35

The Worst of Evil: Episode 1 (First Impressions)

Disney+’s crime noir The Worst of Evil has premiered, and so far, it’s a lot of high-vibe style sacrificed for not a lot of substance. That being said, it still has time to redeem itself (please, please) and actually weave the intricate tale of identity that it promised — if it stops ignoring that little thing called character development.

Editor’s note: This is an Episode 1 review only. For a place to chat about the entire drama, visit the Drama Hangout.
 
EPISODE 1

My disappointment over Episode 1 of The Worst of Evil was palpable. This might be partially my own fault, though, since I’ve spent all of its promotional cycle expecting a character-rich noir with blurred lines culminating in a test of loyalty a la Heartless City. Instead, Episode 1 of this drama was, in my estimation, all blood spatter and no actual heart. Because blood-spatter violence without a story to feed it is just violence for violence’s sake.

The drama opens with an extremely violent gang fight in a building hallway somewhere. Because we’re being dropped into the middle of this fight, we don’t know what’s at stake, but we can feel it in the air. Our hero PARK JOON-MO (Ji Chang-wook) locks eyes with a woman (Im Se-mi) who’s somehow found herself in the middle of this bloodbath and there is a lot of emotion between them. The music soars. Our hero reinvigorates and is ready to cut some more throats. It’s quite a thing, being dropped by a story into Level 10 intensity, but it’s meant to show us the fever pitch to which things will (eventually) climb.

The Worst of Evil: Episode 1 (First Impressions)

From there, we jump two years in the past and we meet a calmer version of our hero and the woman from the fight. She’s YOO EUI-JUNG, and they’re a cute married couple. But while she’s climbing the ranks (and comes from a family of rank-climbing police), Joon-mo is floundering and unable to get his promotion. We see one particular scene with our couple at Eui-jung’s family’s house, where our hero is needlessly belittled. It’s literally the only characterization we have for Joon-mo at this point, so we have to take it, and assume that he feels inadequate and that that emotion will spur his future decisions.

Concurrent to sad Joon-mo is our other hero JUNG KI-CHUL (Wie Ha-joon). He was also present during the opening fight so we know he’s going to be important, but his storyline doesn’t connect to Joon-mo’s till the very end of the episode. Instead, we spend way too much screen time showing Ki-chul’s rise from nightclub DJ (strangely hilarious), to thug, to brutal druglord with a strong sense of brotherhood — and territory.

The Worst of Evil: Episode 1 (First Impressions)

You would think since Ki-chul’s genesis story took up most of our episode we would feel like we have some insight on his character, or feel committed to his quest to aggregate power, but sadly the script falls utterly flat here. While touting the brotherhood between him and the neighborhood boys who comprise his posey, it’s impossible to actually feel that brotherhood. I mean, Wie Ha-joon has a crazy good screen presence, and I believe his character is who they tell me he is, but I feel nothing. And if this world of violence and crime is going to do anything, it had better make us feel something along the way.

Soon, Ki-chul is ruling his turf with an iron fist and the drugs coming in and out of Gangnam become a top priority for the Seoul police. They know this requires a special operation, so they decide they need an undercover cop to infiltrate so they can destroy this crime ring from the inside out. Joon-mo is quickly chosen, being both wild enough and desperate enough to rise in the ranks, and Ji Seung-hyun quickly fetches and convinces him. It’s a little too easy, and again, the only things we know about Joon-mo is that he’s a) tired of being looked down on and b) smoking hot. Okay, that last one might be subjective, but seeing a gritty Ji Chang-wook in a t-shirt planning his op was probably the part of this episode I most enjoyed.

The Worst of Evil: Episode 1 (First Impressions)

Sacrificing character development for plot speed, Joon-mo slides into his undercover operation quite fast, and we don’t really see much inside his character. He learns his cover and puts his acting skills to work — somehow intuiting that he has to be even more of a crazy dog than Ki-chul is in order to win his trust and join the pack.

The two actors are excellent in their first (brief) scene together, and the intensity is super high. But kind of like all the posturing we see happening in the gangster world — where appearing powerful is almost more important than being powerful — that’s actually how I feel about this drama as a whole. It appears gritty and intense, but when you step away, you realize there’s actually nothing giving depth to the story, and that’s where my disappointment stems from. If I’m to care about Joon-mo’s descent into darkness and all the things he’s made to do there — and how his wifey gets involved — I need to know who he is first, and what matters to him.

Speaking of style over substance, the drama does have sharp style. It’s a convincing step back into seedier times, and it’s beautifully shot — purposefully gritty and realistic. I mean, they even manage to make blood spatter and cigarette smoke look poetic (as it should in a noir). But, it might just be me, but when I see poetic blood spatter or cigarette smoke, I want more poetry involved in the actual story. Don’t make the violence and grime purely visceral, but give me something more going on under the surface — this drama should be capable of doing that in spades.

I don’t know why the crime-action genre of late seems to be sacrificing story at the altar of flashiness, but it disappoints me. I think it’s possible to do both — visceral in-your-face action and deep storytelling — and I still have hope that this drama might pull it together in subsequent episodes — but only if it can take a step back from it’s ~vibe~ and peer into its characters a bit more. The world-building is there, and it’s solid. Now, we just need the characters to come to life as they populate it.

The Worst of Evil: Episode 1 (First Impressions)

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , ,

35

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap missvictrix.
I hear and agree with you.
I'm not a fan of bloody violence, sometimes less is more as I think it makes it more impactful.
Hopefully now the show has set the story up and we get the vibe it won't be as prevalent otherwise I will just be ffing through those bits.
The characters at this stage do feel a bit 2 dimensional but again as the story goes on we should get more layers.
Who knew though this was a lead combination I needed, they have a lot of chemistry and are fabulous in scenes together.
JCW is amazing with the little he has to work with so far and this seems like a great role for him.
I'm really enjoying the way it is filmed with the dark, grittiness.
It's nice to have male leads who are not groomed to perfection and covered in makeup, it makes it feel more real.
Looking forward to the next episode.

13
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I also wanted to add that I thought the smoking was overdone, it became very repetitive. I get the vibe and don’t need to be hit over the head about it.

12
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wasn't bothered by the smoking as it's expected in a noir, but I minded how wasteful all the characters were. They would light a cigarette, take at most two puffs, then throw the butt on the ground.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

To 🚬 or not 🚭

I guess they were caught between trying to smoke to look cool and doing an anti-smoking psa.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Every time the thugs shouted, "다 조져라! (Kill them all!)," I would sing Bibi's "가서 조져라" from "Law". ("Imma break it down like only I can do, Bitches talk shit, but they never come through.")

Moving Episodes 10-11 really prepared me for the opening violent gang fight. I kept wondering how Joon-mo could keep his undercover operation a secret from his wife. Does he never go home at night? This drama is really keeping Ki-chul mysterious (or just one-dimensional) because we really don't get his perspective.

DJ Ki-chul was strangely hilarious, and I wasn't sure if the superstar whom he greeted was supposed to be important or not. Jong-ryeol's character was also not fully explained why he suddenly joined hands with Ki-chul's Gangnam Union and became his loyal bodyguard.

The setting doesn't really feel like the 90s to me.

4
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

The Naver dictionary defines ‘조지다’, the verb as:
1. (마구 때리거나 혼을 내다) beat sb up, (informal) beat sb to a pulp, (Brit) beat sb to a jelly
반항하는 놈은 모두 조져 버려!
Beat up everyone who goes[rebels] against you!
2. (망치다) mess up, (informal) screw up
신세를 조지다
screw up one's life
——-==
Do you know if it is also intended to mean “to kill”?
ps - obviously, to beat someone to a pulp, could mean to kill them but not necessarily. As ‘죽이다’ means to kill, I am curiius.

Thanks.

5
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's just slang. Our good guys shouted back, "다 죽여!"

4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not very analytical but I swear one of the thoughts that came to mind when watching all 3 episodes was "how can all this action feel so boring"? I figured it was just me and my apathetic self which is why I continued on even though I thought that way after the first episode then the second and finally the third.

The first episode, the first scene, made me chuckle because all I could think was the folks behind this wanted to take full advantage of this being a foreign streaming project (I don't know if it also airs on Korean stations/channels like how Vagabond and Extraordinary Attorney Woo aired on Netflix as well as SBS & ENA respectively) but the instant (and I think graphic though less graphic than Song of the Bandits if memory serves) violence just screamed that to me.

I didn't know what to expect and I guess I don't know what noir is but "noir" brings to my mind an idea of sleek and sexy. The style, the vibe. Maybe it's just personal taste but I didn't feel that way watching this. I think the most "noir" thing is all the smoking. Maybe it's because I'm so used to the "wholesome" Korean image pushed that it is always so weird and jarring seeing stuff like people doing hard drugs or being junkies in Korean media (I don't even like watching that stuff in American media). It's like they can DO that?! (sidenote: I don't really *like* or want the wholesome image, I'm just saying that I'm used to it)
And then we have the obligatory belittling of people due to their job, rank, comparison to others, and chauvinism. Seriously, it's like how to hate people in 10 minutes or less.

I thought Wie Ha Joon's character was the most interesting and I was looking forward to him fighting back. Again, that was a thought going through my mind "oh, I can't wait til he fights back" as I was watching the scenes because he's a lead character and that meant there weren't any real stakes here (to me).

I'm sensitive to the child being penalized for the sins of the parents so that added another layer of annoyance for me.

I have no idea if I'll continue this.

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Maybe, they knew that not many people like gangster stories and dropped 3 episodes at once which is a smart move, but without the thrill of the chase Ep 1 ended up being ordinary. If they are going to drop us into an intense fight scene, then they should have gone back to show us the stake at play instead of slowing the pace with gangster fights one after another. Drop! @missvictrix thanks for first impressions.

4
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The first scene looked more like a zombie attack with blood everywhere than a battle between humans.

I'm tired by dramas that put violence like their selling card and forget the rest.

My only interest for now, it's the trio of actors. I like the 3 of them and I hope they will be able to shine in this chaos.

11
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am not a fan of violence so wantec to check recap first.

Is Ji Chang Wook's lack of discern regarding scripts could be a reason behind this strange start?

Btw, this is how I had felt while watching 'For the Emperor' - lots of senseless violence and sex without having any character rich story to connect to is just that - lots of sex and violence. They tell us what they are supposed to think and feel and bingo, you are disconnected.

8
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It was fine, but I do agree we don't know these characters. Stories like this with short episode count and the need to get to a point are better off being linear storylines. It makes it easier to understand character motivations and understand the characters themselves, but that may just be my bias.

11
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

- I must be having some underlying issues I need to address, because while I flinch and stop episodes when romantic tension is too high, I have zero difficulties watching scenes of violence.

- With that said, the show is fun. I am grateful to director for not making me watch Wie Ha Joon with 90s kpop hair styling, one long earring and t-shirt with panthera pattern. That's where I draw the line. Wie Ha Joon looks great in suit and every show that takes advantage of dressing him in black had a great success so far.

- By episode three, I loved all the characters. They are all well written and even the fl, who had a very small screen time, seems like a strong addition to the cast. I would have no complaints to the show, if only she doesn't get killed to advance the guys character growth.

- Probably because I don't take the show too seriously, I am having fun imagining Gicheol setting everyone in one straight line, for himself to walk dramatically in the front center.

- At least here, I am glad the director lets their cast exist without tons of makeup or blurry filter (*side eyeing Destined With You*. Have you seen Jo Boah and Rowoon? Why do they need any of that? They are not cartoon characters, they don't need so much colouring)

18
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm with you. For what it is, I'm also enjoying it so far and the violence doesn't bother me because it's not real blood, real wounds, real death. I can understand and even agree mostly with the criticism--too much action without enough characterization to care deeply about the characters--but I think it's a matter of small degress of emphasis and personal preference. If there hadn't been such violence, some could legitimately criticize it for not setting enough of a dark mood. For me, the first three episodes have me caring enough about the main three characters that I'm already nervous about the what will happen when everything is eventually exposed. I'm nervous because I know that extreme pain and even death are real possibilities and almost inevitabilities in the dangerous world of gangs. No set-up is perfect and no set-up is going to please everyone. For me, it's set up well enough that I want to find out what will happen.

7
reply

Required fields are marked *

it's hilarious that JBA looked better in the high school and Joseon flashbacks, as did Rowoon in the latter. They're already gorgeous people, they don't need that much makeup T-T

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

And the scene when she did the perfect skin spell. You couldn't tell whether it worked because the show has been blurring her skin.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is on hold for me after the first episode. At the end, as JCW and WJH stared intensely at each other, I wondered, in a rather disinterested way, if they leaned a little closer, would they kiss? They won't, and even if they did, it wasn't reason enough to watch the next episode. Shame.

Will there be recaps or hangouts? @missvictrix It'd help me decide if I should pick this up again.

5
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

I note that the "Next Post" listed below is a WoE Hangout...so, what path does that set you on, Indy?

3
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh. Bummer. I guess a combo of reports from trusted Beanies in the hangout and my IRL drama buddy to judge if I should resume. However, she is such a JCW fangirl I'd rather trust DB. What about you?

3
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

My plan is to wait for them all to drop and then skim FOR the scenes of violence.

3
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think we should ask you for gifs for this - should we?

Or maybe some Marie Claire style gifs of Ji Chang-wook and Wie Ha Joon

4

Ha! If I do the same, let's make a bet who'll finish faster. The person who ffwds all the violent scenes, or the one who watches only for the violent ones. I have a feeling I might win. It only took me half hour to watch the last three episodes of Moving minus the violence.

6

So what I'm getting is that we were robbed of a JCW and WJH enemies-to-lovers BL drama?

6
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

😂 Hard to be sure this early, but I reckon we'll be robbed of everything except blood and smoke.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ji Chang-wook ... Suspicious Partner was way back in 2017, give us something where we can root for you buddy!

5
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

PS - Young Actors Retreat does not count where he was cooler IRL.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

PPS - Annarasumanara ⚡ 🌟 🎩

Here's a magic spell to make you shine and glow in your roles.

Please Ji Chang-wook ... hwaiting!

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Nothing special but JCW sure as shit shouldn't have stopped doing action, and the leads have great chemistry, which will keep me watching for now.

9
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm partial to the noir genre, and to JCW and WHJ as well. But sadly after watching 3 episodes, it feels like they might have been miscast here. JCW fares a bit better in his portrayal, but really neither actors brings any of the edge/grit that is needed for their character arcs/motivations to resonate for me.

I'm hoping these are just early pains, and both actors settle into their characters in the coming episodes.

On the positive side, WHJ looks delicious in suits, JCW with his crew-cut, and together they have enough chemistry to inspire their own BL-spinoff.

7
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It is clear that no one truly appreciates the violence displayed and glorified. I recently heard an interview with a former Dreamworks employee who resigned because of the constant and total social engineering put into every recent film and series.

I hope that Korea does not let itself be influenced too much by the USA, in recent years I have become convinced that we should look to China, at least when it comes to entertainment. You can notice how in Chinese shows (and partly also in Korea) evil is often punished and never justified. And in any case there aren't as many violent shows as in the West.

6
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap. I really wish to see a recap for the other 4 eps that have been out so far.
Based on the whole 5 eps, I would say this series impressed me with its fast pace with rich plots, subtle and intense interactions amongst characters, beautiful cinematography and soundtrack. The acting skills of the whole cast are very good, especially Ji Changwook's emotional acting in the 4th ep funeral scene. As it sits in the noir crime action category, people should expect lots of fighting scenes. So those violence scenes do justice for me as the production team made them look so real and emotionally powerful.
The flow of the story is full of surprises to me, raising questions such as who the characters really are, are they good or bad, what do they really know? What are their motives? After watching ep 4 and 5, I believe that the series is getting more and more interesting, I can't wait to see the future episodes..

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is madness. She gave up her necklace and he gave up his ring. What do these mean?

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is crazy. Can’t say I like the ending. By now Jun-mo realises how much Gi-cheul loves Eui-jeong that he was willing to give up his drug business in order to live like an ordinary guy so as to be with her. But he loves his wife too, just as much. But why? Why?

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *