109

You can only pick one: Piggyback scene


You can only pick one, and boy the pressure is on. The DB team will answer a new prompt in each post, and you’re invited to do the same in the comments. Ready to play?
 

You can only pick one piggyback scene


 
missvictrix: Not caring how much I get made fun of for loving this drama, my most memorable heart-clutching piggyback scene is between our monstrous hero and the girl he finds himself hating-yet-protecting in Bulgasal: Immortal Souls. I loved this scene because it was drenched in the complexity that Bulgasal was so good at — who are these characters to each other now, who were they in the past, and what will happen between them next? But also, it was just beautifully shot, and captured the comfort of someone’s physical closeness along with the epic vibe of a multi-lifetime saga unfolding.

solstices: I particularly love the piggyback in Today’s Webtoon, in which Ma-eum solves the problem of a drunk and passed out Joon-young by hoisting him up onto her back and carrying him all the way home. Not only is it a rare reversal of the trope, but I also like that it earns Ma-eum the awe of her colleagues instead of being played for laughs. It’s such a cute way to demonstrate her strength and set the stage for the pair’s friendship — one of my favorite things about this piggyback, and this show as a whole, is how the character relationships are allowed to exist simply as they are, in a simple yet sincere way.

Unit: In The Secret Life of My Secretary, it was already funny enough that Gal-hee was warming up to carry Min-ik for the “piggyback ride with your superior” game — even though according to her fellow secretaries, the boss never attended events like that. But then he showed up (shocker!) and presented his back for the ride (shocker, again!), lifting her effortlessly despite her protests, and they ended up winning the race. There was nothing romantic about the scene, but it was very hilarious and memorable.

Dramaddictally: Truth be told, I don’t love piggyback scenes. I think it’s because they sometimes feel jammed in without always fitting the story. So, when it came time to pick just one, I realized the scene had to be natural and feel sincere — and I decided on Just Between Lovers. There’s a scene where Kang-doo carries a depleted Moon-soo through a narrow, lamplit street after she’s had a horrible fight with her mother. The lead-up to this moment gives the piggyback context, but what’s beautiful about it is the conversation that’s happening as he carries her. She feels awful about the fight and wants to just run away and never go home. And no matter what she says, he’s enthusiastically on her side. She doesn’t want to go home? Fine, she can stay with him. She feels hatred toward herself ? Well then, he’ll just have to like her even more. It feels completely natural for these characters (whom I adore) because the piggyback presents itself like an offshoot of their already growing closeness, not a tropey tool to draw them closer.

alathe: Serious spoiler alert here! But truly, the piggyback scene in Mr. Sunshine is in a devastating league of its own. Because oh, could there have been a more gutting send-off for the resistance’s most stylish soldier, Yi Yang-hwa? In one final, glorious roar of defiance, she sets her own hotel ablaze — trapping an entire regiment of Japanese soldiers in wreck. But her death is a quieter affair. Dong-mae, the man who almost could have loved her, but didn’t, walks her on his back across the beach, so she can watch the sunset. I love these two fiercely because they’re the very definition of doomed by the narrative — both jaded, charmismatic anti-heroes, whose deaths are pretty much sealed from the start. Despite hitting every single romantic plot beat you could name, they can never quite find solace in each other. But still, Yang-hwa confesses her love. And still, Dong-mae carries her until she’s gone. Be still my tragedy-loving heart!

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , ,

109

Required fields are marked *

I'm with @dramaddictally. Not a huge fan of piggyback scenes - probably because of how over-used they are in dramas. The only memorable one I can think of is from Weightlifting Fairy Kim Bok-joo, where Bok-joo is just too tall to piggyback so the ML has to drag her along until he gets the idea to escort her home in an empty shopping cart 🤣.

24
17
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is the first scene I thought of! But did he just leave her in the grocery cart? That’s the way I remember it 😂

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think he did take her home. Feel like there was a scene of Bok-joo's dad yelling at him for letting her drink too much 😂.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love this scene as well. Talk about subverting the trope! (In fact, this is one of my favorite dramas for a whole bunch of reasons. There are several scenes that are tropey but are slightly twisted, because the FL is so strong and in truth, the better athlete of the two, although that's another thing I liked, its not a complete reversal in the sense that the FL is the athletic one and the ML is a total klutz. Both are athletes and can communicate on that level as well as others.

The reversal where the woman carrier is the athletic one (or at least the better drinker) has occurred several times, including the one @solstices mentioned, which by the way DID NOT allow a romance to follow which isn't a reversal of the trope, but a DESECRATION of it! Its like bringing in the white truck and failing to see any consequences. ("Oh well, the white truck broke your leg. Lets move on." I haven't actually seen that in a show, but if it happened, as a white truck aficionado I would be outraged!) Or having met in childhood and not being in some way romantically entagled because of it! (Multiple met in childhood stories have the childhood companion as the loser in a love triangle, or as a confidante who is mistaken as a rival by the ML, but there is always some sort of romantic complication!)

But I do have a question about the piggyback scene. Is piggyback really the easiest way to transport someone home? I've been a pretty strong guy all my life, and I'm not sure the piggyback method would be the most effective, as opposed to the hoist over the shoulder method, which is what I would use for my wife if she somehow became inebriated to the point of immobility, or, more likely, what I would advise to her if I'm in that state. (Neither will ever happen.)

8
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

I want to assure everyone that I am well aware that the romantic advantage of the piggy back method is that the heads are right next to each other, allowing intimacy, whereas the the head being next to the waist would if anything, be anti-romantic. But I think it would be easier!

8
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The weight is on the back and not the arms, so it's better. On the shoulders, if the person is not consious, it can work, otherwise it would be very unconfortable and the blood would rush in the head.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel like I've seen Koreans using piggyback even on mountain hikes to bring tired/injured people down. Definitely seen it in reality shows. Maybe also in Business Proposal? So they definitely think of it as the most efficient method. Don't know if that's validated by actual rescue people though!

7
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

I suppose it's just practical because if there's is no help and/or special equipment to transport an injured person properly, piggyback is the least physically draining and traumatizing to the person who does carrying method to get the job done. Bridal carry and other types are just not it in the long run.

4
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

@kurama, @miso2019, @gikata In all seriousness (as if we should be serious on the topic) the so called "fireman's carry" --the body stretched horizontally across two shoulders, the carrier holding the arm and the legs-- avoids the blood rushing to the head by the carried, and is much easier on the carrier as well. Of course, this is if the carried is drunk to the point of stupor, but I can testify it also works for children having a shrieking meltdown in public (although I haven't attempted it on my children as adults even when they are having shrieking meltdowns.)

I was just thinking of what I call the "sack of potatoes" method for its amusing effect.

6

@hacja, fireman's carry is for stronger/trained people because to do that you need to successfully lift another person up there first, which not everyone can do... Piggybacks are easier to try technically imo.

Potato sack carry is when a person is draped over carrier's one shoulder, legs front, I assume? I think it's also called barbarian kidnapping style, at least in trashy romance media))) I've seen it in a drama not so long ago and it was highly amusing indeed. Probably not so much for poor actors though, it looks anything but comfortable...

3

There is one pretty cool bridal-style-subverting-the-trope-scene: in "Strong Woman Do Bong Soon".

Do Bong-soon has to carry Ahn Min-hyuk after an assasination attempt, and she hilariously does so in full on bridal style. 🤣🤣🤣

Had this thread not been about piggybacks, this would have been my favourite.

7

This is done to amusing—and found-brother-creating—effect in the movie Midnight Runners, right at the beginning.

One of our main characters hurts his leg on a stressful, timed military hike, and the other risks failing the exercise to save him on piggyback.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Park Seo-joon's character was bribed a good steak if he were to carry Kang Ha-neul's character to the finish line since the latter's family owned a butcher shop. Steak better than those puny sausages...lol

3

As soon as I saw this question, this was the one I thought of too! I don't mind piggyback scenes, but I love when they break the mold a little!

1

To your question, i always wonder why they don’t just skip the piggyback and take a taxi.. but it wouldn’t be a drama then..

8
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really liked Weightlifting Fairy, but have never figured out the fairy reference in the title? Because Kim Bok Joo did not remind me of a tiny flying Tinkerbelle! Or is a fairy different in Korea? The SK goblin is different from the ugly mean western creatures so perhaps fairies are too? Or I'm misunderstanding the meaning completely!

2
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think 역도요정/ Weightlifting Fairy was Jang Mi-ran's actual nickname given by Korean media. The drama is loosely inspired by her life.

Korean media has a tendency to add such appellations to famous athletes to distinguish them and highlight their achievements. Park Tae-hwan for instance was known as 'Marine Boy'.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ok that makes sense! Thank you. I thought it was likely something Koreans would understand but I always wondered! USA does the same, we have sports pros Magic and the Rock, and music artists like the Boss, the King of Rock n Roll, and the Piano Man.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favorite piggyback scene was a reversal of roles that just highlighted how much our female lead actually do care deeply for our beta male lead. Its Yeon Su carrying a drunk Ung in Our Beloved Summer.

12
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don’t pay attention to piggyback scenes since they are so common. However, it’s been a long time since I rewatched COFFEE PRINCE and I’m not sure if I’m remembering correctly but I think there was a scene where Eun-chan carried/ piggybacked Han-gyul back home? The scene was memorable because I was just starting my kdrama obsession and it’s the first time I seen a of that subversion trope.

20
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was going to mention Coffee Prince as well!

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Coffee Prince was my first thought, both for the piggyback you mention, but also the one where Han-gyul piggybacks Eun-chan and he starts jogging and swinging her around. It's the first piggyback scene I remember watching where the ML wasn't struggling to carry his FL, lol!

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

My pick is Coffee Prince - the scene of Han-gyul piggybacked Eun-Chan downhill, both with broad smile on their face. Two people in love and not afraid (or care) to show the world their affection for each other. The love and happiness is so infectious in that scene.

It is my first piggyback scene from an early drama but still so vivid in my mind.

@linarrick - yes, there is the reverse piggyback in the early part of the drama that Eun Chan carried a drunk Han-gyul back home.

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

These were the first that came to mind for me as well! Eun Chan laboriously struggles to get Han Gyul home and dropping him by his door, and my favorite when he is swinging her on his back, like she weighed nothing! A joyful, playful scene, he also pretends he can't carry her anymore and then takes off running when she gets down.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Simply lovely and authentic - that’s why those scenes are long lasting in our collective memories.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can any of my Beanies shed light on this practice? It isn’t confined to SK, is it? I had not come across this before watching KDs as in the west, piggybacking is mainly given to kids and not adults. I don’t think it exists in the Middle East for all sorts of reasons. Is it a way for men to manifest their masculine strength without manhandling the women? I have noticed that in KDs, where the dudes hands are placed are very carefully calibrated.
It is mostly given by boys and men to girls and women respectively and older women get them too at times. Is it feasible because KD female actors are by and large all so thin that they can be carried but that’s not really possible when women have ordinary bodies.
As you see, I have so many questions about this.

20
18
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didn’t know such a thing existed before kdramas (and was like, WTH???) 🤨

12
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same here, when I first started watching kdramas I thought wow, everyone is gorgeous and the stories are so interesting, and then what's with these piggyback rides, and wrist grabs, and frozen wide-eyed kissing...

14
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

‘when I first started watching kdramas I thought wow, everyone is gorgeous and the stories are so interesting, and then what's with these piggyback rides, and wrist grabs, and frozen wide-eyed kissing...’👈🏾 I think that would make a great headline for a Welcome to K dramaland! Here are some things you need to know checklist…I think that’s exactly why the Javebeans and Girl Friday book was needed.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hehe yes! There were definitely some cultural things that stood out when I first started watching Kdramas!! Piggyback rides and dead fish kiss scenes shot from multiple angles and TODs... My first impression also was of so much yelling and hitting!! Between parents and kids and friends always arguing and hitting. Now I hardly notice, just another piggyback ride! 😁

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was so curious about some of these things I made a detour while flying between California and Hong Kong to stop in Seoul. Didn't see any piggybacking or wrist grabs, but got some omurice.

6

i am ALWAYS AMAZED when women give men the piggyback, even if their feet are dragging, but most times the men's feet are not....

i couldn't do that for my husband and he's not even that big, i probably weigh 20 pounds less than him, but... no. i couldn't do it.

10
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

There is no way I could give my husband a piggyback, he’s over a foot taller than me 😅. Even if I could in some amazing feat of strength actually hold his weight, he’d need to be actively holding his feet off the ground.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

I’m not sure about the practice in South Korea but I remember piggybacking my friends during camp, it was the easiest way to carry them, the weight distribution evened out

6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not sure if you've read the old posts JavaBeans and Girl Friday did, but they give a little insight into some of the tropes.
https://www.dramabeans.com/2010/07/pop-culture-piggyback-rides/

20
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Beverly: Thanks so much for this. What a great little read.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for doing that for us, there are so many gems on the site and I really appreciate those who are more tech savvy than me doing this type of beanie community service.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was searching for this link. You beat me to it.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks @beverly. I remember this post (and Coffee Prince was mentioned therein.)

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Super! Thank you!

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

When I was growing up, piggybacks were given to young children by their fathers or older brothers, especially when the child is tired or wants a better view of what is going on (hike, shopping, etc.) I can't remember it being a gateway for adult relationships.

7
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

And I wonder if this tradition came from cradleboards, is a device traditionally used by Native American indians to secure babies in place (typically for the first year or so) while their parents travelled, worked or were otherwise occupied.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have only seen piggyback ride in kdramas and cdramas.
But I knew the word/expression in english before, so I had I had encountered it pre-dramaland. I believe that it is more limited to children and some sort of student sport play.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't find piggybacks that weird.

I know about real life non-korean piggyback experiences.
A sunbae told me that one time she had to carry her friend after a party.
Same thing happen in a reunion with my friends. My bestie was so freaking drunk two friends had to carry her to bed.

And while playing I've carried my mom and brother and they have carry me. Yeah, I'm not a kid but I still play with my family. 😆 It's kinda normal here. I've seen other people do the same. Friends, family.

The strange part for me is that kdramas try to make drunk people seem romantic or fun. Well, they can be funny sometimes.

Oh, and the long walks seem kinda unrealistic to me. People usually just sleepover or take a cab.
Even when you're just messing around with someone and they carry you, that doesn't last more than 30secs, unless you're competing or something. LOL

You're right, kdramas make piggybacks seem different. It becomes about gender roles and romance. Even though carrying a drunk person is the most unromantic thing in the world. 😂😂

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have a tie, both piggy backs including death:
@alathe’s pick from Mr Sunshine
And
Kang Ha Neul carrying his wife through the snow as she passes away in Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo, both of them followed through the drifts by the woman he really loves (IU).
Both were Sob City for me, and unforgettable 😭

16
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

With the OST... The scene was beautiful!

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yesx1000! For all my conflicting feelings about MOON LOVERS in general and KHN's character in particular, that scene was deliciously haunting and probably the most memorable of them all with this trope.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Coffee Prince. Hands down.
Eun-chan carrying Han-kyul made me laugh.

My favorite though is when Han-kyul practically dances down the street carrying Eun-chan.

15
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me too!

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me three!

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favorite piggyback scene is from episode 5, My Ajusshi when Dong-hoon piggybacks grandma up the stairs to the house.
Ji-an had taken her grandmother outside in a shopping trolley so her grandmother could see the moon. After he helps her home, Ji-an settles her grandmother and comes out to thank Dong-hoon and he turns to her and says to her" you're a good person" .
A beautiful scene with few words but so many feelings.

16
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, that one! My other fav is the ML in Hometown Cha Cha giving a ride to his adoptive grandma because her legs hurt so much.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh that scene in My Ahhussi is beautiful

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like piggyback scenes where our leads secretly like each other. I loathe drunk piggyback scenes because being passed out drunk is not cute.

So I pick the piggyback scene in May I Help You? that happens because Tae-hee drives his car into a ditch, forcing Dong-joo and him to stay the night in the countryside. As they walk back to the house, she scolds him for reckless driving and whines about her sprained ankle, so he carries her, and when she asks how are they going to get home tomorrow, he cutely answers, "I'll piggyback you if I have to."

11
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I recently watched Search: WWW and tiny Tammy piggybacking a very tall Scarlett was cute!

10
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My very favorite piggyback scene is from Hello, Me! The ML (a wonderful Kim Young Kwang playing one of the nicest chaebols ever) has been getting to know the FL. He runs into her after she's been drinking, and they have a conversation while he gives her a piggyback home. He realizes that she's started crying, and without drawing attention to that or asking her why, he takes her around the block one more time. It's a lovely moment of companionship and comfort.

12
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Mr. Sunshine!

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Question: Do S Koreans still piggy back? Or does this happen in dramas only? I've been to Korean and I've never seen anyone piggybacking.

7
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am convinced it’s a K dramaland thing. I think one drama did it appropriately but everyone who saw it loved it and now it is a trope they will shoehorn in just because it’s a romance. It is like cherry blossom falling like snowflakes when there is no breeze and the trees are still full it’s not a romance without it.

10
reply

Required fields are marked *

Maybe you have not been drunk enough 🤣🤣🤣

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have seen many but nothing sticks to my mind but reading the post and fellow beanies comments I think Mr Sunshine and the scene where Kang Ha-neul's character carries his dead wife on his back in Moon Lovers are the most emotional ones.

11
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This one is quite dark cause it followed with death and a funeral.

Dae Jo-young - Two of Dae Jo-young's finest are trapped in a skirmish with Tang warriors and Guem Sa-wol has hurt her leg so she's unable to run away. So while they were able to get away from been caught in the middle of enemy soldiers, they still had to escape as quick as possible. In what was both one last act of bravery and love, Guem Sa-wol asks the guy who is also her love interest to piggyback them out of sight. Pros - she can't run so it'll take them quickly out of enemy lines. Cons - there's a 100% chance she'll get hit by enemy arrows.
Both the pros and cons played out. Both of them knew there was no way they were both getting away alive if the piggyback didn't happen due to her injured leg. Both of them also knew she was signing her death warrant with her suggesting the piggyback.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favorites have been mentioned already (My Ajusshi, Coffee Prince). I'm not that crazy about piggybacking as a romantic device because it assumes a certain gender size/weight ration akin to pairs figure skating. But I did like the one in Jang Bori Is Here, which was both nice and comedic. Also amusing as I recall was Jung Gyu-woon repeatedly lugging Hong Soo-Hyun uphill in History of a Salaryman. But my final pick is Arang in Arang and the Magistrate pretending to be out cold and then alertly jumping off at the piggyback destination.

7
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't really swoon over piggyback scene. It's often about a drunk girl who's about to vomit on the poor guy...

So I guess the most remarkable are the sad ones. And Mr Sunshine did so well. It was connected to their first beach scene when he asked her if she wanted a piggyback ride to comfort her. Both actors did so well. It wasn't very easy for YYS to carry her on his back, walking in the sand and acting an very emotional scene.

I was very impressed by Kim Seul-Gi (1m62) carrying Lee Jin-Hyuk (1m85) on her back in Find Me in Your Memory 😂

8
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was going to add Kim Seul-Gi carrying Sung Hoon (Weekend in Bernie's style) in I Picked Up a Celebrity on the Street, but I just realized it's Kim Ga-Eun.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favourite piggyback scene is in "Possessed" (towards the end of episode 9).

Pil-seong (whose body has temporarily taken over by a dead cop) carries the cop's drunk daughter on his back. She does not recognise him as the ghost of her father of course, but she talks about her childhood and how it feels like her dad is carrying her on his back.

Without the context of the drama, the description of it sounds weird, but it is quite a moving scene when you watch it.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not a fan of piggyback rides. (I don't even count them!)
It's quite often when one is drunk, and I find it a little tedius.

However, when reading the promp there is one scene that came to my mind : in My holo love it's the koala ride, particularly in the last ep. The koala as a subversion of the piggyback, now that's amusing.

12
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh I loved that scene!!!😊

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like that we now have a metric for interpreting the prevalence of a k-drama trope: “Does @darwi count it?”

If so, it’s of interest. If not…it’s overdone!

6
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

You're making me blush ! I have only seen 103 kdramas, there are others with more viewing experience.
The counting started because among the first kdramas that my friend and I watched, there were several "propagnosia" and "falling elevator". Having found Dramabeans, I had heard about "frequent tropes" and thus found funny that these two rare real life situation seemed so frequent in dramaland. I wanted to check. Turn out that these two are not so frequent. (maybe future treasure hunt?)

btw, have you looked at my dramalist-template ? I've made a few improvements. [link in my fanwall for any Beanie that likes to count and rank]

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Do you have the count of hospitals that have burned down so we can't find the birth records?? I always find that one ridiculous.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sorry, I don't. You should propose it for a treasure hunt (so I can update my file 😜)

1

I was wondering the same thing about the recent “treasure hunt” for scenes in which people return to the orphanage they lived in as a child. @darwi - do you keep track of that trope?

1
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes and no... I have not read yet the answers to the treasure hunt. I'm eager to discover in which dramas this happens because at the moment it's only a pre-trope .
It's a scene we have seen in two or three dramas (ok the count is 5 now) so it did not reach the trope-threshold when first observed/noted.
I submitted a few pre-trope (we usually notice that it happens in two dramas what we watch the same week) for the treasure hunts.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I swear it started because a specific scene happened in two different dramas... I'm not mapping all scenarii.
I just happened to watch FL ask ML to hug her, hug strongly, hug stronger, ok now that's too strong I cannot breathe in Extraordinary Attorney Woo Young Woo and Love like the galaxie a few days apart. These are the week repeat.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Your attention to detail leaves me flabbergasted…

I don’t think I’ve read anywhere that anybody is keeping track of bodily function tropes, which seem to be as prevalent as wrist grabs, piggybacks, and open-eyed kisses. The subcategories would include: vomiting (drunk vomiting, vomiting due to overeating or to seeing something nauseating, etc.); hiccuping, especially connected to physical attraction; belching; diarrhea (I often fast-forward through these scenes); and the ever-popular, much-discussed nosebleed. There are probably more subcategories that I’ve missed.

Am I being too graphic? I certainly don’t want to cause anyone to vomit!

1

That's correct, I do not count bodily functions. It never occurred to me because It don't find them amusing, and do not really want to pay attention to these scene.
However, I count the occurrence of "strange/creative illness" in cdramas. Allergy to one's tears, memory of women that erase when it rains...

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hiccups can be cute, but I agree with you that the rest are for the most part pretty disgusting.

The reason I brought it up was that I had just fast-forwarded through a diarrhea scene in Romantic Doctor Teacher Kim<\ 3, and was thinking about how often this trope appears in kdramas. I guess some people find it hysterical, or they wouldn’t keep using it. (There are apparently a lot of people who think the toilet scene in Dumb and Dumber is one of the funniest moments in movie history. As the song says, “different strokes for different folks.”)

Have you noted any odd illnesses in kdramas? Would you count Min-Joon’s allergy to human bodily fluids in My Love From the Star, or do you count only human illnesses?

0

@babylilo I'm with you on toilet humour... it doesn't sit well.
I cannot remember where I read that bodily function are the basic link between humans because everybody experience them. That's why little children find the word "poop" hilarious. In my opinion, if you have to resort to such basic humour, then its an indication that the scrip and scenario are lacking depth. Minus 10 in creativity.

There is the human allergy in I'm not a robot. But the "absurd illness" is more a cdrama staple for me. (Yes I have a different list of tropes). I would count allergy to bodily fluids. I have not seen, and do not plan to watch My love from the star as the FL seems over-played.

2

I also don't like scenes where drunk characters given piggyback rides.

I like the piggyback ride in Business Proposal where Jin Young Seo (Seol In Ah) sprained her ankle while being irritated at Cha Sung Hoon (Kim Min Kyu) while mountain climbing/getting lost. They made up right after the piggyback, then there was another piggyback where Young Seo wanted to go home for shenanigans and Sung Hoon wanted to go to the hospital for safety reasons.

7
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I find that I actually do have “only one” of these…and it’s directly related to my “Only One Park Seo-Joon Drama,” because it’s Itaewon Class again.

Now, before you think I only like one drama…hear me out. What I like about the use of this trope here is that it is, IMO, sets up the full character arc for both parties. It’s really well-done.

The piggyback ride in question is in episode 2, so, very early on for a drama that feels like every minute of its 16+ hours (even for fans!). Park Sae-ro-yi has just been released from prison and he heads straight to Oh Soo-ah in Itaewon, because of the letters she had been writing him while he was incarcerated.

He finds her there and they have an unexpectedly normal (for both, but especially for him—as he’s been very quickly thrown back into society without help) night out on the town.

At the end of the evening, Park Sae-ro-yi then gives Oh Soo-ah a piggyback ride all the way up what must be one of the tallest set of neighborhood stairs in all of Itaewon to her house. Step-by-step he carries her home while they talk about who they are to each other in semi-cloaked language.

The drama downplays that they were drunk (for example, PSJ’s clown makeup is mysteriously completely gone), and instead focuses on Park Sae-ro-yi’s strength and commitment (literally and figuratively). We watch Oh Soo-ah basically learn how much she still means to him, and this is the first time I feel she really has to figure out what to do with that given her own life choices—and this is the crux of the drama, frankly. Seen first, right here on this piggyback ride.

At the top of the steps, they then talk face-to-face in what ends up being one of the most heartbreaking moments of the show (again, IMO). When they are in piggyback, they can connect. When they are not, it appears much harder, perhaps impossible.

7
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love the way you have written this.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you!

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have not watched the drama I only got to episode one and walked away. I looked up the scene and it really is a very good example of the use of a piggy back scene.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow! Thanks for making that effort! I’m so glad you found it worth your time. It was very memorable to me, obvs.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree that the one from "Mr. Sunshine" is perhaps the most memorable and emotionally powerful, but I hated that that was the end of their never-quite-got-there romance! Beautifully acted scene, but in a drama filled with tragedy, it felt like too much at the time.

So I'm going with Reply1988. When I watched it, I already knew which man would ultimately win Deok-sun's heart, but I still wasn't sure who would ultimately carry her off the soccer field when the game suddenly broke up because of a hemorrhoid explosion (still don't quite get this medically, but ok) and due to her already injured ankle, someone had to give her a piggyback ride home, and someone else had to take care of Mr. Poop Pants. There was something about Park Bo-Gum's character awkwardly and then determinedly picking her up in the midst of all the chaos and making sure she wasn't left behind that got me. Prior to that, his character didn't have many typically or overtly manly moments, and that was fine with me. His mastery of Go and awkward sweetness were both plenty attractive. But when he makes sure Deok-sun is taken care of without hesitation, it made him finally seem like a person who could not only exist outside of his own headspace, but who also would be a loving, involved partner.

12
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Which do you prefer in you drama, drunk piggy back rides, injury piggy back rides, or piggy back rides just because?

2
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Like others here, I'm not a fan of the drunk piggyback. It usually ends with the girl throwing up on the guy and that's just disgusting. Also, I've never thought there was anything appealing about a drunk partner when you're the sober one, annoying yes, appealing no. Either of the other two options are okay if we must have a piggyback scene at all.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

As long as there is no vomit of destiny presented, I'm good with any option, but 2 and 3 are the best)))

There is this minor but super sweet scene in WHAT HAPPENS TO MY FAMILY? weekender when youngest OTP (still during "will they/won't they" phase) get off from work and play rock-paper-scissors, loser piggyback carries winner for 10 or so steps, then they play again. Guy loses multiple times in a row - most likely on purpose - and clearly has the time of his life carrying the girl. At some point he drops an act and just keeps going, both VERY happy with it anyway. It's pure diabetes, really)))

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

As a person who had a lot of sprains to the ankle, it always makes me laugh when the girl sprains her ankle and can't walk anymore but the next day, it's like nothing happened.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Chuno has a masterfully directed piggyback ride scene, where the PD juxtaposes two couples. Weary Dae Gil is carrying drunk street urchin Seol Hwa on his back, while reminiscing about his first love Eon Nyeon. When Seol Hwa drops her haegeum (small string instrument), he picks it up. At the same time, 2ML carries injured Eon Nyeon on his back. She drops a small stone (the only keepsake from her first love Dae Gil, whom she believes to be dead), but nobody notices and the stone is lost forever. This is a very beautiful and sad scene which also foreshadows the ending.

7
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watched this show a long time ago, and had forgotten this lovely scene. Thanks for bringing it up!

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

in my roommate is a gumiho, when lee dam had to piggyback her hilariously drunk friend do jae-jin. mainly because i was amazed she could carry him at all. and because i loved their friendship.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just like many other beanies, I'm not a fan of piggyback scenes (but I prefer when the reason is feet pain or broken shoes than when a character is drunk).

I'll pick At a distance, spring is green because it was when FL talked quite sincerely to ML for the first time since they met.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me the most memorable one on mind right now is piggyback between seo woojin and cha eunjae dr romantic season2. It's also the one when it turn thing around for t
Woojin view on EunJae about her struggle all this time through med school..it's such a surreal scene and welk directed.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Absolutely My Name is Kim Sam Soon - ep 2 - the stuffed piggy punches and ‘chemical warfare’ as Jin Heon piggybacked Sam Soon - this is my most memorable kdrama piggyback of all times!

6
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favourite, in “Girls’ Generation 1979”, is not so much the piggyback scene itself, but the next-day breakdown in the classroom. Jung Hee spills the beans to her squad, and her friend teases Jung Hee for having rubbed her chest against her crush’s back! I hadn’t seen this aspect discussed in a Kdrama before.

6
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

🤣🤣 Please give us the episode so we can enjoy watching that scene it sounds really funny.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's the first episode.

But you should watch the whole drama. It was a very good one with humor but they didn't forget the area. The OST was great. The drama starts with ABBA!

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ok, there are some dramas that have you from the opening scene and you know if they continue on the same level throughout they are going to be fighting for a slot in your already very tightly contested top ten. Thanks to you and Kurama I am 15 minutes into the first episode and know that this is going to be a very enjoyable binge watch.

I get why you chose your name tag now😊

6
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for being the first person in nearly 6 years whom I’ve helped convince to watch this drama! I can’t get enough of it. I’m on my 15th time around with it right now. I still think Jung Hee’s character arc is the most realistically satisfying I’ve seen in Kdramaland.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It sounds like you were talking to the wrong crowd, which must have been very frustrating for you. On this site, surely the beanies have either seen it already or would be happy to add to their long watchlist.

I finished it today and I must say it was very good. It’s in my ever growing list of of top 25-50 dramas. It was really well written and acted and it was a lovely journey towards character growth for most. I like coming off age dramas and young love genres. I like the fact it was away from the Seoul accent and we saw realistic portrayals of status and class. However, there are certain elements that I will tolerate in a drama/film but any drama containing them can’t go in the top ten. I don’t like being exposed to toxic things for entertainment. So even if it’s a tiny percentage of the over all story the murkiness lingers for me.

There are some dramas that brought me joy but had to be demoted from the top ten as new ones came in and that’s why it went from a top 25 to a top 50 list.

My top ten are the dramas that bring me joy, shift my mood and leave a warm glow for most of the air time.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh gosh, I needed a trigger warning re Junghee’s dad he is NEARLY as bad as the dad in Kim Jiyoung born 1982, who said it was Jiyoung’s fault the stalker tried to follow her off the bus.

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

So many good ones! Not my favorite, but the one that I think stuck out to me the most was in Moon Lovers, and I didn't even finish the drama. It's the one where the 2ML/Kang Ha-neul was piggybacking his terminally ill wife. During the piggyback, she dies. His steps faltered and his eyes shook with grief in that moment when she passes, and then he continues piggybacking her. And then you have that Lee Sun-hee soundtrack song playing making it EXTRA sad.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I vaguely remember something but I don't recall from where. Either a reality show of 'behind the scenes' video. Actors/celebrities were in a car stuck in Seoul traffic when one of them looks the her right and squees with delight. There on the city sidewalk right next to them she spots a young couple piggy back riding 'in the wild' like a K-drama come to life. Everyone in the car had an 'Awh...' moment.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Piggy back scenes to me look very uncomfortable, especially when women are piggy backing men who are strangers (even if they are eventual male leads). One of the tropes that I find completely redundant, unless it's a life and death situation. I haven't seen any that has impressed me. The only one that made sense and was done realistically was Seargent Sung-On carrying Crown Prince Yi-Hwan to a pharmacy when he was greiviously injured (Sung-On was sweating profusely while CP looked deathly pale. That was well done). In a situation like this, a tall man carrying another very tall dead weight man with his weight distributed evenly across the back makes absolute sense.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeon-sue (Kim Da-mi) carry a drunk Ung (Choi Woo-sik) in Our Beloved Summer.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My pick is (hear me out) Personal Taste. The hilarity of these two is absolutely wonderful 🤣🤣🤣

First off, it's far from romantic because she thinks he's gay, also she's drunk and is suffering for a heartbreak. He is pissed off, snappy and done with her. But then she falls asleep on a bench and sprains her ankle and he carried her.

The most important thing about the scene though is how it moves the plot forward by revealing some things about both characters:

Jeon Junho - It reveals how much his respects women and how kind he really is under all that brusqueness

Park Gae In - It reveals a bit of her childhood trauma with her dad and why why she is a sucker when in love.

All in all, a beautiful piggyback ride 🤗

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love the piggyback scenes LOL you can't write a kdrama without them (or subway LOL). I can't pick a favorite!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *