point to the sign on their door and claim that they don’t exchange Japanese money because of their patriotism. The man finds this ridiculous, but the duo sticks to their resolve. After the man leaves, Il-shik comments that the prevalence of Japanese money seems to indicate that a war may actually be looming and tells Choon-shik to look into the price of gold.

Dong-mae’s lackeys watch over the Righteous Army member they released, and at the dojo, Yujo asks what they should do about their men stationed in Gangwondo watching this man. It seems that this Righteous Army member is staying low and not receiving any correspondence from the organization. Dong-mae comments that this man knows how to function in an organization and wonders if he should just leave him be.

When Hee-sung arrives at the hotel, the receptionist informs him that a guest has been waiting in his room. Hee-sung enters his room to find Ae-shin’s grandfather waiting for him, and he apologizes for making him wait. He immediately bows respectfully in greeting and sits with him to discuss his engagement with Ae-shin.

Hee-sung apologizes for visiting Ae-shin without realizing that he broke traditions, but Grandfather is wise and understanding about Hee-sung’s actions. He knows that Hee-sung stayed in Japan for so long to escape the shadow of his grandfather, and Grandfather says that he allowed for this engagement because of this disposition. Grandfather says that Hee-sung should now take Ae-shin’s hand in marriage.

But Hee-sung thinks back to Ae-shin’s insistence on breaking their engagement, and he lies to Grandfather that he doesn’t like Ae-shin. Expressing the complete opposite of what he feels, he says, “The way she smiles, walks, her every glance, her every touch — I don’t like anything about her.”

Knowing Ae-shin, Grandfather says that she probably told him harsh things to break their engagement, but he asks that Hee-sung embrace all of that. Grandfather fears that he may not have much time left, and he asks Hee-sung to protect Ae-shin if anything happens to him.

As Grandfather makes his way on carriage, the servant notices Eugene approaching them on horseback, and he turns his head away to avoid recognition. Eugene hangs his coat in his hotel room, and the red pinwheel drifts to the ground. He stares at it as if it were foreshadowing some looming mission.

That night, Grandfather writes letters asserting that the Japanese are trying to use their currency to buy Joseon and its people, which will lead to a loss of sovereignty. The servant sends the letters at the post office, and the owner of the post office reads this letter, trembling as he reads Grandfather’s summoning of all the nobles to break their silence and gather at the end of the month to discuss their plan of action.

The post office owner brings this letter to Wan-ik, who seethes at this unexpected source of rebellion. He orders the post office owner to burn all the letters and vows to bury Grandfather in his grave soon.

Eugene oversees the arrival of U.S. goods at the port, and he runs into Dong-mae, who’s on his way to another job. They greet each other but stand awkwardly in silence next to each other. Dong-mae comments that they have nothing to say to each other in this uncontentious situation outside of their usual run-ins at the bar or while rummaging Eugene’s room. Eugene thinks likewise and tells Dong-mae to make lots of money. Dong-mae walks away and wonders if he should have made small talk about the weather, and Eugene notes that Dong-mae didn’t tell him to “take care” this time.

Dong-mae meets with his client at the Japanese embassy, who requests more police forces at the embassy. He seems worried about the Joseon mobs destroying the railroads and revolting, and Dong-mae listens curiously.

Joseph arrives at the U.S. embassy and leaves a bottle of liquor on Eugene’s desk. Domi arrives with tea, but Joseph tells him that he needs to leave and asks that he just deliver the bottle to Eugene.

On the train, Gwan-soo picks leaves from branches, trying to decide if he should accept the money from Duk-moon. Eugene watches this bizarre hysteria and later asks Gwan-soo what he was doing with all those leaves. Gwan-soo comes clean and reveals to Eugene that he was offered a large sum of money to report on the U.S. embassy as well as information on Allen and Eugene.

Gwan-soo expresses huge relief for finally telling Eugene the truth and says that it was worth losing the money. But Eugene tells Gwan-soo to take the money, since Duk-moon will likely solicit others at the embassy if Gwan-soo rejects the offer. Gwan-soo wonders to what extent he should report to Duk-moon, and Eugene suggests that he only tell the truth, like the fact that Eugene is smart, with a good voice and good looks. Gwan-soo adds that Eugene can’t read Korean, and Eugene corrects that to “currently learning Korean.”

Ae-shin thinks about the photo of her father, but her thoughts are interrupted by her servant delivering a letter from the temple. The monk writes about a suspicious man in a kimono asking about Ae-shin and sitting in front of the mortuary tablets of Ae-shin’s parents. Ae-shin seems threatened by Dong-mae’s investigation of her, and she makes moves to get him off her tail.

Ae-shin writes a cryptic letter to Hina requesting to meet, and they meet once again at the PPL bakery. Ae-shin asks to borrow money from Hina, and Ae-shin says that she’ll need to threaten her if Hina refuses to lend money. Hina doubts that the threats will work and says that Ae-shin will be more inconvenienced if she reports their run-in as thieves to the police, but Ae-shin says that she’ll reveal that she had a comrade to Wan-ik.

Ae-shin remembers the autopsy report that Hina took from Wan-ik’s house, and Hina correctly guesses that Ae-shin is indebted to Dong-mae, since nine out of ten debtors owe money to Dong-mae. Hina offers the money to keep Ae-shin silent about their secret, but she offers a mere coin. Ae-shin says that she has that much too, but Hina says that this amount should be enough since this will be a personal matter.

Ae-shin arrives at the dojo thanks to Hina’s intel, and Dong-mae motions his gang to leave. Dong-mae comments that Ae-shin must be interested in him to find him here, but Ae-shin corrects him to say that she’s wary of him — the person who demanded that they meet in person to repay a debt, the person who shot her leg.

Dong-mae confirms that he did shoot her, and Ae-shin asks if he plans to sell her over to the Japanese. But Dong-mae says that he intends to do nothing. Ae-shin doesn’t believe him and asks why he followed her tracks to the temple. Dong-mae insists that he mistook her that day and plans to continue to mistake her for someone else. If someone clearly recognizes her, he plans to kill that person. He claims that he needs to know Ae-shin better to protect her, so that’s why he tracked her down to the temple.

Ae-shin doesn’t want his protection, but Dong-mae reminds her that she saved his life without his permission when they were children. He asks for the money, and Ae-shin drops a bag of coins on the ground. Dong-mae takes only one coin — just as Hina had predicted — and returns the rest. He says that he won’t investigate the girl or the receiver of the banknote any further since he’s now accepted payment, and he tells Ae-shin that he’ll receive a payment every month.

Ae-shin asks if this means that Dong-mae plans to see her for their whole lives, and Dong-mae confirms this, as long as Ae-shin keeps him alive. She predicts that he won’t be able to receive all the money, and Dong-mae says that those words hurt. But he assures her that he’ll heal on his own.

At the embassy, Eugene happily reads over the letter from Joseph. Domi runs to him with the bottle that Joseph brought, and Eugene says that Joseph will likely visit again during his missionary rounds. Domi wonders what he’s reading, and Eugene plays the role of teacher now, instructing Domi to sit up straight while translating the English words.

Then, the post stamp on Joseph’s envelope catches Eugene’s eye, and he remembers the same stamp from the Hamgyeong post office on the envelope he found in Kim Yong-joo’s room. Then, Gwan-soo runs toward him with breaking news about an American man’s body found in Jemulpo. The Hanseong police have now recovered the body, and they believe it was murder.

Eugene makes his way to the police station and slowly walks toward the covered body. He notices the cross in the dead man’s hand, the same one that he carved for Joseph in his youth. Trembling, Eugene folds over the mat to reveal Joseph’s face.

Overwhelmed with sorrow, Eugene kneels down next to Joseph, and he thinks about his upbringing. We hear Joseph’s narration as we see Eugene growing up with him: “As I cut your hair and apply mere medicine to your wounds, I prayed to God to grant this foreign child freshly baked bread and clean water, to reap cold and provide warmth.”

Eugene holds Joseph’s hand and weeps, asking how they’ve been reunited like this. In his narration, Joseph adds, “It was wrong of me to say ‘mere medicine,’ as it was quite expensive for a missionary. I miss you, Eugene. I learned how to make alcohol, and I’ll try not to drink all of it on my way to Hanseong. Great and noble one, my son… wherever you are, I will pray for you.” Joseph signs off by hoping that God will be with Eugene even on nights when he doesn’t pray for him.

 
COMMENTS

Ah, yet another reason to feel sorry for Eugene. I do sympathize with all the misfortune that Eugene has endured through his life, and it’s definitely shaped him to be the resilient Joseon-American whose hyphenated identity is often his greatest strength but also his greatest weakness. I do wish we had fleshed out more of Eugene’s relationship with Joseph and what exactly Joseph did to get himself killed. I presume that mystery will unfold with an investigation of his murder, but I feel like we were deprived of any hints to keep us interested in Joseph’s association to the story other than as a surrogate father to Eugene.

I am finding the interactions between Dong-mae and Ae-shin a bit repetitive now, so it was nice to have Dong-mae expressing his feelings to Ae-shin, albeit indirectly and with a confusing animosity. I think that Ae-shin still got the message that Dong-mae intends to protect her, but from her perspective, I can see how Dong-mae’s duality is quite difficult to read. He demands money, threatens, and kills, yet he’s fiercely loyal and protective. As a viewer, it’s really intriguing to watch, but I wouldn’t want to be Ae-shin, trying to figure out if this traitor wanted to kill me or protect me. Either way, I’d be frightened, and I prefer swooning from the the other side of the screen.

I think Dong-mae has the most poetic role in this show — everything he says replicates poetry because it feels so charged and loaded. He doesn’t say much, but he doesn’t need to because he just carries this aura of pain and complexity. Hina comes in as a close second, and seeing them together at the bar was one of my favorite scenes in this episode. They’re kindred lost spirits wandering together, and something about it gives me real — not futile — hope.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , ,

212

Required fields are marked *

This episode just plodded along. I realized this when I noticed that I was more interested in the authenticity of the beer bottle labels than I was in the dialogue. There were some idiotic plot holes too, like the whole incident with Eugene's bullets.

Oh, there were some cute moments, but overall just ho-hum (except the final scene, of course). Was I the only beanie who felt the meeting scene between Ae-shin and Dong-mae fell flat? Ok, so he's going to protect her but also be cruel to her at the same time? Hmmm, that's obsession, not love. I was really expecting more from this highly-anticipated scene.

The trip to the beach had the flirting and light-heartedness that I expected, but there was also a dreamy "playing on borrowed time" feeling to it. I agree with @lukeswerrthing in that both Eugene and Ae-shin know they are living in the moment, the calm before the storm. They want to build some memories while they can, before that storm comes. And they have set boundaries on how far they will let themselves go in this happy time.

Eugene's tragic reunion with Joseph was really hard to watch. Lee Byung-hun really acted his heart out in this scene.

19
32
reply

Required fields are marked *

For someone as smart as Eugene, missing the 3 bullets logic was ridiculous. But I guess they are playing to the galleries?

I for one liked the interaction between AeShin and DongMae. Finally he made his intent clear. Yes, he also had the scorn on his face but at least she knows he has no intention of betraying her. She believed he won’t betray her(as mentioned in an earlier episode while talking to Eugene), but hearing from him directly settled any confusion. Also, did the writers hint that he will not live long?

8
15
reply

Required fields are marked *

Eugene missing three bullets really bothered me. They still could have had the bullet scene but with Eugene outsmarting Kyle.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Could you explain the three bullets logic? Why'd he go buy more?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think the writers hinted that She would not live long, or at least she believes that.

She said she would not be able to pay him in full, so she would die first.

At least I think...

3
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

Nope, AeShin definatley knew that Dong Mae has feeling for her. She replied not being able to pay him in full as an indication of rejecting Dong Mae's affection. Thats why Dong Mae replied by claiming that he's hurt.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think it's the other way around. Dong Mae is clearly getting lots of death flags in the series and this is one of them. It's not a perfect translation (please correct me if I'm wrong) but this is how it went between them:

애신: 지금 나를 평생 보겠다는 건가?
동매: 예. 그말입니다. 애기씨께서 저를 계속 살려두신다면요.
애신: 자넨 그 돈을 다 못받지 싶어.
동매: 그리 말씀하시니 퍽 아픕니다. 허나 걱정마십시오. 제가 잘 알아서 아물어보겠습니다.

Ae Shin: Are you saying that you're going to see me forever right now?
Dong Mae : Yes. That's what I'm saying. If you keep me alive.
Ae Shin: It seems like you'll not be able to receive all the money.
Dong Mae: Hearing you saying that hurts me so much. But do not worry. I'll look into healing it well by myself.

The way I see and interpret it, when Ae Shin was saying that she thinks Dong Mae will not be able to get all the money she owed him, it indicates that she doesn't think she'll let him live for long, hence Dong Mae claiming that he's hurt. Dong Mae already knew that she didn't like him and wanted him dead, but was happy when she said she wanted him to live when he slapped him. It's just that this time he's hurt to hear from her that she doesn't think she'll let him live for long enough for him to collect all the money?

10
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

This show more than any other makes me wish I could speak, read, and write Korean. I'm stuck with Netflix' captions. -sigh-

2

Thanks so much!
I feel so many things are lost in translation.

2

Thanks for this translation. The writing isn't bad, I guess I just had set my expectations too high in anticipating this scene.

2

That's interesting, I interpreted it as (with questionable Netflix subtitles and no understanding of Korean)

Dong-mae has pledged his devotion and implicitly his love to Ae-shin, this isn't a debt she can ever return. The rejection hurts, but he is working separately on getting over his feelings for her. He characterises it as a 'wound,' Hina calls it a 'weakness' either way his attachment to Ae-shin is a vulnerability that puts his life at risk.

Dong-mae is always trying to do 'nothing,' when it comes to Ae-shin but like a magnet to a compass his life has been thrown into disarray and it's probably been in disarray since their first meeting when she saved his life.

6

AS told EC to bring her across the ocean that took a month to reach. Wasn't it America?
AS and EC love is taboo in Joseon but not if in America. So, on the narrative that she can't pay DM whole life (his/hers) is because she planning to be with EC to a blissful life in America.
AS mentioned twice about going away from Joseon to EC and both times EC gave a doubtful solemn look. Now that look bothers me

2

@78semra / hangsang nae ma-eum-e - I took noticed that. I wasnt sure what to make out of it. Are they just dreaming of going away knowing very well that wont happen?

1

Netflix translated the Dong-mae/Ae-shin something the effect of Ae-shin doesn't think she will be able to pay back his debt rather than he won't be able to receive all his money back.

Watching it I just assumed that it meant she can't reciprocate his feelings.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I’m a little late to the game but could someone explain why Eugene went and bought three extra bullets? I’m definitely missing something here and it’s bothering me

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Please read below comments from Tim
And the one above that.

It’s been a while and I don’t remember well. I think he shoots Tsunga thrice. It gets accouted for. But he buys the 3 bullets later. I think he ends up with extra bullets during the second inspection. Basically an oversight on Eugene’s part. Something dumb like that.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Why was it a "Ha!" moment? (Based on the recap above). I was wondering if I was missing something. Was he trying to keep it a secret from Kyle?

0

The beers that Eugene gave to Eun-san in ep 10 were Baltimore's American Brewery, while the ones in this ep were Budweiser perhaps (only got a glimpse of the label). I think the labels were pretty accurate.

I agree with you and @dramallama, Ae-shin and Dong-mae's interactions are repetitive and in this ep it bores me a little bit tbh. They are not making much progress in their relationship (Ae-shin being wary and borderline hostile towards Dong-mae, and Dong-mae being obsessed with Ae-shin).

I'm glad Eugene has his turning point at the end of this ep. So far, Eugene's actions were mostly driven by either his revenge or Ae-shin (returning bank certificate and saving geisha) that coincidentally corresponded with Joseon's interest. But since now it's Joseph who died, it'll be even more difficult for Eugene because he might become everyone's enemy. Ultimately, it will be interesting to see Eugene's conflict of his standpoint between Joseon, US, and personal interest.

Just to add, I'm still waiting for Hui-sung to make his move as well. We've got some great development with Hina, and I hope Hui-sung will get his spotlight or a major role. Possibly a double agent for Righteous Army and Wan-ik.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I researched all the beer bottle labels that I can identify and posted images on my fan wall. Thanks for your info too.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This ep beer was from Centlivre Brewing Company
https://brookstonbeerbulletin.com/historic-beer-birthday-louis-centlivre/

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The the gallop over golden fields, the shining horses, the breathing and sound of hooves. Two interesting people who are smitten but ever so restrained. Quite the contrast to the race across the weeds. But at the end of the conversation when she says someday she would like to travel farther and EC says "am I there with you" and she says " I wish it to be so" then there is this clunky shift and refocus to the kettle over the fire. Its so odd. Is it a camera error? It looked to intentional for that. Is it a symbol of togetherness???? I'm over thinking it right?

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

They probably had another scene where they brew coffee, but it was edited.

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hina spoke in an earlier episode about three types of coffee-related hopes

That's what Ae-shin remembers

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0

I missed the three types of coffee related hopest . Which episode?

0

This episode felt like a waste of time with nothing really telling, plot-wise. Some cute moments here and there which felt a bit forced, like the writer has some cue cards which read 'inject humour here'.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It really did feel like a mostly 'filler' ep.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

DM got my heart though. He could have gotten Grandpa Go into trouble but he didnt. He bared his soul to AE's parents. He stood up for his men and fortune teller friend, at great cost to himself.

Poor bad boy just doesnt know how to behave in front of his crush except to slash those who insult her (ep 3) and to make biting remarks at her frm when they first met to every other meeting...
his fault for putting her on a pedestal i suppose.

10
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I found this fan made Dong mae video beautiful.
https://youtu.be/QO9qH6ehH_Y

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Actually, the whole bullet scene is FOR REAL what soldiers do. They must have their equipment checked and monitored by their superiors. Having more or less bullets than you should is reason for heavy punishment. More bullets clearly indicate back-end purchases of illegal weapons, and less bullets indicate excessive use of force without notifying your superior officer.

They played it off as a joke, but it's actually not. (But, also, rules were a little more lax, then.)

And thank you for the mention, they both needed that respite for the coming pain of Part 2.

Lee Byunghun had me crying my eyes out with him; both via narration and his own tears. He presented a powerful scene of sorrow and horror. I was deeply moved.

4
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Didn't the time lapse between the incident with Sgt. Tsuda and this firearm inspection bother you? It did me. Eugene's pistol was discharged 3 times in the confrontation with Tsuda, and that event happened weeks (or possibly even months) prior to the firearm inspection in this episode. Since the incident with Tsuda was officially investigated, it seems logical that the bullets fired by Eugene's pistol would have been previously accounted for, documented with Kyle, and replaced. We have been shown that Eugene understands the danger that surrounds him, so I can't believe he would have carried around a half-loaded gun for so long.

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

My theory is that scene was intended to set up a future situation in which Eugene will need to get his hands on bullets -- all kinds of bullets -- for all kinds of guns. We shall see. I agree that it was a clunky and awkward scene.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Was expecting that Eugene would have to surrender his gun after the Tsuda incident whilst the investigation is ongoing. Heh.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved the meeting of Ae shin and Dong mae but maybe that's because my subtitlors were either more exact or more creative having Dong mae day he'd pop the eyeballs out of anyone who threatened Ae shin. 👀

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I enjoyed this episode more than the last one. I'm glad the writer didn't drag out whether or not Gwan-soo would betray Eugene. And I like Hee-sung and Dong-mae more and more as the drama unfolds. The whole cast is interesting to get to know (and watch develop.) I never would have thought I'd feel sympathy for Ae-shin's gambling cousin. But I do. With a husband and his fertile nasty wife--I can see why she acts how she does.

9
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I do feel bad for Ae-soon too. But if I were her, I'd get my husband's money, pretend to gamble but buy gold instead (like the pawnshop duo), and stash it somewhere (probably in her mother's house). Lol. :)

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I can't. I pity her life situation but it's no excuse to be a [w]itch, thief and tattletale to her immediate family.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

The writer certainly knows how to write cheesy dialogue. Most of the rest I fast forwarded through.
On to episode 12 - the first episode I actually watched the whole thing instead of rolling my eyes and fast forwarding.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oops, I meant episode 14.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me, The key scene in this episode was the interaction between go-grandpa and Hee-Sung. I finally understood how well grandpa knew Hee-Sung to entrust his grand daughter to him. It was a very sad scene. Hee-Sung painfully rejecting her and the grandfather asking him to accept her knowing the situation. I fear for grandfather’s life. I hope he and Ae-Shin have some interactions about her father before his time comes.
It’s a mystery how grandfather chose such a ass son in law for the cousin.

14
14
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm also worried about the grandfather. Wan-ik is so evil he'll probably take every chance he gets to destroy grandfather.

5
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

It actually hurt me a lot thinking about Ae-shin's elderly grandpa toiling all night to write out all those letters only for none of them to be sent out. He'll be so disappointed when no response comes.

8
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

i know I shdnt fault for his snobby, pragmatic ways... for only caring for his family and treating everyone else below him as mere trifles - frm his slaves to his tenant farmers. that he is only a product of his times... but somehow I dun feel very sorry tht he has now come under Lee Wan-ik's machinations.

he represents all that is rotten with Joseon society - those who were once powerful and exploited others to amass even more power... getting his just desserts if i may be so mean to say so

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

But the one who did those bad deeds towards his slaves and tenant farmers was Hui Seong's grandfather and not Ae Shin's. Both are two different men

8

Ae shin's grandfather, while like you said is a product of his time, but he hasn't been shown to be cruel. You may be confusing him with Hui sung's grandfather.

1

no kidding! AE's and HS's grandfathers are not one and the same person? lol lol lol I got to go rewatch...

1

omg u guys are rt!!! they are 2 different people. lol my bad

1

@lizmesenas21/Dizzylizzy, ha ha. In the first few episodes I could not tell one grandpa from another - they all looked the same. HS's grandfather is dead though.

1

I don't think the writer is so subtle that we can't easily pick up hints and foreshadowing. He's probably gonna die next week.

10
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lol :))

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Another reason for Ae Sin & Eugene to grow closer as well - since Eugene lost his 'father' this episode. That makes sense. Bye bye to Go-grandpa, I guess

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Completely agree. And yeah I loved that part. Grandpa saw completely through Hee-Sung, and even when Hee-Sung said how much he didn't like Ae-Shin, grandpa was like, 'yeah i know you're lying and i know Ae-Shin is driving this, but please protect her anyway.' Shows how clearly he knew her.

Hope they spend a few minutes fleshing that out a little (Grandpa / Ae-Shin), cuz Ae-Shin is so lonely for her parents.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

yeah. Go-Grandpa has his methods/contacts because he is a noble. He has to transfer that knowledge/wisdom to Ae-Shin. I really don't want him to die without helping Ae-Shin find some understanding about her dead parents. I know they both had frequent fights when she was growing up. But its time they sit down and have a talk.

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's probably all he could get for Ae sun! Besides her being generally unpleasant, remember azzhat son-in-law said something about their family having money but something else negative that I can't remember that made the girls less than the best marriagesble material. With Ae shin, I know it was her mother's lack of status but I can't remember what the other thing was about the family. Maybe their "liberal" stance with sons dying in the righteous army (of that's a well known fact that that's how they died)?

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was bored watching most of this episode. The sea scene was boring. I sat, unmoved, and was wondering when they were going to move on to the next scene. Then, I started wondering about the horse's backstory. Where did it come from? Did it understand English? Or Japanese? What did it eat to give it the strength to ride such a long ways to the beach? Hay? Horsefeed? See, I was that bored.

Dong Mae's date with Ae Shin didn't do much for me. So he's going to blackmail her for more meetings in exchange for her silence. Weird. Maybe he'll blackmail her into sleeping with him next - I hope so, anyway, because if they keep doing this ploddy, uninspiring meet-ups where he mocks, and she snipes at him, I am so going to grab myself a black horse and gallop into the sunset.

The only thing that worked for me was Hee Sung and the grandfather scene. It was very moving, how he listed all the things he detested about her, and those sad, sad eyes. Poor baby, Ae Shin should just hurry up, and marry him.

I did like the gambling cousin's scene with the husband and the mistress. Now I understand her, and her gambling - the scene helped a lot, and she has suddenly become a character to sympathise with for me.

13
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not Hee Sung. Even if he wants to redeem his family and follow through for Grandpa's sake he is Hee Sung.

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

i like Hee Sung though. He has more depth than meets the eye. He has always been conflicted about his granddad's and dad's ways but the one thing he is unwavering about is his commitment to protect AE

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

but i dont want AE and HS to end up together. I would like AE to end up with no one actually.

just the 5 of them as great friends leading the next wave of the Righteous Army lol

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agree with the part on gambling cousin. I felt sorry for the way she was treated by her husband, and yet she was so sweet to the boy immediately after.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Since Ae shin is Kdrama destined to be with Eugene *yaaaawn* or Hui sung *fun & goofy times*, I'd be happy for 15 more scenes of Dong mae not knowing what to do with his feelings and Ae Shin disgusted, but secretly, way down deep somewhere, intrigued. She's only human.
I'm reposting this Dong mae/Ae shin video because I hope everybody gets to see it. https://youtu.be/QO9qH6ehH_Y

2
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's not my video. I just saw it on YouTube and thought it was gorgeous.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Great video! says it all in a nutshell. Tell the truth, would you want someone as violent and emotionally disturbed as DM interested in your whereabouts all the time? That would be a noooooo! Burn that silk skirt. but now she owes him money, which I don't really buy into. Its really blackmail to withhold information about the Russian bank certificate's route to the King. She is paying for his silence with 25 cents and a monthly visit. That in its self is way off the end of the creep-o-meter gauge.

1
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Absolutely! The practical side of me knows you have to nip stalkers in the bud... immediately! Nothing good can come of it. If these characters lived in reality, her meeting Dong mae once a month would come down to a duel to the death between him and Eugene. Or, if Eugene never found out, possible rape due to Dong mae's delusional state where he interprets Aeshin's continuing to meet him as a form of her willingness to engage in a relationship. All kinds of messed up crap could happen! But for now, I'll continue to appreciate the fantasy Dong mae gives with his bad boy, willing to "pop the eyeballs out of anyone who threatens you" (that's what the subs I watched said although no recappers seem to have seen that). lol

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh yeah, I forgot about the eyeball thing. Yes that was in ith subs alright.
No, Eugene will definitely step up and teach DM what he learned in the Marines if AS has misjudged her ability to manage this situation.

1

@lamastonished But who knows what the U.S. military hand to hand combat training was like in early 1900's (@tacourtn)? My impression is that our (U. S.) military incorporated techniques learned in Asia but I don't know if any of that was in the program during this time period. Whereas Dong mae is a ronin. A samurai warrior with close combat skills we've seen already. Eugene may be a firearms marksman and a war hero but how much of that would've been in close quarters? I'm just saying in a duel to the death, while it'd be a good fight, my money's on Dong mae.

1

I wish DongMae and Hina end up together!

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I’d happily watch a show with Hina and Dong-mae as leads

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

actually the vibes I get of DM and Hina that they are great friends that have each other's backs.

It is okay even if they dun end up

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It took me three sittings to finish this episode. However, I didn’t fast forward any scenes. But yes, too much dialogue that really didn’t seem that important at the time. I still think that watching it on a television is 100x better than a laptop though. When I get bored reading subtitles I just look at the pictures. I feel like I’m in kindergarten again.

6
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's okay. Feeling like you're in kindergarten looking at the pictures? It feels like the dialogue was written by a child in kindergarten too, so that kinda fits.

2
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think the dialogue would be okay if Eugene were played by a much younger actor and a less seasoned military man. Landing a huge star like LBH has perks but drawbacks when his age doesn't fit the script. imo

2
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

"Better to be a old mans darling than a young mans fool."
My sister has been working on the family genealogy and I was amazed at how many December and May couples there are in the family tree. Apparently, since women in no way could earn a living and/or inherit money choosing a seasoned bread winner with assets made a lot of sense. Also the husbands like the idea of having a young and energetic woman to provide nursing for themselves and their families should the need arise.
Another reason I am grateful for my current incarnation.

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not against it. I was fine with the age gap in Goblin. But I think some of the things in this script would come off funnier from a younger character such as eating the military order.

2

I had to like your comment for the old wive's tale saying at the beginning. I've heard that too from the older women in my family. Also "It's just as easy to love a rich man as it is a po' one". 🤣

2

Yes you're right, That was juvenial. I think it wouuld have been funny if Domi grabbed the note and ate it to keep Eugene in Joseon.

4

Yes. I must admit I kept pausing to see how much time was left. (Are they going to spend the whole rest of the time left camera lingering on horseback Eugene staring at Ae standing in her courtyard?)

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Speaking of kindergarten, let’s talk vocab: The Korean kid saying “Okay” to the missionary. Actually this could actually be part of the vernacular of the time in America. Grade: A. I hope I didn’t steal your thunder, @tacourtn!

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not at all, there is enough thunder, lightning, rain, and ESPECIALLY SNOW to go around. (Is that freakin' winter ever going to end?). LOL

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I looked it up. Okay is American slang for All correct:
"A more likely explanation is that the term originated as an abbreviation of orl korrekt , a jokey misspelling of 'all correct' which was current in the US in the 1830s. https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/explore/what-is-the-origin-of-the-word-ok/

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

My biggest question of this show is: Wan-ik is well-known of being a traitor. But why do people - even the King - still trust in him?

2
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think they trust him, but they are intimidated by his power due to his Japanese backing. So they have to appease him.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

But why must the King give Wanik a post, specifically the foreign ministry? How can Japan force his posting?

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Emperor Gojong fears assassination, just like the Japanese agents assassinated his queen years before.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's the keep your enemies close scenario—the King did explain in the previous episodes (when he first summoned Wan-ik back from Japan) why he wanted Wan-ik to be back in Joseon despite knowing his slimy blood-sucking ways.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

To be honest I really enjoyed this episode. I loved the characterization and the conversation. I even loved the ocean. Obviously it was going to happen that Eugene sharing himself with Ah-sin was going to make Joseph's death that much harder, and Ah-sin's response deeper and more poignant in the next episode. Even the scene with the potter, though it was silly, did show 2 things. first, how much Eugene was rubbing off on Ah-sin, and second, how much more well known their relationship is becoming. It was the members of Ah-sin's cell knew they were connected, but now they're seeing how deeply they're connected. This will result in problems later. But depending on how Eugene plays it, it could also result in opportunities.

I think sometimes people need patience when they're watching this show, as many things are taken to mean one thing, and later on are shown to mean something else. I'm thinking of Ah-sin so many times thinking that Eugene would betray her, and getting so mad, when it turned out that Eugene was really 'threading the needle,' showing her what he could show her, while at the same time keeping his affections, and their connection, hidden from everyone else. The things he told her were for her own safety. Don't show upset, don't stand out, be careful around the american soldiers. But she took all of these as insults. Later on he told her how he was trying to cover up these incidents and her involvement in them, but it wasn't until he shot himself to protect her that she truly believed he was on her side.
I also think about her tears on the ice, the meeting on the bridge, and the returned music box, and how in that moment he lost hope. But it turned out that what she meant each time was different than what he'd thought.

The meeting between Ah-sin and Dong Mae was the same way. It was an extremely complex conversation, with many meanings, and many contradictions between words and tone and intent. I think it will play out to make more sense in the future.

It actually reminds me of Hina's remarks about coffee, how it's always initially bitter, but then it becomes sweet, spicy, swirling with flavor, always surprising. And then the sad part, like a vain hope or a dream.

18
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree with your comment about patience. It is a drama, not an action movie. Relationships, connections, feelings must be explored before the action takes place. This adds depth to the story. This episode is the quiet before the storm.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I would like for DM and AE to come to some sort of understanding. DM was as open and as sincere as he could be, baring his feelings for AE in front of her parents' altar but in front of AE he just couldnt be vulnerable..

i know to AE, he must be a real annoyance, if not an obsessive stalker. But still, I feel for DM and his pain. i guess i must have stockholm syndrome.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well written @bluetrix- I couldn't have done better. I too am enjoying the show and how it is slowly unfolding layers of the story with the layers of each character. Personally, I like everyone except Wan Shik and his lackey, and how we are coming to see all their sides and inner fears/joys.

Also, I'm a total coffee fiend/snob so the references to coffee always catch my attention.

5
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

When my daughter and I watch this show, I call Wan Ik and his minion Glasses Guy and Junior Glasses Guy, and every time we see what they're up to, we say, yeah, these two gotta get got.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you, let's peel the onion one layer at a time.
Speaking of coffee and the King may I recomend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gabi_(film)

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh, thank you for that link! I'll see if I can find that film.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That huge pile of bullets in the pawn shop looked like all rifle bullets.... Yu-jin would have been extra embarrassed if he tried to pass those off as handgun bullets in the inspection.

4
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I am pretending I didn't see the barrel full of riflebullets. I had to stretch my imagination and pretend they also had a different barrel of bullets for an American Remington pistol that was practically an antique by 1903. My imagination was stretched to its limit but didn't quite snap.

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

There were a multitude of bullets in there, for all kinds of pistols; including Russian, Japanese, German and American made. Pause and fact-check.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That occured to me as well. The pawnbrokers open the door and the rooster crows in the silver blue morning light.. That was pretty funny.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't know bullets but they looked HUGE to me and I wondered if they were right.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favourite scene was the bar/piggyback scene between Hina and Dong Mae, the song fited really well. I like their sexy friendship.

For Ae Shin, I'm not sure why she hates so much Dong Mae. He's not a good guy but she's an assassin too... Eugene's story should make her understand that some people had to run away from Korea to survive. And Dong Mae is in love with her since a very long time for a thin reason now, he's kind of a fool.

For Eugene and Ae Shin couple, I like how they share their past, their feelings. You can see their feelings for each other. But their couple lacks that little something that make me eager to see them together.

7
13
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wonder if it's partially the camera work. It's unusual for both Eugene and Ae Shin to be in the same frame, so they're never quite close enough for good eye contact, as if the camera is keeping them separated right now on purpose. Maybe as they grow closer and are thrown together in such a way they need each other and can't betray their feelings, the camera will have them as close as it's had Ae Shin and Dong Mae.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, I feel Ae Shin and Dong Mae are stuck in an impasse. I would like to see some change in dynamics. This week I thought finally Dong Mae said what he wanted. That was a big step forward.
Ae Shin needs to see Dong Mae atleast as a political beneficiary. She is completely dismissing him because he is not aligned to Joseon's fight. She has to realize his loyalty lies nowhere. Also realize not everyone who fled for their life will turn up like Eugene. Her opinions of Right vs wrong is so black and white, which is endearing but also not very fitting in times like this. I want her to step up and take a more active role (rather than just be a soldier).

10
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't know how many times I can agree with you, but I do. Her right/wrong is very black and white, but it also shows her naivety and how sheltered she's been, even though she's a 'snipah'.

In the beginning I was just amazed by how many times Ae Shin got mad at Eugene. It was like, I love him, I hate him, times infinity. And, my lord, how many times did she pull a gun on him. I was like, this girl would give me such a headache. :-)

7
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don’t know if there is going to be character growth for her or her role ends in a place where 3 men protect her.
I haven’t seen much growth in her for a few episodes now.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

totally agree with Blue Footed Booby and Blue.
I think that the writer is focused on romance between AS and Eugene so no room for Dong mae for even making her understood his situation. What a pity. Dong mae do not have a firm association like Ae shin because I believe that he grew up not be able to believe in any liaisons or established belief( society, association). Instead of belonging to a political belief or some sorts, he creates his own and do whatever money dictates him to do. That is actually one of better ways to protect himself under any unstable societies. He needed to protect himself first in order to survive in this cruel world unlike Ae-shin.
Dong mae has a good heart. He does treat women with respect. Hina was completely drunk but he did not take advantage of the situaion. Ae-shin only has seen bad side of him and that is a true tragedy!

8
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

yes, he is a survivor. He did what he had to, in order to survive. But when it comes to people close to him he is fiercely protective. Whether it is his fighters, mute friend, Hina or Ae-Shin. He would give up his life for the sake of his fighters. It is such a shame, Ae-Shin has no clue! I really want to see some change in their relationship. No, am not rooting for romance or anything. Just some respect and understanding would go a long way.
Ae-Shin has such a good network - Hee-Sun , EC, DM, Hina - but she is hardly gathering any information. Even EC figured out before her that the potter was the leader. She really is living a very sheltered life. Her experience comes from books, not real world.

10
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"He would give up his life for the sake of his fighters. It is such a shame, Ae-Shin has no clue! I really want to see some change in their relationship. No, am not rooting for romance or anything. Just some respect and understanding would go a long way."

Thank god I am not the only one! *clap clap*

4

Atz, your post really resonated with me. I totally agree with you, Blue Footed Booby, and Meheartisamusicbox. The foursome of Ae Shin, Eugene, Dong Mae, and Hina always made me wish for Dong Mae and Hina to come together, if they couldn't have who they loved. But I was reminded of Moon Embracing the Sun (don't remember how long ago it came out), where the King's older brother and first wife both died. I don't know if it's a trope in KDramas, but I don't have much hope for those two, even though I love them both. I do want to hope, but I worry. Dong Mae broke my heart when he spoke to Ae Shins parents, and Hina weeping in the bar did too. -sigh-

I also agreed with BFB about Dong Mae being a survivor, and I guess it goes back to Ae Shin's black and white thinking. Even Ms. Hanam was like that, saying that Dong Mae threw away the chance that AS had given him, when in fact he had taken that chance with both hands. I feel that Ms. Hanam and Ae Shin are both seeing the world through the lens they grew up in, and have not reexamined that perspective to see where their view was wrong or incomplete. What did they expect, that he would run to some other noble house and become a servant there? When you saw Dong Mae screaming at his father in such anguish, how could you let them do this to us? How could you even bring me into this life? Could you ever imagine him wanting to place himself under the power of another?

I see a lot of that, not just with Ae Shin and her people, but even the king, and the chamberlain, who even after Eugene has helped him repeatedly, can't get over his roots in slavery, or that he didn't blindly obey the king. Although in this case the king seems to be much more forgiving and understanding.

I also agree about Ae Shin's network, although I don't believe she even recognizes she has one. Maybe it's the culture of secrecy within their cell of the Righteous Army (and I definitely got the Maoist flavor).

What amazed me early on was how quickly Eugene was connecting with people, and developing a network of friends / allies, who he could repeatedly go to for help. The way he was able to go to the former slave hunters to hide the document was fantastic, and the way he went to them to find some bullets was hilarious. I rolled when he tried to guilt them with the 'he's shivering' line, and they just groaned in irritation. They were like, 'come on, buy yourself a thicker coat!'

And, Meheartisamusicbox, I also clap with you. I hope that this thing between Ae Shin and Dong Mae isn't an impasse, but a knot, that can be unravelled, little by little.

8
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for your detailed thoughts. You bring up some very good points.

"What did they expect, that he would run to some other noble house and become a servant there? "
Exactly! Right? I was pissed too when Ms.Hanam judged Dong-Mae so quickly, without knowing a thing.
I think the writers are kinda hinting that this 'stuck-in-a-rut' system was what caused the downfall of Joseon.

Ae-Shin: I think her character is what I have most trouble relating with. May be, as a woman, I have high expectations and hence the disappointment. It disappoints me that she is still fighting to keep the status-quo and has not questioned anything so far. I thought Eugene is what will cause the shake-up, even that didnt happen.
She really cannot give up her identity as a noble woman. I understand her situation, but I have reached a point where I feel her growth is stunted.
Even for someone fighting status-quo, I don't know how much she knows what the status-quo is. She goes around the streets of Joseon, but does she really see?
She goes from executing orders and comes back to eat pastries. There is a huge disconnect here. For 10 years she has been training and doing this, but she seems so clueless.

8

BFB, exactly, and in the beginning, her stated motivation was, "they killed queen Min."

4

To Blue's comment, her stated motivation was, "they killed queen Min."

Seriously if that were the reason, I am afraid that her view is so limited.
I think Ae-shin does not fully comprehend how badly Joseon was shaken up by other countries( not just by Japan) and the root of it is the corruption of the court and the class system (therefore abuse of power by Yangban( aristocracy)). Maybe Go family was not as corrupt as other aristocrats but they are quite powerful therefore they were the key to let the government decay as it was.
Can Ae-shin have a courage to live without the status? Can she walk everywhere without her carriage? Can she do everyday chore without servants?
Ae-shin prepares for die for her country for a heroic/romantic notion as if she is so bored with her life and wants to do some daring action without a full understanding of the world surrounds her.
I wonder her action is often associated with romantic notion. And that is the reason she is attracted to Eugene. He is joseon man but also American whose country is in a far, far away land. That itself stirred her curiosity. She cannot help being romantic.
The whole shot in this drama is beautiful but that also represents her notion, even a sad scene has to be beautified to be poetic. Without skilled actors in presence, this drama would have been all about beautiful scenes.

7

To Blue Footed Booby and atz, your words above resonated with me. I want to comment on them but need to think. I'll write more tomorrow if I can.

1

I was pretty surprised when she threw her hanbok just because he touched it... I thought her reaction was disproportionate. She always overacts with him.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm quite confused with Joseph's death. He was just in the sidelines, now, he's become a sort of meeting point for our characters. Also, I don't want to pick on the details but do they have any tin cans with that kind of opening during that time? It looks too modern. Lol.😀 The bullets too. Hah.

Hina's drinking and silent crying tugged at me for some reason. The ladies when they are together, and the gentlemen when they are together have better chemistry with each other than the guy/s and girl/s mixed up. Lol.

I love Hee-sung's and Harabeonim's interaction. Harabeonim's like, boy, I wasn't born yesterday. Hehe. I wish Ae-shin too can see what Harabeonim saw in Hee-sung.

Wan-ik's being a slimy hagfish as always. Or a lamprey because he sucks blood from others. Lol. And Ae-shin's right- and left-hand man are adorable and thick as thieves.

Also, no wonder Ae-soon spends her days gambling, if I have a douche for a husband like that I'd spend his money too. Well his money not my mum's. Is she the primary wife? Based on her social standing she's supposed to be, is there any indication of that?

All in all, it was an OK episode. But I'm angling for more action. For some reason this episode left me feeling that I don't have any idea where the whole series/story is headed.

7
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

You are correct, metallic pull-tabs like Eugene used on the can of food were not invented until 1959. For accuracy, he should have been using a knife, or a "churchkey" utensil to open the can. If you want to take a deeper dive I posted links on my fan wall.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

There are so many anachronisms I can't keep count. My favorites were, when the american legation interpreter started coughing and said, "We're busted!", and Ms. Hanam's NBA fist pump when Ae Shin caught the innocent papers.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Checked it out. :) Thanks for the info—your wall is like a one-stop shop for references! :D Ha.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really love that interaction between Go elder and HS as well. It makes me wonder so much how come his granddaughter who has the access to all the knowledge that she ever wants fail rather successfully in reading other people except of those that she has willingly given her heart to. What the elder did in ep 14 is even better. I have high respect for such character in a person. The ability to see beyond a person's words and self is hard to come by. It's worth learning and exciting to watch. Thus, I love the bromance interactions more as it has this element. Talking in riddles but it doesn't mean those are meaningless speech to them.

6
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

The difference between hearing vs listening. seeing vs perceiving.
I think Ae-Shin is so quick to judge which might be her failing. Even with Eugene, she trusted him inspite of being warned by Gunner not to trust anyone. It probably also explains why the righteous army is keeping her in the dark - they don't fully trust her judgment (in addition to protecting her because of go-grandpa's request ).

7
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Like giving a kid his most wanted toys just to keep him occupied and quiet cos without those he will just scream his lungs out and that spell headache? hehehe

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ah, that explains it. It bothers me why she immediately jumped to the conclusion that Dong-mae is threatening her just because of the letter from the nun, when in fact, she hasn't heard from him for ages (I'm assuming it's been ages since I have no idea how time flies in this story)—from her point of view though, since she hasn't been privy to Dong-mae's other actions, it does seem quite reasonable. I love Ae-shin all right, but yeah, she does have that tendency to jump to conclusions about people. It also bothered me that when she was asking for money from Hina, she said she would just resort to threats if she was refused help. Logically, if you're the one who is needing help, you wouldn't threaten someone you're asking help from—but with Ae-shin it was the other way around. She does have other interactions with Hina—and from them you know that she knows that Hina knows a lot about people—and if it were the first time they met, her actions would have been reasonable. I would think she would probably get some intel first about somebody—like what the others do. Eugene, Hee-sung, Dong-mae, Hina—they all scout out info about a person/people they are interested in or anything that comes up in their radar directly or indirectly before going to confront them or before even meeting them (yunno due diligence), I've barely seen that in Ae-shin.

6
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Entitlement that comes from privilege (in her case, her social standing). Thats how i see it.

5

"Eugene, Hee-sung, Dong-mae, Hina—they all scout out info about a person/people they are interested in or anything that comes up in their radar directly or indirectly before going to confront them or before even meeting them (yunno due diligence), I've barely seen that in Ae-shin."

Exactly! Isn't she also the one with bigger purpose in life? Shouldn't she also be doing some field works to gather her own intels? Easy life that she has. Power of privilege shouldn't make one with such fire and flame to fight be so complacent.

1

@miracle23/Meheartisamusicbox - In her defense, she did not have to do anything to 'survive'. The others had to survive in this world and have gained skills over a period of time. I only want Ae-Shin to open her eyes and look beyond what she sees. Be it Hina, Eugene, Dong-Mae or her grandfather (this is a woman who thought her grandfather sent her to the gunner to kill her off!!). Joseon is going to be a more dangerous place, and she needs to awaken. I would be heartbroken, if someone ends up dying protecting her.

2

" I only want Ae-Shin to open her eyes and look beyond what she sees. "

@mayhemf I share this sentiment since the time I noticed the opposite from AS. That's why I am quite frustrated with the character despite loving her badass-ness. The inconsistencies (I call it) are distracting me. On the topic of survival and living in a dangerous world, I think AS had that albeit not as extreme as the others. But the killing at instruction things that she has been doing for so many years is dangerous in itself and requires a good survival skill. I don't want to take her as being skill-less because I want to keep potraying her as a very skillful fighter. I wish she fully utilises her brain more beyond what is shown to us so far. Perhaps we will get to see that in the next ten episodes. I won't be heartbroken but rather annoyed if someone died protecting her and she barely acknowledges such sacrifice because that someone is not EC or her teacher or her leader or her grandfather. Hope that is not happening. I still hope to have faith in AS

0

these episodes are just getting slower and slower. I enjoyed some moments between Eugene and Aeshin but with those two together and the show focused more on romance than plot its kind of like we have reached a faux ending of sorts already and are just dragging along twiddling are thumbs when there isnt much more to see.

I also feel like the relationship aeshin shares with the other characters also wasn't milked as much as it could have been before aeshin and eugene got together. Like all the tension has just dissapated and I need the plot to pick up real soon to save this.

7
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

We're already more than halfway through. Should we take bets on when the action will pick up?

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

A lot of us are really waiting for the action to pick up. I mean, we all know that the country is in real trouble, so romance is not the priority right now. Unless, her romance directly or indirectly contributes to the plot or her character growth.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

🤦🏽‍♀️ I just feel like throwing in my err... hat 🎩 on this show now

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I dont't know why after waiting for this Kim Eun Sok drama, I put too much hope that this drama can compete with DOTS or Goblin, but until eps 14 I didn't see the beautiful scene or even beautiful OST in this drama....the romance between Eugene and Ae Shin doesn't have a good deep background that can make their love grow as it meant to be. Kim Tae Ri acting also not too good compare to Lee Byung Hun....

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

rewatching the earlier episodes after having watched the later episodes helped me see more nuance and tension in the characters' relationships with one another.

it also helped me work out the timelines and appreciate the beautiful framing of most of the key scenes. it is like i can take a screenshot and it turns out to be a beautifully framed postcard. lol.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"beautifully framed postcard."
Then you might enjoy watching "Every Frame A Painting" on Youtube. How film is made. Quite interesting.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Are you for REAL???

A sorrowful, powerful moment watered down to "another reason to feel sorry for Eugene"?? Are we not watching the same exact series? Are you not seeing the exact same precise, tightly written story? Are you not seeing the fleshed out, complex characters??

Eugene Choi is a man who lives his life on the outskirts. His parents died to protect him. He was hunted as a mere child. Practically left for dead by many people. He survived by pure grit and the grace of Joseph, who spent no more than three years with him. Three years, but it was a labor of love for someone who was poor and humble. He has few (if any) friends, barely finding a place to belong. The U.S. considers him expendable and a pawn. He is not outwardly emotional, though we have seen that the flames in him burn bright. He might keep a level head, but he's driven forward by emotion and desire alone. If not, he'd be dead. He's a smart, capable, warm man who, through no fault of his own, has always stood out. It has been pointed out multiple times throught out the series. Lee Byunghun has been doing a great job of bringing him to life; from the quirky way he talks though only half of his mouth, to the powerful emotions he manages to push through even Eugene's icy veneer.

I'm sorry, I've begun to see that you deliberately and pointedly hate this drama. Just stop recapping it. You're not doing anyone any favors. Just stop. You clearly don't enjoy it. Step away and recap a drama you prefer. Please.

5
23
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hear, hear!👏👏👏👏👏👏 I also find it difficult to reconcile the drama and recaps.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Bless me, I had been hoping I wasn't the only one. I think I'll stop reading the recaps altogether. Disliking a drama is all well and good as we all have our tastes, but being biased (while pretending you aren't) is just wrong.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

There is an inherent bias at Dramabeans against KES (the writer) that spills over into recaps, just like there is a similar bias in favor of the Hong Sisters.
I get it....these are artistic productions and tastes can differ. Side note: I always love to imagine the scrambling that must happen over at DB headquarters when it comes to deciding who has to recap what (short straws? mud wrestling? A drinking contest?).

I think the difficulty is that it becomes a challenge to fight the groupthink and offer opinions that differ.

2
9
reply

Required fields are marked *

I dunno, I seem to remember a few bad words from DB re the Hong sisters latest dramas.

9
2
reply