38

Poong the Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

As our new entrants settle into the clinic, we welcome an old member of the family and get a peek into their mentor’s backstory. Danger also lurks around our hero, because even though he has left his past behind, the people in his past are not willing to let go of him.

 
EPISODES 3-4 WEECAP

Poong the Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4 Poong the Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

Rejoining our clinic family this week is their cook, NAM-HEE (Yeon Bora) whose presence adds another spark to the dynamics of the family. With her arrival also comes a murder, and an enthusiastic Eun-woo goes with Poong (who’s scared of corpses, lol) to inspect the body. The suspect is a killer dubbed Gumiho by the villagers, but Gumiho was supposedly arrested a year ago. Eun-woo notices the cutting on the body is different from Gumiho’s signature cut, and discusses her findings with her father, the district governor. But they’re interrupted by the arrival of Shin-woo, the royal inspector from Hanyang (and her father’s old student).

Unlike what you’d expect from an old student, Shin-woo is pretty formal, and slightly condescending towards the district governor for arresting the wrong man. And if that’s not enough to roll our eyes at him, we also learn he’s the adopted son of the second state councilor and was sent by his father in search of Poong. Shin-woo entrusts this task to the high and mighty COMMANDER IM (Kim Hyung-mook), but at the clinic, Commander Im cannot find an acupuncturist Yoo Se-yeob — just a Poong who can’t perform acupuncture. Lol.

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

One of the clinic’s patients sleepwalks to the scene of a second murder, and with all the evidence pointing to her, she is arrested as Gumiho. To prove she just has a sleepwalking condition and is not a murderer, Poong and Ji-han take Shin-woo to trail after the girl, who sleepwalks out of her cell into the mountains. She collapses beside a grave and has to be taken back into detention, but Ji-han manages to persuade Shin-woo to allow him to visit her daily for some treatment.

On one of such visits, the girl tells them she saw a goblin shoot a star down from a tree and her words don’t make any sense until Eun-woo and Poong go back to the crime scene, and Eun-woo deduces that the victims were shot by an arrow from the tree. True to her suspicion, Eun-woo digs out a broken piece of arrow from one of the bodies, proving that an arrow was the main cause of death and the Gumiho-like cut was just a cover up.

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

To successfully frame the sleepwalking girl, the killer would need to have known her condition. Hence Jang-goon – thanks to his incredibly retentive memory – digs out the records of the patients who visited the clinic the day the sleepwalking girl was loudly diagnosed, and all roads lead to… Eun-woo’s brother-in-law! Wow! Apparently, he’s working in cahoots with Commander Im to illegally hunt rare animals in the mountains, and had to silence the victims who were looking into the matter.

With her husband’s memorial coming up, Eun-woo returns to her in-laws, but her motive is to search for evidence to prove her brother-in-law’s guilt. He catches her snooping around and tries to strangle her, unconsciously revealing where the murder weapon is, and Shin-woo enters to arrest him. His mother blames Eun-woo for ruining both her sons, but Poong says that based on the clinic’s records, Eun-woo’s husband had stomach cancer and died because his mother relied on talismans rather than getting him proper treatment. Eun-woo then pays her last respects to her husband and cuts off a piece of her hanbok, signifying the ties she has cut with his family. Yes!!

Poong the Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4 Poong the Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

Eun-woo’s desire to help people like Poong does, makes him encourage her to join them in the clinic and study medicine. Poong also drops the formal address of “my lady” and calls her by her first name: Eun-woo. Almost like a rebirth from living under societal dictates to living for herself. Awww. I find it really sweet how Poong always tries his best to bring solace to people. First to the sleepwalking girl, for whom he made a doll as a replacement for the one made by her mother (whose grave she sleepwalks to), and now to Eun-woo. As Eun-woo said, he might not have been able to use acupuncture to cure the girl, but he was able to use the needle (from stitching the doll) to help her. Indeed, what makes a doctor is not his tools, but his heart towards his patients.

Back in Hanyang, one of the king’s court ladies dies, noticeably from the same ailment as the late king. But before her death, she tells the king about a court lady involved in the late king’s death. The court lady in question is the witness to Poong’s father’s assassination, and is currently on the run from the second state councilor. The assassin, who now appears to be Shin-woo, asks Commander Im if the new doctor (Poong) could be Se-yeob, and Commander Im says no. But Im has already pieced Poong’s identity together, and knows he is Se-yeob. He reveals this to Poong and tries to recruit him to his side, but Poong turns him down.

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

While Poong has found satisfaction in treating the common people, Man-bok bemoans his master’s fate and believes that if Poong didn’t have hand tremors and could still perform acupuncture, he might have had a shot at being called back to the medical office. The clinic then gets a patient who suffers from hand tremors — a noble lady, brought in by her fiancé who appears to be the most caring man in the world. But on a closer look, he’s borderline obsessive – not allowing Poong to take the lady’s pulse because he’s a man, and doing all the talking on her behalf.

Man-bok overhears Poong’s prescription for the tremors (meat and some herbs) and complains that his master isn’t cured because the clinic doesn’t give them any meat. Heh. A frustrated Ib-bun tells him to go catch some meat himself and Man-bok goes to catch a rabbit. Poong refuses to eat the cute rabbit, lol, so Man-bok returns to the mountains to search for herbs instead. There, he sees the noble lady and her manservant on the run, but he assumes the servant is a threat to the lady and confronts him. He’s knocked out and when he comes to, he is beside the now-dead servant and arrested for the murder. Yikes!

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

To clear Man-bok’s name, Poong visits the noble lady with Eun-woo – who now dons colorful outfits and wears her hair down like a single lady as opposed to the widow’s whites and hair in a bun style of married women – but her fiancé insists that she was at home the whole day. Hearing his sarcastic remarks about how he’d pay a fortune if there was a female doctor to check the lady’s pulse, Eun-woo decides to do just that. But first, she has to actually learn the location of all the pulse points. Thankfully, Poong is a good teacher and she’s a quick learner.

With a three-day day countdown to Man-bok’s execution, Poong and Eun-woo sneak back into the lady’s house and Eun-woo is finally able to take her pulse. They convince the lady to accompany them to the servant’s grave (dug by Poong, as the poor man was just left to rot away, unburied), and we learn the servant and the lady became friends as they grew up together. She promises to confess to his murder the following day. But our clinic family doesn’t believe she did it and tries to figure out who the killer is on their own.

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

Poong and Eun-woo realize that the fiancé is the only person who mentioned that the servant was strangled (information they know, but was kept from the people who think he died from being stabbed), and they’re able to deduce that the fiancé is the killer. Unfortunately, he kidnaps the lady, and takes her with him on the run.

After searching for hours, they hear that the fiancé is headed to the docks in the hopes of getting on a ship, but it’s almost time for Man-bok’s execution. Poong begs Shin-woo for a horse and constables to accompany him to the docks in order to bring back the killer, and Shin-woo puts his foot down at using the government’s resources for personal reasons. But with Poong on his knees and Shin-woo’s flashback to how Poong buried the servant, Shin-woo relents and provides the horse. He tells them the execution will proceed as planned if they don’t return before then with the killer.

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

As Poong and Eun-woo ride to the docks, Man-bok is led to the execution ground, where Shin-woo stands with a letter in his hands. We don’t know the full content of the letter, but there is a name written on it: Yoo Se-yeob! Eek! Does he know now? If so, that didn’t take as much time as I thought. But I suppose I should be glad that the drama is not dragging out this plotline. I expected to flat out dislike Shin-woo, but surprisingly, I don’t. He’s firm with his ruling as an official, but he’s also willing to give the accused the benefit of doubt as we saw in the sleepwalking case and with Man-bok. Yes, there’s the matter of him being the assassin, and there’s no justification for that, but his crush on Eun-woo aside, I’d like to believe that there are more layers to his character under the cold exterior.

Another layered character is Ji-han, whom we learn more about this week. Underneath his brash and money-loving exterior is a Robin Hood committed to charging the rich a premium for his services in order to treat the common people for next to nothing as fees. And just like Poong, he was once a respected doctor at the medical office until he was fired. He also lost his wife while attempting to treat her, and I’m sure that must have crushed him. It now makes sense as to why he understands Poong so well, and is determined to help him.

Poong The Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

It was really touching to see our clinic family pool their skills to save Man-bok — from Nam-hee distracting the servants in the noble lady’s house with her cooking, to Ib-bun coming up with a sketch of the fiancé (her only talent, lol) thanks to Jang-goon’s memory. There’s also Ji-han giving Poong and Eun-woo pointers in their Operation Save Man-bok plans, and even if it was just chasing Commander Im out of the clinic with her broom, Grandmother also contributed to the cause.

The clinic proves that it’s a place of healing not just for others, but also for its occupants who despite being of different social classes, have come together to become a unique family of their own. And I know that regardless of whatever situation might come their way, as long as they stick together, they can pull through.

Poong the Joseon Psychiatrist: Episodes 3-4

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , , ,

38

Required fields are marked *

Oooph ngl both these episodes dragged for me. Both drew out their murder of the week's (am I the only one who didn't know she was signing up to a murder procedural but set in Joseon...) resolution to the last minute (or not even that in the case of episode 4), and I can't help but wonder how the conversations about run time go down in the studio...

"So you have a new show for me?"
"Yeahp, a B-Tier sageuk, where a Joseon Physician solves Murders!"
"Okay we have a 1:15 slot available on Monday Tuesday."
"Ah."
"Is there a problem?"
"It's just... the story probably would suit a shorter episode run time..."
"You get what you're given."

It's not a good sign for furture episodes, because if I get too bored it'll be an early drop.

7
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

Seriously, there really does seem to be a problem with pacing with dramas like the format is designed for getting in as many advertising opportunities or to suit a schedule rather than to tell a great story. Some stories are so much better when told in 20-45 minute segments over 10-12 weeks.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh yeah, it's been a problem for years.

Used to be worse, so I am thankful we have way more 12 episode dramas at least (the perfect length imo), but the problem of [narrative efficiency] still remains and the goal of telling your story in the best possible way for what your story needs (whether that is short EPs, long EPs, long no. of EPs, mini series, etc etc) is not the priority of stations, channels, producers or even the majority of PDs and writers, and won't be whilst the industry functions the way it does right now. (This is not isolated to just kdramas by the way; this is a problem worldwide, because the goal is not Storytelling itself as a craft, as a whole, and if the motivation and philosophy is wrong it will effect the outcome.)

Personally I think the 1hr, 12-16 episode (6-8 weeks) format of kdramas is actually a very good format, especially for telling a single story in a linear line, as it were.
I don't exactly miss Western shows with 45 mins 25 Episodes and 5 -15 seasons to be perfectly honest, but (with the exception of the 5+ seasons because I am staunchly ANTI multi seasons above about 3 at most, and in general 1 (exceptions not withstanding)) to be sure there would be a place for that format as well- animated shows and procedural shows for example often work really well on the shorter show run time.

I'm not against the general kdrama hr runtime tbh, but I think I'd prefer the shorter side of a hr for most things than what we have a lot of atm, which is 1:10, 1:15, 1:19 etc etc. It can work but you really gotta have a reason for it. (It does not work here.)
.
.
.
And, all this being said, none of this makes a difference if the writer and PD don't know how to pace their story themselves, because that can also be just as much of an issue, as a drama with the wrong time parameters, that they might not have control over.

I'll use my Mystic and Kill It examples again:
Both 12 episode shows at approx 1 hr episodes (I think Mystic was a tad over)
One had the perfect length and the crew knew what they were doing and where they wanted to go and how to get there. A fantastically paced and packaged show.
The other had the right amount of time necessary for the story and the kind of show it was, but flailed through its story, and its strongest episodes were weirdly 7-10. It ended and started badly and wasn't satisfying.
I would never give Kill It more episodes, because that would create things like drag and filler, but it's a good example to use to show just how many moving parts and things there are at play when creating a story for the screen.

2
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think this is so true, what is the purpose of the fiction pieces we watch if it’s not to tell a good story well? Thanks for sharing your expertise in this area. I always wanted to ask what your area is as I can’t work out if it’s screen writing or books or both.

Obviously, I accept it would be a scheduling disaster if everyone did their own random length shows just because 72 minutes was the perfect length!

I also know we all need to learn our trade but maybe it’s about teams being balanced with new and experienced members so they can find that sweet spot. I also wonder about the pre produced shows where people have time to plan and polish.

Back in the day I liked the multiple series like The west wing, Ally McBeal, Suits and ER but they all went rogue at points for multiple reasons like getting caught up in their own success or the actors moved on and other characters just didn’t have the same pull. I stopped watching Ally and Suits quite early.

All this rambling to say because there is a need to fill the schedule, and people need to eat to live sometimes quantity seems to win over quality. The end result can lead to people dropping shows and then all the hard work goes unrecognised and unrewarded. Sometimes there are shows that improve part way through so it is worth hanging in there but I think people are less likely to do that now.

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

"I can’t work out if it’s screen writing or books or both."
Technically, it's both lol.

Preproduced is overrated - too many preproduced shows have been such a let down - all the time in the world and nothing to show for it. Once again pointing to a deeper issue behind just having time and/or resources.

3

@sicarius of course it’s both, multi talented woman that you are. ❤️ It’s a shame I won’t be able to watch/read any of it as it’s too dark and tension inducing for delicate little old me🤣

0

🤣🤣🤣🤣 hey, who says I can't write fluff!!!!! Lmao

2

@sicarius But more importantly, do you you want to?

0

Yes, sometimes, definitely!

2

What does "B tier sageuk" mean?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh that's a good question haha.
I might struggle to explain it pffft.
The way I came up with this term was a typo lmao, but I decided to stick with it cos it made sense to me, but as a result it's not a very fleshed out term yet, and kind of just an impression I get from the range of sageuks 😅.
The original typo was calling Secret Royal Inspector and Joy a D-tier sageuk lmao. Which. It is. 🤭 (dw Bead Boy, I will always love you.)
So if Secret Royal Inspector and Joy is a D-tier sageuk, work up from there lmao 😂😂😂

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

read the recap for episodes 1 and 2 and decided to watch ep 3. it was fun but it didn't get my attention enough to think about watching another 10+ of this story. I think minjae and hyanggi are doing well for their roles, but the story is just not interesting or charming for me. I will have to pass this one.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ep 4 was so draggy for me. Feel like dropping this drama, acting is so so (kim sang kyung n the kid are good, provided some comic relief). Good thing got boar hunting, monday why no good drama.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Show was *almost* pretty good this week, but I find Granny and Commander Im really annoying and they drag it down a lot. Somebody has a very different idea of what is fun than I do.

Does anybody think the medical treatments of the time could have cured stomach cancer any more effectively than talismans?

Little known fact: this show is the result of a frantic rewrite after the rejection of the original script "Poop the Joseon Proctologist". Remember, you saw it on the internet so it must be true.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was with you on the stomach cancer cue spoken as if this was a proven technique and the family were wrong to go for a dodgy alternative.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'd love to see the story of the clinic family. We know about grandma, Poong and Eun Woo while we know a bit about Ji Jan and his daughter, maybe the mother died when giving birth. Jang-goon story maybe related of someone abuse him and Nam-hee who never married still mystery.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am invested in the backstory of the other characters too. I want to know where the cook went for so long, it surely could not have been to source ingredients for their meals. I think Janggoon was rejected because of his Autism or maybe his mum died and no one was able/willing to care for him.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@unit Thanks as always for a great weecap laced with humour… ‘Hence Jang-goon – thanks to his incredibly retentive memory – digs out the records of the patients who visited the clinic the day the sleepwalking girl was loudly diagnosed’ this made me laugh out loud.

As everyone who reads my comments knows I can’t take even the most basic low level tension inducing moments in any drama. I managed to get through episode three but episode four proved too much for me after seeing the preview. So I have just used the recap to stay up to date. If episode 5 continues the trend then I am not going to be able to handle watching it and will be following via the weecap.

So pleased my theory about the Robin Hood approach was correct. I will be surprised if the only reason for helping Poong is their shared history of working in the palace I still think Jihan knew Poong’s dad maybe from training days as they look as if they are of a similar age.

I wonder why they promoted this drama as if it was a light drama whilst it does have its moments it’s not got Mr Queen like humour to keep me going when it goes down the power hungry men/women stop at nothing route. I want to stay because I like the clinic characters and really want to see the development of alternative treatment approaches for mental health.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

😀

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

After the first 2 episodes, I thought the story would be more about psychology. But in these 2 episodes, it was more about murder investigation.

It's not a bad drama but nothing is catching my interest. The second male lead is so cliché.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like the drama. The crimes and their solutions aren't particularly original but I find the clinic's association with them refreshing. I'd like more focus on the clinic's cast of characters and their history - I guess we'll get them eventually the way we did for Grandma.

As for the second lead, he makes me miss Bead Boy, a truly memorable example of the 'adopted son of corrupt minister' trope.

6
9
reply

Required fields are marked *

Bead Boy! My love! He's can never be replaced though (this boy WISHES he had what Bead Boy did!)

4
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was sure that you would react to Bead Boy comment 😂

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

How could I not!!!!! 🤣🤣

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Also apropos of nothing, how much fun was Secret Royal Inspector and Joy? I was kind of hoping this show would be that kind of fun.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I ... have to admit I was hoping this was going to be a fun cracky sageuk also. Alas.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah I'm a bit disappointed I admit. It looked like it was going that kind of cracky fusion Sageuk that last year had quite a few of. But it's not holding my interest.

2

I was thinking of BEAD BOY also as I watched the last two episodes last night but I relate to a different character: (now former) brother-in-law Ho Joon. Ho Joon is being played by Go Geon-han who I think physically resembles SRI&J’s BEAD BOY Park Tae-seo beautifully played by Lee Jae-kyoon. Ho Joon’s character is not similar to our BB.
As a character Shin-woo’s adopted son is probably closer to BB.
With that being said at this point I don’t see Shin-woo being set up to get run through the back with a sword but I would warn Shin-woo to ‘watch your back’ and please don’t go over to the dark side.

Also this has annoyed me since the last scene in episode two when Poong and Eun-woo bumped into Shin-woo for the first time and she addressed him as “Shin-woo! Orebeoni! At first I was confused and thought it was her actual older brother.
Did single women in 17th century Joseon do their own version of the modern use of the term ‘oppa’? I have a feeling the answer is no but I wonder if someone knows the answer to that?

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes I saw the resemblance with the brother-in-law too. I do think Shin-woo would have a tragic end if he really is the assassin of Poong's dad. Perhaps not 'run through with sword' tragic though lol.

I have definitely heard Orabeoni frequently in sageuks even when the people are not blood-related. I think In-woo's character in Mr. Queen was addressed that way for instance. But the use of the name + orabeoni did sound off to me too in this instance.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just checked Lee Jae-kyoon's Asianwiki and he hasn't been in anything this year. He was so good in SRI&J.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Still enjoying the show and so far I haven't been bored (unlike again with the last episodes of Alchemy of Souls).

I am most interested in the residents of the clinic, although the grandmother sometimes gets on my nerves.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

These episodes dragged for me. Commander Im is also an aggravating factor along with small things like people doing high fives (was that a thing in the Joseon era? Maybe it was but it seemed out of place) I enjoyed last week's episodes so I'm somewhat disappointed this week. I'll keep going for another while, as I keep this for my Wednesday night viewing, but it needs to pick up.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Kim Hyung-mook who is Commander Im plays these shady characters quite well but I think in POONG he is a bit over the top.
Lol when Im was was laying it on thick to Poong to come over to his side I was hoping Kim Min-jae as Poong would go into full Moo-hak (DALI) mode and tell him to shove it. Alas he remained in Poong character and quietly took his leave.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

The episodes for this are too long, for no reason. However, I continue to enjoy the relationship of the leads. He seems like a good teacher and she a willing student. I have said this before, but I really appreciate that she is so smart and acts like it.

7
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Re episodic length that is tvN for you. With all due respect to PRISON PLAYBOOK (2017/2018) (Netflix US) which I loved I probably wouldn’t sit though again a 16 episode drama with each episode running 90 minutes.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dramas where writer Lee Woo-jung is involved definitely call for a strong editor. Hospital Playlist Season 2 had a total run time of 20 hours for only 12 episodes!

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Less episodes, but the episode lengths are so long and draggy. Still like the main leads and I like the clinic family so I'll keep going. I was/am waiting for Nam Hee and Man Bok to fall for each other.

I hope the show moves towards mental health issues. I wasn't expecting all the murder mysteries.

I've seen Kim Hyung Mook in a lot of roles recently. I wish he got to play a character that wasn't corrupt/shady/evil.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love historical mysteries/procedurals, but I feel a little irked that I was expecting something that is more light, warm, and slice-of-life medical drama, but it ends up hitting similar beats as many fusion sageuks.

I do like our clinic characters and how they're pretty much turning into your usual police team - detective, medical examiner, forensic artist, the brawny cop, etc. And that one rule-stickler person outside of the core group.

Kim Min-jae and Kim Hyang-gi in sageuk-wear visually looks so really cute together. Especially when they look furtively around the corner.

I agree that the pacing is a little off. I dislike how episode 4 ended in a cliffhanger (that isn't much of a cliffhanger; yes, Man-bok will be saved) after spending over an hour on the case.

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *