Beanie level: Noble idiot

Hi Beanies. I’ve been away from kdramaland for a while. What’d I miss? (The last time I was here properly there were whispers on the street of a man who became a cat. A were-cat? I shudder to think.)

5
4

How is everyone’s week going? Thinking of all you guys and hoping you’re taking care of your mental health. 💛

14
1

Not sure if I should watch Plus Nine Boys, Bubblegum or finally begin the Reply series…

0
12

    i vote for reply and bubblegum.

    3
    0

    Don’t watch Plus Nine Boys, it wasn’t great.

    0
    1

    Watch Reply 1997 and 1988 but skip 1994.

    1
    1

      O no! :(( :)) We have different taste^^
      1994 was my fav! Then 1988.
      I FF 1997, for me that one was so boring. I do love SIG but I couln’t feel any of the characters except the mutual dad:)

      3
      2

        ooops, I do beg your pardon! ☺️

        0
        0

        Haha finally I found someone who thinks 94 was better than 97!!. I didn’t like 97 but I can’t choose between 94 and 88😅

        1
        1

          Glad to hear we share the same taste! For me 94 is way better than 97. I didn’t like the female lead character in 94.
          And oh god! You can’t choose between 88 n 94 either? I’m with you in that dilemma. There are things I adore about 88 but I have to confess I didn’t quite like the ending. 94 may have flaws but at least the girl ended up with who I wanted😂 and I love that the actors were’t different as adults.
          *dear Moana, sorry for saying these on your wall dear! I tried not to spoil and I hope you enjoy all three^.^*

          2
          1

            Not at all. Hearing people talk passionately about dramas is literally why I joined this site. 😄

            2
            0

    Omg you haven’t watched Reply series yet😱
    Good for you because you are going to have a wonderful time soon if you start! They are absolutely amazing. I watched them about six months ago and I couldn’t think how my kdrama-watching life was before these three!
    My absolute fav are 1988 and 1994. I didn’t enjoy 1997 like the other two.

    2
    1

      Sounds like you really enjoyed them. ☺ In what order did you watch them?

      1
      1

        Yes, so muchhh^_^
        1997
        1994
        1988

        I watched 97 but didn’t enjoy as much as I expected but I’m glad I didn’t give up and watched the next two! 1988 is such a rich drama if you are into vintage vibes☺️

        3
        0

@ndlessjoie Her Private Life was so nice! I loved that reconciliation was one of the themes (Seon-joo and her husband, Ryan and both his mother figures, Hyo-jin and her mother). Also PMY’s outfits. 😍

8
4

On The Popularity Of The “Dating A Superior At Work” Trope
Perhaps it’s because my latest drama-watching victim partner is an impressionable 13-year-old, but I’ve been thinking a lot about the prevalence of romantic pairings in which one character is a boss and the other is an employee or subordinate. How do I help her understand that while we are expected to swoon over the fictional Ryan Golds, such a relationship would be ill-advised in real life?
Just this year alone we had:
Touch Your Heart
Her Private Life
The Secret Life Of My Secretary
Romance Is A Bonus Book
Hotel Del Luna
Angel’s Last Mission: Love
Catch The Ghost
My Strange Hero (?)
In some instances, such as Encounter/Boyfriend, the central conflict arises from the power imbalance and difference in socioecenomic status between the romantic leads. However, this seems to rarely ever be the case, as dozens upon dozens of secretary dramas have mined their drama and conflict from places other than the nature of the relationship. In Touch Your Heart or The Secret Life, dating your boss is portrayed as a viable romantic option, not as a choice rife with ethical and professional issues.
This year we’ve seen a rise in dramas that reverse the trope by having the female partner as the boss, which usually opens the door to interesting discussions about gender roles and societal expectations.
I have loved many dramas with this romantic set-up and will continue to watch them, but I remain curious as to why this kind of pairing seems to be so popular. Thoughts?

9
12

    I’ve enjoyed dramas with this setup because they were fluffy and this is entertainment – it doesn’t need to be woke for me to enjoy it! But to tell you the truth, in my opinion this trope is pure patriarchy

    3
    1

      When I was a kid, this trope was all over the TV shows I watched (non Korean). I was surprised to realize that it’s still so common on Kdramas. Basically, these shows tell women that it is aspirational to date your supercute usually chaebol boss (adding an extra layer of classism to patriarchy) instead of telling us that we are able to reach professional sucess if we focus on our careers… Worse still, they tell us that instead of doing real work, it’s ok to have a woman following the whims of a totally unprofessional boss who feels entitled to usurp her time and attention… Ludicrous! This doesn’t mean that I eschew these dramas, but I think we can enjoy something and be critical at the same time

      8
      2

        I’d have thought that narratives like this would be a thing of the past by now, but here we are. And this is not to shame women who want to date someone with a good job, but must it be someone who controls your job as well? This, in addition to the inequality built into the relationship, just seems like a bad financial decision.

        1
        0

        In real life, it’s pretty hard for the average person to have a dashing chaebol boss.
        I think workplace romance would probably work best if there’s a degree of separation, like it’s not your direct superior, or different depts, otherwise the conflict of interest & bias will make it complicated.

        3
        0

    It could be that in these cases attraction is related to the stability a boss gives to an employee. There are a lot of advantages in dating your boss as portrayed in dramas like he’s always there to save the day, charismatic, respected by everyone, financially stable, closed to the object of affection (no need to go to blind dates), can be seen everyday and give work privileges (in dramas at least). He’s husband material and when there’s a weakness to all of his perfection, it makes him more approchable, thus a bond more special than the usual boss-employee relationship.

    Even if I enjoyed dramas you mentionned, I think that it gives the message of getting into a company to find a husband. There are dramas with that kind of women (because only women have these thoughts =.=”) and they’re portrayed as bad. So, only a nice woman who didn’t ask for anything and who just happened to fall for her boss or the boss fell for her, gets a pass. That’s also a point that ticks me. Sometimes, the boss gives special treatment and it makes it for the employee to be recognized for their work. But then, if rumours appear, the boss comes and saves the day. Isn’t it like a never ending circle?

    4
    1

      This makes a lot of sense, especially the part about the boss being attractive because he is respected by everyone (even though he might not necessarily be liked at first). The idea of dating your boss is so unattractive to me that I couldn’t fathom why anyone would do it even in a fictional setting, but I’m considering the reasons you suggested and the puzzle pieces are starting to fit together. It boggled my mind at first.

      I get what you mean about how only nice women who didn’t come to work looking for a husband are given a pass if they find one. Those who expressly want to meet someone at work are labelled as desperate or manipulative. It’s part of a whole thing where women aren’t allowed to be proactive in their love lives the same way men are. I feel a rant incoming so let me stop here. 😂

      The thing is that I wouldn’t mind this set-up as much if the characters acknowledged that their respective positions made their relationship problematic. Some hesitation on the part of the secretary, some reticence from her boss, some discussions on how to handle things and how to make the relationship more equitable, something.

      2
      1

        I agree with you. Dating your boss doesn’t appeal to me neither. Actually, anyone who can use power play on me isn’t a potential romantic partner. He can decide on your work career’s evolution or ending. That’s really icky.

        I feel you. I stopped myself before renting too haha A discussion between the two partners to separate their work from private life is needed. In What’s Wrong With Secretary Kim, I expected Kim Mi So to gain complete independence from her boss and live as Kim Mi So, not only as Secretary Kim like she wanted in the premiere. But, she was already caring for him and did more things than a traditional secretary should do.

        3
        1

          That’s true for me as well. Anyone who has power over what becomes of my career is automatically disqualified as a romantic prospect. Ick.

          WWWSK was ultimately disappointing in that respect – I didn’t watch it but Beanie rants told me everything I needed to know – but thankfully Park Min Young came back with Her Private Life, which had a far healthier relationship.

          Are you currently watching any romcoms?

          0
          2

            I’m watching Love With Flaws, Crash Landing on You and the Jdrama Nee Sensei, Shiranai No?

            The male lead in Love With Flaws is a chaebol and decides to work in the school where the female lead teaches because he wants to get revenge. Things happen and he goes back and forth but the fact that he wanted to use his power in the first place to get revenge because she rejected him when they were kids doen’t make me cheer for him.

            0
            0

            HPL had a healthier relationship than in WWWSK because Ryan Gold was the new boss, Deok Mi was qualified and her work recognized before his arrival, and the two kept butting head in the beginning. Deok Mi was her own person outside of their relationship whereas Mi So in WWWSK was always secretary Kim at and outise work.

            0
            0

    Totally agree with you. It presents an ethical dilemma and is professionally inappropriate. I do think that the female boss discussions about gender roles and societal expectations are needed especially in a patriarchal society like South Korea.

    However, I don’t think Touch Your Heart and RIABB technically fall into that boss/subordinate trope. Yoon Seo wasn’t really Jung Rok’s secretary. Dan Yi and Eun Ho knew each other before she started working for the same company
    and while he was a department head he wasn’t her direct supervisor.

    2
    1

      Same here. I find that I enjoy female-boss dramas because they challenge the status quo in Korean society. I found it especially awesome when My Strange Hero’s Son Soo-jeong rejected the advances of her wealthy, well-connected boss to be with Bok-soo.

      As for RIABB and Touch Your Heart, when I was writing this I was thinking broadly of a situation where two people work at the same place/company and one has a superior position to the other. But I do understand your point.

      1
      0

Quick poll: how many dramas in which the lead dates their boss did you watch in 2019?

2
12

    Technically 3 that were produced in 2019 (Haechi, Melo is my Nature and Her Private Life), but none of these -except Haechi from the second half on- felt like the power dynamic was terrible. Anyway, this year I watched some of those that felt cringier. Strong Woman Do Bong Soon, Clean with Passion and Suspicious Partner, I’m looking at you!

    1
    1

    Hmmm…none. i watched about 10 2019 dramas and none was centered around a boss dating his/her subordinate. Yayyyy 🎉

    Perfume had a somewhat boss-worker relationship, but I consider it a noona romance and they knew each other since they were kids.

    I also watched about 11 older years dramas and I recall none had a lead dating their boss!!! I’m surprised by this finding 😯. I didn’t notice it before 🤣.

    2
    0

    Romance is a Bonus Book is technically boss dates subordinate, but it was really just a noona romance.

    0
    1

      Surely it’s both? Or am I misunderstanding what noona romance means?

      1
      1

        You’re right it is both. I just meant that the romance was predominantly characterized by their noona-dongsaeng relationship because they knew each other in that way before she began working for him 🙂

        0
        0

    Quite a few number of dramas I watched this year were like that now that I think about it.

    0
    1

      Our beloved CTG was like that too, and while I adored the leads, I can’t help but wonder why this set-up is popular among kdramas.

      1
      1

    8 :/ I don’t get the obsession over dating your boss. I feel like that’d be so weird in real life… It’s such an unbalanced position / situation of powers.
    Forget dating I don’t know how you can like (not in a romantic way) your boss.

    1
    2

      Actually 9 I forget Be Melo 😱

      0
      0

      I don’t understand the appeal either and the inherent power imbalance tempers my enjoyment somewhat.

      1
      0

My favourite drama of 2019? A tie between My Strange Hero and Tale of Nokdu, both of which belong to a new genre I’m proposing called Sweet, Kind Men And The Badass Women Who Love Them.

13
10

I had to take some time away from – well – everything. Because I was not doing so well. But man is it good to be back. I have missed this little corner of the internet.💛

20
11

My HDL theory is that the captain betrayed MW and he was reborn as CS who will eventually take over as hotel owner to make amends for his past sins. I kinda hope I\’m wrong.

2
0

So…are we just gonna ignore the fact that it should be Hotel De La Luna since the noun is feminine?

3
12

    Everyone has been complaining.

    0
    1

      I was waiting for an explanation during the first episode, like say…it was originally written correctly but the “a” fell off from the sign and no one bothered to put it back up again. I don’t know. Something. Anything.

      2
      0

    Maybe its intentional !

    0
    1

      How?

      0
      1

        The ghosts who did not know Spanish, etc, I just say maybe they wanted it to be like that, but I since I did not ask them and there is no rule that the titles should be grammatically correct and they maybe they just wanted to create more buzz, I can’t really answer your question.
        I personally do that many times with nouns with gender in my mother tongue, just for fun or shock value even when I am talking and I know its wrong grammatically.

        0
        2

          Sorry the two they’s above where not intentional, they were a mistake 😉

          0
          0

          Perhaps they did this on purpose but if so, it’d be nice if they offered an explanation, no?

          0
          1

            I am not sure, who knows, but I don’t think I will watch more of this show, so my interest ends here!

            1
            0

    Nope. Eye sore still.

    2
    0

    it’s spanish right? well it has to be cos luna lmao but i never thought of that bc i majored in fr and speak eng. HMMMM. interesting. lmao. i would be irritated too

    1
    1

      Luna isn’t only a spanish word for moon it is actually an ancient goddess from Roman mythology that’s why it’s used as a poetic word for the moon in lots of other languages.

      2
      1

        i was wondering about the title! cos french is v. similar so i was like wait it hot it was a spanish title…aahahha

        0
        0

What is the verdict on WWW? I want to watch for the female friendships but I could do without the politics and chaebol drama. Is it good?

2
8

    Depends on who you ask. It’s a weird show – all tropes reserved for romantic heterosexual couples, all roles, dialogues, tasks usually reserved for men, have been given to women. I suspect the all-women in leadership positions sits oddly with a few people. I know the main romance sits oddly with most people. HAHA Including me, re the romance.

    The show is excellent in my opinion. I’m ready to rate it a 9.5/10 or even a 10/10 depending on how the final few episodes go.

    5
    1

      I saw episode 1 and I liked all the women. I think it’s the tone/style that I’m still not quite on board with – lots of lens flares and intense close-ups. Plus, I wish there was a bit more comedy. Scarlet is an instant favourite though.

      1
      0

    I think it’s brilliant. Try to give it a chance.

    1
    0

    Go for it! We always complain women don’t get written well in dramas and finally we have a Drama. Yes, the main romance may or may not work for you (it doesn’t work for me) but I don’t care because it’s not the main plot.

    4
    1

      I really liked Scarlet and Tae-mi in episode 1, so I just might give this another chance.

      0
      0

    Personally, I like it! Give it go!

    1
    0

    It’s great, I love it. Very different.

    @moana, did you hear about this Moana fan who got an unexpected birthday cake?
    https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/bakery-mixup-leaves-woman-with-marijuana-birthday-cake-181828197.html

    1
    1

      Heol. A very different birthday than the one she had in mind. At least the family were a good sport about it.

      1
      0

Just found out that I\’m finally a noble idiot! Yay! That explains the sudden urge to take my lover on one last romantic trip before leaving them without offering any explanation whatsoever.

27
7

An Incomplete and Unlikely List of Things I\’d Like To See on TSLOMS:

– After seeing how smart Gal-hee is at the shareholder\’s meeting, Veronica offers her job at CinePark
– Gal-hee and Veronica forming a genuine friendship/allyship based on mutual respect
– Gal-hee no longer being Min-ik\’s secretary = their relationship is no longer problematic
– Min-ik puts 2 and 2 together AT LAST
– The parents plan the wedding but to their shock, it\’s not Veronica, but Gal-hee who walks down the isle
– At least one episode post-wedding. Kdramas tend to act like the wedding is the end goal of a romance. We know this is not true.
– Faux-ronica Park never makes another appearance. Jebal.

11
6

    last line is my wish to see but not sure how long we will have to bear this fauxronica… cause if MI figures the truth i’d die seeing thier romance cause if an hesitant MI cant set DB on fire than imagine if he actually does things to woo GH whom he loves *now i am in my la la land imagining it*

    3
    1

      I feel like Beanies would implode if Min-ik earnestly started wooing Gal-hee. Just think of all the cute! Sadly, we have to get through a lot of angst first.

      2
      0

    GH used to be VP’s secretary at Cinepark. That’s where she got practice as Fauxronica. (Love that label!!!)

    3
    1

      Instead of a secretary, I’d like her to have a higher-level job. Maybe overseeing scripts? Meeting potential investors? Gal-hee is skilled with people and she knows her way around a room full of stuffy old men. Not to mention it would allow her to live more comfortably, which is something she’s always wanted.

      3
      1

        Soon she should be able to choose whatever she wants to do without having to worry about making money. If this OTP doesn’t work out in the end, I’ll eat my hat.

        1
        1

To kick off Pride month, here\’s a challenge: what was the name of the LGBTQ character in the last Kdrama you watched? 🌈🌈🌈

1
19

    Lee Kyu-hyung’s character in Prison Playbook. His character was my favorite.

    5
    1

    I clicked randomly on a webdrama pilot about two girls confessing to each other but I don’t remember the name. So for Kdramas, I think it was Haerongi in Prison Playbook and in Kmovies it was the main couple in Ordinary People.

    1
    1

    This is a challenge indeed given that there are so few to choose from. I would have to say Chi Soo from Long Time No See. It’s not a mainstream drama but a web drama. He is a surprisingly interesting character with some depth to him. And being superficial for a sec, he is really hot.

    If you want to open it up to Asian dramas, then I’d have to say hands down Hsia Yu Hao from the Taiwanese Drama HIStory2: Boundary Crossing. Both the writers and the actor Fandy Fan made me love this character. I cannot wait for the sequel.

    1
    1

      Does Long Time No See have a happy ending? I’m tired of tragic stories about queer people.

      1
      1

        I too am tired of tragic endings in BL dramas. Thankfully, this drama does have a happy ending.

        1
        0

    To be precise, there hasn’t been a clearly LGBTQ character in any dramas I’ve watched since Matrimonial Chaos and Prison Playbook.

    3
    3

      Is Matrimonial Chaos any good?

      1
      1

        It’s really good. The focus is on two male/female couples though. It’s one of the few dramas where I wanted to crawl into the screen and hang out.

        1
        1

          That good!? I might check it out then. Thx.

          1
          1

            It’s more real life believable than most. It’s not a traditional romance or traditional couple drama. I’m also a bit obsessed with the river crossing that appears in most episodes.

            1
            0

      I forgot Matrimonial Chaos! I wanted more of her storyline.

      1
      1

      I think one of the supporting characters in Jugglers was maybe asexual? She didn’t date and was described as “celibate” but since she wasn’t religious, that’s how I interpreted it.

      1
      0

    lee jong suk in Secret Garden

    2
    0

@raonah and the rest of the He is Psychometric Beanies, I watched the first episode and I liked it! 😄

7
8

    It’s my favorite of all the current dramas I’m watching.

    2
    1

      So far, I’m impressed with how well the merged the mystery/murder/prosecutor stuff with the more light-hearted stuff. Sometimes when dramas try to do this, it can feel like you’re watching 2 different shows.

      And how adorable is Lee An? He went to school at 5:30 in the morning. On a Sunday. 😂

      3
      1

    And I’m finally caught up! It took another dark turn in the very latest ep that bothered me, but here’s to character growth! I’m still enjoying it as well!

    4
    0

    Yay! Glad to hear it! We’re having discussions on my wall if you’d like to join in once you’re all caught up 🙂💚

    2
    1

      I kinda don’t want to catch up because waiting for new episodes will be so hard. But I also want to join in on the discussion. Sigh. What’s a girl to do?
      In the meantime, is Lee An’s ability voluntary or not? When Hyung locked him in the morgue, it seemed like he had no control, but later we seem petting the doggo without getting any visions.

      2
      1

        I understand the struggle 😄
        I don’t think he can control it at all. Maybe the dog just didn’t have any interesting memories for him to see.

        2
        0

Squad!🙌 Squad!🙌 Squad!🙌

10
0

Beanies, can you recommend any dramas in which Home plays a big part? I want something that feels warm and familiar with lots of domestic scenes. Examples include 21st Century Boy and Girl and BTLIOF.

4
13

If I’ve learned one thing from watching dramas, it’s that no interest is too niche to have a bespoke stuffed toy (see below for evidence). So then, if you were making a drama starring a female lead who’s an elegant, slightly awkward chaebol by day and a crime-fighting badass by night, what kind of plushie would you give her?

11
2

    That’s all because this toy company puts ppl in everything. They just don’t have a sign like subway.

    2
    1

      I didn’t realise it was the same company. At least they vary their product from show to show, unlike the vacuum people and the massage chair people.

      0
      0

Kdramas are really out here giving us the most bizarre relationships between OTPs. Dating your fake cousin (My Girl) or adoptive uncle (Pinocchio) is pretty strange, but your stepfather who is in fact younger than you (Sweet Stranger And Me) takes the cake. I thought you couldn’t get any weirder, dramas, but you proved me wrong. Bravo.

14
2

    I’ll admit, that stepfather bit at the beginning was really weird, but thankfully things cleared up after a while. I might be one of the few beanies who likes that drama.

    0
    1

      I’m enjoying it so far. Granted, he was never functionally her stepfather which I think keeps things from being too icky. Unlike in Pinocchio (which I also enjoyed) where they grew up in the same house and were, for all intents and purposes, related. Ick.

      0
      0

Uri Beanie-made drama🎬
Writers:
@egads (In charge of tropes📺)
@hotcocoagirl (Makes characters who are friends engage in shenanigans and general buffoonery👯)
@isthatacorner (Our resident PPL coordinator🛒)
@leetennant (Has characters make snarky, almost self-aware comments about how badly made the drama is🤭)
@ally-le (Oversees heartwarming personal and relational growth👪)
@ndlessjoie (Time jump preventer. Studying abroad? Not in this drama⏳)
@bammsie (In charge of naming the drama📝)
Also if y’all could tell me what the plot is that’d be great because I have no idea.

Casting directors:
@oppafangirl (You also wanted to be a wrist grab remover but I don’t know if I trust you.😂)
@raonah (In charge of idol cameos🎤)
@greenfields (Kittens and doggos 🐶)

Director:
@justme (of both the drama and the BTS documentary of fangirls who try to make a drama and fail spectacularly. Out this summer in a cinema near you.🎥)

Location manager:
@anothernicole (First dates, MTs and romantic rendezvouz🏝️)

Editor:
@katakwasabi (Also in charge of making GIFs!🎞️)

The following posts are still open to any Beanies who wanna get involved in this nonsensical endeavour:
-Plot hole filler
-Plot twist facilitator (is sincerely tod available?)
-Quirky stuffed animal designer

11
67