25

[Hey, that’s me] Villain edition

By pogo

“They say a hero is only as good as his villain” – Mark Hamill

There’s nothing quite as potent as a sympathetic or interesting villain to make me feel strongly about a story, especially when I understand where they’re coming from. But it’s an entirely different level of compelling when the villain comes from a place I’ve actually been in myself, which is what happened with Kwon Soo-ah (played by Chae Soo-bin), the main antagonist of 2015’s Sassy Go Go.

Part of why I rooted so hard for that character had a lot to do with the excellent writing and acting bringing Soo-ah to vivid, occasionally infuriating, slightly pitiful life. The other part stemmed from war flashbacks to my own years in the pressure cooker of being a teenage girl under massive pressure to live up to academic expectations – expectations which, like Soo-ah, I constantly fell short of, and which made her story hit uncomfortably close to home at times.

Much like Soo-ah, my teenage self lived in an environment that encouraged me to see the marks on my report card as the marker for my self-worth at any given point in time. We aren’t exactly alike, of course. For starters, my parents weren’t complete monsters, and I was nowhere near the top of my high school class, forget being ranked second. But the crushing weight of disappointment and feeling like you’re not good enough by the only standards that matter? I know that all too well. Which is why it’s hard for me to look at her without a pang of sadness for, not only the ways in which an intelligent and hardworking teenage girl is constantly reminded by the people she looks to for guidance, that she only amounts to the sum of her class ranking and her mother’s plans for her to get into an Ivy League college, but also the ways in which she’s encouraged to distance herself from her friends who don’t have that toxic mindset.

She ends up pushed to a point where ignoring or actively skewing her moral compass in pursuit of her mother’s approval seems like a good idea even as it makes her so miserable and angry that she turns into a monster who can barely stand her own life as she knows it. It’s commonplace for university-bound students to have actual strategies on how to get into their chosen colleges, particularly if they have family money easing their way (as the recent US college-admissions scandal shows, this can be done by fair means or foul). But it’s still a little heartbreaking to me to see an onscreen portrayal of a seventeen-year-old whose entire life is lived for the sole purpose of forming the perfect college application. Literally the only thing the poor girl does solely for herself, and not to use in her all-consuming mission to get into college…is smoke!

That doesn’t mean that Soo-ah doesn’t do terrible things, or that I can identify with the worst of her impulses, which usually involved hurting anyone who stood in the way of her goals. But I can certainly see why she had those impulses in the first place, since watching Soo-ah’s spiral into ever-worsening isolation and misery felt like watching the human equivalent of a thin glass beaker being filled with boiling water – you knew she was bound to crack, and hard. The mixture of wistfulness and envy as she watches her best friends Yeon-doo (whom she hasn’t yet alienated as collateral damage in her pursuit of the #1 rank) goof around with a mother who’s nowhere near as demanding as Soo-ah’s own? I’ve felt that look on my own face at her age. The feeling of living an entire life as if there was no more purpose to it than getting into the “right” college…with her mother having decided what the “right” college was? The increasing isolation and inability to admit the severity of the strain on her to even her closest friends, for fear of being thought vulnerable and weak? Those too.

In all fairness, I should say this – education is important, and an enormous gift to those of us who get to pursue it. That doesn’t mean that educational systems, and the expectations attached by some parents to the young people in their care, can’t be terrible. Privileged though they may be, the Soo-ahs of this world don’t deserve to suffer that.

It was a commonly-held opinion at the time of airing that the drama’s resolution for Soo-ah let her off too lightly, and that she really shouldn’t have been forgiven after all she’d done (quick recap: setting up her best friend to get into trouble and snitching on her, blackmailing a student over his self-harming, encouraging another friend to file a false report for sexual harassment, framing yet another student for cheating, shoving her by-now-ex best friend down a staircase in a fit of temper…and that’s not even the full list). But the heart of Sassy Go Go was the idea that friendship and genuine caring could help even the most far-gone of young people in a toxic system, as long as they realised it before it was too late.

Allowing Soo-ah to self-destruct, or shunning her as an absolute villain at the end, would have gone against everything the drama was about, especially after her own regret and shame over her actions caused her to have a major breakdown. It was Soo-ah’s friends and classmates who ultimately save her by allowing her to earn her redemption after they see what she’s been going through. Even if it’s conditional on her mending her ways and proving worthy of their trust, it’s far kinder to her than the oppressive weight of expectations she’s been living with. And it’s that forgiveness, and the kindness it took for the kids of Sevit High School to have it, that gives me hope for all the kids out there who are some version of past me or Soo-ah, to not buckle under the weight of what they’re supposed to achieve. And that’s something I will always be in favour of – there’s nothing quite like a reformed villain, after all.

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags:

25

Required fields are marked *

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

An excellent write up, fellow beanie! Your words resonate with my teenage years experiences so much. The community where I come from all consist of such families: somewhat in the middle of the socioeconomic strata, parents who regard their children as nothing more than an investment and a possession to show others off, like one shows off their fancy cars and luxurious villas. I am immensely grateful to my parents for providing me with the gift of education, but this gift came at a great cost. Maybe that's why I can relate to the school dramas so much. The bone crushing academic expectations feels relatable on a spiritual level.

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Funnily enough, most school-set kdramas DON'T seem to acknowledge studying/grades as a primary part of going to school, or a thing that comes with expectations attached. 9 times out of 10 they're romances or bullying stories, or someone's doing music stuff or running away to be a loan shark...school is just an incidental setting.

And even where studies are mentioned at all, everyone is either naturally a straight-A student, or a slacker, or studying itself is completely inconsequential for them - Sky Castle is one of the very few other dramas that deals in detail with kids and their academic lives. I actually loved Sassy Go Go so much because it actually went there with Soo-ah and showed the WORK that goes into trying to achieve those results. Not many dramas do that, probably because studying itself is a rather unglamorous activity even if it's the one thing all teens have to do.

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH.

Pogo I LOVE YOU. But I love my best baby Kwon Soo-ah the most. THANK YOU FOR WRITING THIS ODE TO SOOAH.

I love her so much. She suffers so so so much. And you can see how she comes to hate her life and the world and herself a little more every day. And I wish she weren't so relatable, not to me, nor to you. But alas.

Kwon Soo-ah's story is a reminder to not forget about the present as you prepare for the future. Happiness right now is important as well and everyone has the right to enjoy their lives.

I love her so so much.

In less capable hands Soo-ah could've been a terrible villain (and she did do terrible things), but Chae Soobin made me feel for her and love her the most.

I love this entry so much I will never shut up about my hardworking baby Kwon Soo-ah who suffers the most.

7
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm glad to find another beanie who gets Kwon Soo-ah!

I love the character, she's possibly my favourite kdrama villain ever. She may be a rich brat, but the kid is so desperate to win her mother's approval, and suffers so much in the course of chasing it. I too, wish this wasn't the character that was so relatable to me, but here we are, I just couldn't hate her because it was so clear just what was driving her to behave so awfully and it wasn't just malice.

And the writing and acting is SO good - Chae Soo-bin doesn't really need words to show us Soo-ah's slowly dying inside, one of my favourite parts is the little flicker of strain on her face when we see her first meeting her mother in episode 1. It's such a small thing, but that one expression and situation is enough to tell you this girl really takes her mother's criticism to heart ..... and has been for a while now.

3
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I also loved the stark contrast between how Sooah was in front of her classmates and in front of her mom. She was such a sweet vulnerable truly happy child who just wanted her moms love in the scene she got the handbag. And her demeanor and personality changes completely once she believes its over - shes more vulnerable, she speaks more tenderly and all of the panic and stress and malice is gone from her face. I love Chae Soobin.

Kwon Sooahs story is one of my favourite things of all time.

2
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

The scene with the handbag was so sad to me - poor kid was so happy to get a kind word and some acknowledgement from her mother for once, meanwhile her mother's attitude to it was like she was giving a dog a treat for learning a new trick. I think that was part of what made it so sad for me - Soo-ah isn't naturally a rebel, she just wants to feel acknowledged as a good daughter.

1
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Exactly! It was very sad. You see how, despite the monstrous things she's doing, she's really just a little kid who wants her mom to love her, even if just a little bit. What she wants is so simple. It's heartbreaking.

1

I think that's one of the great things about Sassy Go Go - it spends enough time on parent-child relationships for you to really get why these kids are the way they are.

Like Soo-ah and Ha-Joon both have abusive parents, and it's so easy to see the effects of that on the respective kids. Soo-ah's mother might never raise a hand against her, but what she does is clear-cut emotional abuse, especially the bits where she orders Soo-ah to distance herself from the other kids.

Meanwhile, you've got Ha-Joon who has a physically abusive father who beats him up over grades... no surprise the kid has a hair-trigger temper and an inclination to express himself in violent ways. Though at least his dad doesn't poison his mind against his friends, which is why he has one actual person he allowed himself to think of as a friend. Unlike poor Soo-ah.

(Seriously, if we can have sympathy for serial killers in drama recaps, a scared and anxious teenage girl deserves our compassion too)

3

Both Soo-ah and Ha-Joon were raised with a really warped sense of reality. It's hard to blame them for doing the wrong things when they've been taught right is wrong and wrong is right their whole lives. By the people they should be able to trust the most.

Soo-ah was working so so hard and suffering so so much yet she was unhappy. And you could see from the very start that it killed her to see people who didn't put in that amount of effort get to be happy. And somehow she didn't deserve to have that.

It was so painful to see how jealous Soo-ah was of Yeon-du's world and how miserable being around her happiness made her. But at the same time, it was also Yeon-du and people like her that showed Soo-ah that the world she lived in and her life wasn't the only way, and I bet it's her friendship (be it barely genuine at first, though I believe she did enjoy being friends with Yeon-du) that kept Soo-ah human and made it possible for her to ask for forgiveness.

Soo-ah makes me want to cry. So much. The most hardworking most miserable most everything BABY who just needs to be loved.

I have so many words and not enough words.

2

I could see myself in Soo Ah too. Sometimes the urge to sabotage in retaliation did occur to me, & I empathised with her a little bit.
When you're constantly taught that the people you're with don't matter & it's all a competition with only you not taking things seriously, it chips away at you bit by bit.

Glad you found your footing pogo.

4
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

It really does chip away at you, especially when it's the benchmark for your life. Soo-ah was clearly developing major mental health problems as a result of the stress, and her being encouraged to see her friends as competition or pawns, didn't help.

I did eventually find my footing, I suppose.... by completing my degree. It's a relief to be out from that environment.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I absolutely adore Sassy Go Go to pieces, to the moon and back, all of that shebang, and I would write a million essays on it, because it's just so good.

I personally never felt that Soo Ah was let off "lightly"; the overwhelming guilt and regret of her own actions and self deprecation were enough of a punishment, and that was the whole point. This girl had suffered enough, by the system, by her mother, and by her own hand, and she needed grace and forgiveness from her friends, and from herself, to move forward.

Allowing Soo-ah to self-destruct, or shunning her as an absolute villain at the end, would have gone against everything the drama was about

This.
Sassy Go Go continues to have one of the best redemption arcs in kdrama ever (fight me it's true), and I love that it is just as much Soo Ah's story as it is anyone else's.

Bravo pogo!!! Thank you for sharing!!

12
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

What are you talking about it is Soo-ahs story first and foremost.

Im kidding. Kindof.

3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm so glad to find Soo-ah appreciation in this thread! Not because I identify with her, but she's genuinely a well-drawn and three-dimensional character, and honestly I love that her arc is all about HER problems and not some love interest thing (in fact, I really appreciate that boys as a romantic interest, are a total non-factor in Yeon-doo and Soo-ah's relationship and antagonism).

And you are right that Soo-ah's biggest punishment was facing the ugly truth of what she'd done. Also about the redemption arc (I also think Sassy Go Go is one of the best high school dramas ever, period - anyone who disagrees can fight me too!).

5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lovely write-up @pogo1. I too loved Sassy Go Go and wanted a good redemption arc for Soo Ah.

Thanks for sharing and I'm glad it was a more positive experience for you, 'growing up' with the burden of others' hopes and expectations weighing you down. I wonder sometimes if because I don't like the attitude of Soo Ah's mum and what she and other drama parents like her do to their kids, I may have gone too far in the other direction. But I want, and I want my children to know, that they are happy as students, that the desire to do well comes from within and that they can manage well without the external pressure from a parent. In the end, a formal school education is only up to a point and they have to choose to continue to learn through life while loving it.

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Truthfully, I got off lightly compared to some of my peers/kids I know, and I also know my parents meant well according to their own value system. That's why it's so hard - at the heart of it, these parents don't mean their children harm. They just think that it's important to push them to perform, for the sake of their own futures/to secure those futures. Meanwhile, the poor kids end up feeling like they're on a hamster wheel, sometimes even if parents are supportive, schools and colleges can be awful about this sort of thing.

Frankly, I think that as long as you value the skills and abilities your kids actually enjoy developing and don't make everything about measuring up to a standard, they will be fine.

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

This was a fantastic write-up, @pogo1! It made me feel kind of emotional and misty-eyed 🥺

I come from a society that, hasn't gone as far as South Korea, but isn't all that far off when it comes to the education system and the astronomical expectations that are loaded onto the shoulders of students, nation-wide. For some young people, that can be extremely damaging, and it's heart-breaking to see them isolated and questioning their sense of self-worth.

Here's to forgiveness—forgiving our friends (of course, maybe not everyone is deserving all the time) and forgiving ourselves, because sometimes it's important that we do that too ❤️

Also, side note but I was just thinking of Sassy Go Go the other day because Yeondoo's mum and Yeol's dad are none other than our Queen Dowager and Vice Premier Min Ikpyeong from Rookie Historian. Funny how they were so in love in Sassy Go Go, and total enemies in Rookie Historian!

3
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel like a lot of kids in Asian countries will have similar stories, even if their own systems aren't as extreme as the Korean one - the busiest time for suicide helplines in my country since as long as I can remember, has always been school/university exam season. That's not a coincidence.

And the weight of expectations is real, even in some cases from parents who convince themselves they "don't care what other people think" but still insist their child MUST go to engineering/medical school Or Else. Don't even get me started on the contradictory messages from schools here - they might preach to the kids' faces that "marks don't matter", but still end up with kids feeling like they're morally defective or just plain defective for not doing well enough, when the real issue is lack of support for students.

Here's to forgiveness and eventual healing!

2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ah, Pogo! I've missed you. And how fitting it is to find you on a Sassy Go Go post.

I remember how we used to spazz and squee in the recaps, and all the insightful, poignant commentary it drew. Good times.

I loved your write up. I still go on Sassy Go Go rewatchs from time to time. In fact, I think I just may go on one, this night. LOVE!

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for this excellent write-up. I loved this drama, and I loved Soo-ah's arc in it.

"...the crushing weight of disappointment and feeling like you’re not good enough by the only standards that matter? I know that all too well."

I know this feeling too. It took me years to unlearn this and remind myself that my worth was more than just the letters and numbers that were decided by someone else. Like the kids in Sassy Go Go I went to a school where most of the kids were really smart. I attended this school my entire life (so ~15 years). Unlike a lot of South Asian parents, my parents were happy with me if I got B's or even the occasional C so long as they knew I tried my hardest. Yet, despite this supportive home life, I didn't become a Yean-do, I became a Soo-ah (well, minus the maliciousness). I felt like a failure most of the time. It ate away at my self-esteem and I felt like I had nothing to offer, so I often didn't speak up or out, even when I did have ideas. I stayed in a shell because I believed I had nothing to offer. It was likely because I was in an environment where we joked that "A B+ is a failing grade". Imagine that when you're a solid B student...so, yeah. And the thing is, no one meant this maliciously. No one really knew my grades or even cared. But for some reason I internalized them so much. It was only after I graduated and went to university that I realized I was ahead of the curve in many respects. Being a solid B student at a school of incredibly smart people is not bad. (Not that I'm a genius.)

I think that once I realized that my worth isn't measurable in letters and numbers but by what you put out in the universe, my whole outlook changed. I was able to unlearn that habit and embrace failure and rejection. I learned that those things are never about me not being good enough, but rather that it's about me needing to keep learning, to keep getting better. It's OK to fail, it's good to fail. I stopped feeling a pit in my stomach when I failed. I stopped retreating into my hole of self-loathing. What mattered was the kind of person I was and whether I strove to be better. And getting better requires failures.

I'd like to say I learned this habit in university, but sadly this was a lesson that I only learned a few years ago after I'd finished all my schooling. It took a massive failure and essentially shutting down to finally change the way I saw myself. But ever since I did, I learned to ignore my worst instincts when that voice tries to speak out in my head.

I think that's why I loved Soo-ah so much in this drama. I wasn't the top student, but I was going through that same breakdown. And the thing that helped me was that I still had the people who cared about me around me and supporting me even when I thought I was unworthy of it. Soo-ah needed that too, and even if the ending was a bit too pat for some, I thought it was well earned.

3
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Soo-ah had such a well-written arc and Chae Soo-bin brought her character to life perfectly. My heart hurt for her with every poor decision she made because she was just a kid who was put under so much pressure that she felt she had no other choice. And you could tell how much it hurt her too. I probably cried more at the video her friends made for her than at any outright sad scene in any other show. Thanks for sharing @pogo1

2
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Aww i love this, reformed villain is definitely intriguing and interesting when done right...unfortunately I felt like in Sassy Go Go it was hard for me to feel for Sooah at times, however I'll admit my eyes produced tears during the scene of her ultimate breakdown when she let herself go to that very dark place that one shouldn't allow themselves to go to...I actually recently finished Sassy Go Go, it definitely dealt with really dark themes with an optimistic hopeful tone

i personally didn't relate to the amount of pressure that Sooah felt from her mom but I do have parents who highly valued education and didn't really let me take sick days from school for any slight headache or stomachache as my friends seemed to do. My parents were relatively happy with the success I had in school and didn't push me too far other than talk of wanting me to be a doctor or whatever which I did not achieve. Yet I did achieve a college degree and that was ultimately enough for them and most importantly it was enough for myself.

1
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Attempted murder and blackmailing a person with already fragile mind isn't too late for you?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

No.

And she's a person with an already fragile mind too, which you may have noticed if you watched the drama.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *