22

Moonshine: Episodes 9-10 Open Thread

Our bootlegger and stodgy inspector spend some unexpected — but much needed — quality time with one another, but illegal alcohol and an arranged marriage aren’t the only things keeping them apart.

 
EPISODES 9-10 WEECAP

Have you ever watched two hours of a drama and thought, “Well, I enjoyed the last ten minutes of that?” That was me this week, which isn’t to say that Moonshine isn’t an entertaining drama, but a part of me is definitely feeling burnt out. It’s a shame, too, because there was some decent character development and quite a few big plot reveals this week.

And yet, I was apathetic. I think a large reason why I’m feeling this way is because the parts of this drama that I’m enjoying — like our cast of female characters — are losing screen time to Ro-seo’s annoying brother and a one-dimensional bad guy whose most noteworthy characteristic is his facial scar.

Even when it was revealed this week that Merchant Shim is Woon-shim’s first love, it felt contrived because his relationship with Woon-shim in the present has never hinted at a familiarity that extended beyond their current business transactions. Perhaps he’s supposed to be a dutiful little henchman who has been hardened over time, but it’s really hard to see him as anything more than a convenient plot device who pops in, causes trouble, and then miraculously escapes.

And how many times is it now that he’s been able to narrowly avoid arrest? I’ve legitimately lost count, and at this point, I don’t know whether to commend Merchant Shim for his wiliness or shame Young for his ineptitude. At some point, Young needs to stop being such a boy scout and just shoot Merchant Shim’s knee with an arrow and be done with it.

Even though all signs point to Merchant Shim being Young’s white whale, maybe Young should step aside and let Ro-seo take care of him. She’s the only one who seems capable of getting shit done. In just this week’s episodes she: saved Young from Merchant Shim, helped Young locate Merchant Shim’s underground bootlegging tunnel, rescued Chun-geum from Merchant Shim’s henchman, paid for Chun-geum’s freedom so she’s no longer a slave, called Woon-shim out for withholding information on Merchant Shim, and — oh, no big deal — pretty much single-handledly masterminded a heist to steal all of Merchant Shim’s money. And to celebrate all her accomplishments, she created a new cocktail with a nice lemony zest!

So, what exactly do the men vying for her attention bring to the table? I don’t often root for the second lead, but in my opinion Pyo is the one most worthy of her strength. I mean, when he showed up with Young to rescue Ro-seo and handed his sword to Young saying, “I’m about to obtain one soon,” I leget swooned a little bit. But on a less superficial level, he understands Ro-seo better. He may have grown up with all the superficial comforts of the palace, but unlike Young, he recognizes that what’s lawful isn’t always ethical or right for the people.

To be fair to Young, he’s starting to learn this, too, now that he’s been hanging out with Ro-seo and Pyo. But what else does Young have to offer besides his moral compass and a bland sense of humor? Hmmm… he can MacGyver a bow and arrow out of random stuff he finds in an underground tunnel. That’s what every woman looks for in a man, right?

Lest we forget, though, they have a childhood connection, and I called it! The tiger in Young’s memory was a metaphor for Ro-seo’s father, who — nicknamed the Tiger of the Southern Mountain — was a guard of the former crown prince. We haven’t been given enough puzzle pieces to see the full picture, but something important — likely tied to the former crown prince’s death — happened that night. Whatever it is, most of the people involved are now dead. Everyone except Young, Merchant Shim, and… (maybe) Shi-heum.

Shi-heum’s attendance that night is unknown, but the other big reveal this week was that he’s the Big Bad backing Merchant Shim and Woon-shim. I can’t say that I’m surprised. Despite his outward loyalty to the King, he — not his sister — has the most to gain from the former crown prince’s death. He’s also proven that he’s self-serving and a master manipulator, and he’s ensuring that the path is clear for Pyo to ascend the throne. The next step in his plan: marry Pyo off to Ae-jin.

Just when Young works up the gumption to give in to his feelings for Ro-seo and call off his wedding, his almost-future-father-in-law saves him the trouble. With his engagement broken, Young is one step closer to embracing a relationship with Ro-seo.

While he can acknowledge that alcohol isn’t inherently evil, he also can’t allow himself to be in a relationship with a bootlegger as long as her business is still illegal. So first he needs to arrest Merchant Shim and then petition the King to legalize alcohol again. Unfortunately, Young’s unwillingness to harm Merchant Shim when he had the chance(s) bites him in the ass, but instead of getting harmless teeth marks on his tooshie, Merchant Shim stabs him in the gut.

I may joke about the circumstances of the stabbing, but I was legitimately moved by the scene and the dramatic irony of knowing Ro-seo is waiting for him as he lay there, dying in the street. Also, even though I’ve sometimes questioned the oversaturated colors of the cinematography — looking at you freakishly pink flower blossoms — the light cast by the nearby lantern in contrast with the shadow of Young’s body was gorgeously tragic. It made me worry — for a moment — that Young might legitimately die.

But if Sang-mok can fall off a cliff, hit every rock on his way down, and still be able to walk away from it, I think Young can survive a little knife in his stomach, don’t you?


 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

22

Required fields are marked *

I agree that the women are the most compelling characters in this show. It's frustrating because there are so many good elements that could be part of a really interesting and innovative, but they're glued together by these really tacky dramaland elements, like really incompetent palace guards, or characters with super thick plot armor.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@daebakgrits Thank you for a very engaging review! I liked reading this more than watching the show 😂

I dropped it some eps ago, after going through exactly what you went, i.e., burnout. You've got it right on all the things that seem to be off about this show - 2D characters, an ML who's tired (YSH needs something more high energy?), and some ridiculous plot lines (Cliff of Not Doom, I remember reading in these pages - and yeah, that's just about where I dropped).

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hehe, remember people making crying emojis when i said on discord that I'm dropping this show after 1 ep! Back then I dropped for it being too over the top, looks like a wise decision, no?!😉

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

100%. These recaps by @daebakgrits are way more entertaining than the show itself. I only watch this drama when I want some background visual noise while I work, and I'm not quite sure what episode I'm on or what's going on with leads or what the hell is going on in this show but I'm always coming back just to read the recaps, lol

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

my favorite part was when Ro-Seo blew up merchant Shims storage with her gang behind her. it was so bad ass. she is one of my favorite drama heroins. She gets the job done, no need to wait for a man to rescue her, she rescues herself.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you, @daebakgrits, for the weecap! Yes, I too believe that Young will not die - better not be or else ... Though I like him with Ro-seo, he's so strait-laced that even reporting Merchant Shim is a big problem with his connection to Ro-seo.

2
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

The previews for the next episodes make seem that Young is alive but in hiding?

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Most likely. They can't kill the lead off in Ep. 10. 😂

Or can they?

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Only if he becomes a zombie/vampire… with a thirst for alcohol laden blood.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

There is a new trend in dramaland to keep someone dead for only one episode and bring it back lol. There is no chemistry between leads, their romantic lines are just plain emotionless dialogues, unfortunately, fast fwd. it. one is too energetic other one is too boring they don't go well with each other. young's character makes me drowsy, whenever he showed up on the screen I feel an urgent need for coffee. hehe

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

😂 I felt everything what you described in 1st ep only and dropped it!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap @daebakgrits! Something had to give for this relationship to go anywhere, and it's Young accepting that the prohibition law is hypocritical and has done more harm than good... (I'm still not on board with the way this show romanticizes drinking though). Ro-seo has also opened up to him that she likes making her own money. So that was the biggest development for me this week.

The rest was kind of boring. We could see the *gasp* plot twist of Chief Royal Secretary being the Big Bad a mile away. I had to laugh at the way Merchant Shim escaped from Young and ALL of the Office of Inspector's men. They're so bad at their job.

Oh, I almost forgot! Last week we were wondering if annoying orabeoni would make it out of that tunnel alive ... and everything seems to suggest he didn't *shivers* For a light fluffy sageuk I was quite shocked to see Shim's men slashing workers in their sleep.

One character that I'd like to see more is the young Queen. She's the old minister's granddaughter, but methinks she's not on her grandfather's side.

1
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

"I'm still not on board with the way this show romanticizes drinking though." Me either.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The worst show in that regard is Drinking Solo…
But if you really pay attention to tv shows in all countries, I don’t think there is one that doesn’t show the alcohol consumption as being glamour: either as the only way to have fun when between friends, or to relax and/or forget a bad day, or for being cute : when the male or female lead is drunk (then piggy back, funny talking, expressing feelings, confessing… cute being even verbally said by one of the protagonists…)
Kdramas are quite a few steps behind US ones in terms of glamour Ing somewhat decadent activities, but I’m wondering how long they will resist
(Yes, I am old school, an « old soul » in that regard 😉

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sometimes I wonder if sageuks have FLs with elder brothers just so that the word "orabeoni" can be used thousands of times.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Haha. My favorite is Gil-hyun Orabeoni from REBEL WHO STOLE THE PEOPLE. Such a smart and caring orabeoni.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

DiebakGrits, thank you for the recap.
My wife asked me what I thought. I told her the basic alcohol brewing selling smuggling story was interesting. I did say, in typical fashion, the writer ruins the story by adding the 4 square love, court shenanigans and childhood trauma connection. I’m still going to watch, lol.

If the writer had focused on a tale of legendary female moonshiner and her run ins/relationship with a lawman ,(without all the other mess ), it would be a breath of fresh air. Perhaps the Chinese could write drama like that.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This drama lacks Steadiness also, at one point it gets too serious and suddenly there's a comedy sometimes I get shocked. Like in epi. 5 after a failed mission to rescue sang mok from the cliff, they started with the comedy..I was like what now I have to laugh! LOL

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ro Seo & her band of outlaws are so much fun and the highlight of this drama to see while her relationship with Young is so endering,adore when he is always shocked by her deeds yet he still likes her…Always giggle at his reactions when he finds out her deeds…Pyo is also endering in his own…

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It has been a while since I watched an American show properly, but at times I feel like this drama could use a bit of that element those shows usually have.
For example, the love triangle. I am all for love squares and complicated lovelines which strings go all around the place, but in some American drama I have seen, they are more open for the characters to "explore" those lovelines. The characters can get together, see if it works, then break it off for whatever reason and try with someone else. Even in dramas where you know the endgame-ship, I have seen them still be attracted to others, even getting together with other people before or between being with each other. It is not just to see how the characters interact in different settings, but also for us to see either 1) why the endgame-ship is the better one, and/or 2) how the endgame-ship STILL chooses each other even if they know that their love is not special, that they get the same from others but still want to be together.

With many K-dramas, they put an emphasis on the lovestory between the FL and ML, and very few K-dramas I have seen have the FL actually, genuinely like/love or, god forbid, be in a good relationship with another man. Even more scandalous, have the FL and ML fall in love but still going for other people and falling in love with them instead. Thus, the love squares feel like filler rather than something that is relevant to the plot or character growth (and yes, this is another excuse to mention how "Seven Days Queen" is an example to how love triangles work for plot and growth and FURTHERMORE--).

At any rate, I also agree that the FL's story is much more interesting, and I would rather watch that story unfold, with the romance maybe a distant third (second would be the hot FoeYay rivalry between her and Merchant Shim, because I am weak to villains being personally interested in the heroine, I'm sorry). And I feel, had this been an American drama, they would have actually made the FL going around the law, making and selling alcohol, her past and her relationships with people around her be the focus, rather than the loveline. They would have the love triangle, but would have an easier time explore how she could love both of them at different times. Perhaps she would have preferred the prince, but when she finds out the truth, she knows that it would be impossible and would take away the little freedom she fights for, so she has to let it go (or being lied to gave her issues. There are multiple reasons to stay away from royalty). Meanwhile the weird and righteous lawman has grown, and they slowly start growing together as the laws seem to change. Or something.

Would it be a good drama? Probably not, American dramas stretched out beyond entertaining is an actual problem, I do not like the sexual focus in many of them, and they would probably put way too much emphasis on "showing it to THE MAN" than to show a (fantastical) side of government making those...

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

...unpopular decisions and how it affects the common masses.

This was basically just a long-winded way for me to say that I wish the story had focused on Ro-seo and her journey first and foremost, and her romance could have been a bonus or something. Because I am also getting a serious case of second lead syndrome, lmao, if only because Ro-seo is competent and the prince is, if nothing else, not as annoying.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap, really. I decided to pick this up a bit late, but I wanted to give it a chance despite the bad reviews it got on this site. I liked it... at first. But since episodes 7 and 8, I am drifting apart. I am bored. And the annoying thing for me is I cannot pinpoint exactly what's wrong with this. I can't say it's the plot because there are so many things happening. And the acting is fine too. But, I just don't know it just does not work. It just isn't interesting. There is something missing despite all elements being there. What a shame 😏

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *